find and fix common errors in finding slope, y-intercepts and unit rates, including lines that fall.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. A student counted 15 seconds between lightning and thunder and wrote “15 × 5 = 75 miles away.” Is that reasonable?
What does the reading say that proves 75 miles is wrong?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Good detectives check. A slope answer should make sense in the story and match the graph. Today we study five common mistakes so they stay out of our consumer guide.
Mistake 1: run over rise. For the line through (0, 0) and (4, 2), a student writes slope = 4 ÷ 2 = 2. The rise is 2 and the run is 4, so slope = 2 ÷ 4 = 0.5. Check: the line climbs slowly, less than 1 unit up for each unit across, so 2 is too steep.
Worked example 1: the scale trap. Leah’s grid counts the x-axis by 2s and the y-axis by 1s. Her line goes up 3 squares for every 2 squares across, and she writes slope 3/2. Step 1: 2 squares across is 2 × 2 = 4 units of run. Step 2: 3 squares up is 3 units of rise. Step 3: slope = 3 ÷ 4 = 0.75. Step 4: always read rise and run in the axis units, not in squares.
Mistake 3: dividing when the line has a start. A student says a 2-mile taxi ride costs $10.00, so the rate is 10 ÷ 2 = $5.00 per mile. But the fare includes the $3.00 start: the rate is (10.00 − 3.00) ÷ 2 = $3.50. Only a proportional line lets you divide y by x to get the slope.
Worked example 2: a line that falls. Rafael tracks a sample phone plan with 8 GB of data that uses 2 GB each week. Points: (0, 8), (1, 6), (2, 4), (4, 0). Step 1: from (0, 8) to (4, 0), rise = 0 − 8 = −8 and run = 4. Step 2: slope = −8 ÷ 4 = −2. Step 3: equation y = −2x + 8. Step 4: a student who wrote +2 missed the sign; a line that falls from left to right has a negative slope.
Mistake 5: mixing up m and b. For y = 4x + 6, a student says the plan starts at $4. At x = 0, y = 4 × 0 + 6 = 6, so the start is $6 and the rate is $4 per use. Plug in x = 0 to find the start.
For each item, find the mistake or the correct value, then check it.
Error-analysis stations.
Station A: a sample bus card starts with $20 and each ride costs $2.50. Write the equation, give the sign of the slope, and find when the card reaches $0.
Which line is proportional?
Station B: write a slope mistake of your own on a card, with the wrong answer and the right answer. Swap with a partner and fix theirs.
We can catch slope mistakes before families see them. Next we return to our runners and plan the consumer guide.
Exit ticket: which mistake is easiest to make, and what check will you use to catch it?
Pacing: Do Now 4 min, reading 6, mini lesson 12, guided practice 12, stations and exit ticket 6.
Accuracy: channel and crack/rumble/boom facts, divide-by-5 rule, the 5 s and 15 s examples and the 10-mile range are from the NWS thunder page read 2026-11-20 (also used in 2.05). The phone data and bus card are sample data. This is the only lesson in Part 1 with a negative slope; keep it to reading and computing slope, not solving.
Re-derived errors: run over rise on (0, 0)-(4, 2) gives 4/2 = 2 (correct 0.5); counting squares on the x-by-2 grid gives 3/2 (correct 3/4 = 0.75); dividing fare by miles gives 10/2 = 5.00 (correct 3.50); multiplying seconds by 5 gives 75 (correct 3); a dropped sign gives +2 (correct −2); reading the coefficient as the start gives $4 (correct $6).
Supports: a slope checklist: axis units, rise first, sign, intercept at x = 0, reasonable in the story.
Answer guide: Station A: y = −2.5x + 20, negative slope, $0 after 8 rides (2.5 × 8 = 20). Notes should name the error, show the fix and give a check (sketch, plug in a point, compare with a fact from the reading).
National Weather Service, Understanding Lightning: Thunder · U.S. government work, public domain
We return to the National Weather Service page on thunder, this time to use its facts as a check on our math.
The page says a lightning strike usually hits just one spot on the ground, but the lightning channel travels many miles through the air. When you listen, you first hear the thunder from the part of the channel closest to you, then the sound from parts farther and farther away. That is why thunder can rumble for a while.
The sound tells you something. A sharp crack or click means the lightning passed nearby. A rumble means it was at least several miles away. The loud boom comes from the main channel as it reaches the ground.
The page’s rule is to count the seconds from flash to thunder and divide by 5 to get miles, because sound travels about a mile in 5 seconds. It gives 5 seconds as 1 mile and 15 seconds as 3 miles. It also says thunder can be heard only about 10 miles away, and that hearing thunder means you are within striking distance and should get to a safe place at once.
Source: National Weather Service, Understanding Lightning: Thunder (weather.gov)