compare proportional relationships given by a table, a graph, an equation and words, using each one’s unit rate.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Car A’s dealer shows a table. Car B’s dealer shows a graph. Car C’s dealer shows an equation. How could you tell which car goes farthest on a gallon?
What one number should you find for every car before comparing?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
One rate, many looks. A proportional relationship can be shown in words, a table, a graph or an equation. To compare two of them, find the unit rate of each, then compare the numbers. The same units matter: compare miles per gallon with miles per gallon.
Finding the unit rate in each form. In words or a table, divide y by x. On a graph, find the point where x = 1 or compute rise ÷ run. In an equation y = kx, the unit rate is k.
Worked example 1: four sample cars. Grace compares four sample cars. Car A’s table: (2, 64) and (5, 160), so 64 ÷ 2 = 32 MPG. Car B’s graph: a line through (0, 0) and (3, 84), so 84 ÷ 3 = 28 MPG. Car C’s equation: m = 35g, so 35 MPG. Car D in words: 150 miles on 6 gallons, so 150 ÷ 6 = 25 MPG. Order from best to worst: C (35), A (32), B (28), D (25).
Worked example 2: the steeper line. Ethan graphs Car C and Car D on the same grid. Step 1: Car C passes through (2, 70); Car D through (2, 50). Step 2: slopes are 35 and 25. Step 3: Car C’s line is steeper. Step 4: when two lines share the same axes and scales, the steeper line has the greater unit rate.
The other rate. The label also shows gallons per 100 miles. Car D at 25 MPG uses 100 ÷ 25 = 4 gallons per 100 miles; a 20 MPG car uses 5. For this rate a smaller number is better. Always check what the rate measures.
For our guide. Plans arrive in many forms: an ad’s sentence, a price chart, a graph. Our guide will turn each into one unit rate so families compare fairly.
Find each unit rate first, then compare.
Card sort: compare each pair and write which is greater.
Pair 1: Walker J goes 7.5 miles in 3 hours; Walker K's equation is d = 2.4t. Pair 2: Printer X's table shows (5 pages, 2 minutes) and (10, 4); Printer Y's graph passes through (0, 0) and (3, 9) with y = pages and x = minutes. Find every unit rate, then compare.
Which equation matches the line through (0, 0) and (4, 10)?
Write a short tip for our guide: how should a family compare two plans when one is a table and one is a sentence?
Different forms, one unit rate each. Next we look at steepness in the real world: ramps.
Exit ticket: which is the better rate for a family, $45 for 5 visits or y = 8x? Show the unit rates.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 7, mini lesson 10, guided practice 12, card sort and exit ticket 6.
Accuracy: label features (best and worst in category, gallons per 100 miles, the MPG illusion example, MPGe, 1-10 rating) are from the fueleconomy.gov page read 2026-11-20. Cars A-D, phone plans and bike shares are sample data.
Likely misconceptions: comparing the biggest numbers instead of unit rates (Car A’s 160 “wins”); judging steepness on graphs with different scales; forgetting that smaller is better for consumption rates.
Supports: a four-box organizer (words, table, graph, equation) with “unit rate = ___” in each box. Stretch: which car uses fewest gallons per 100 miles? (Car C: 100 ÷ 35 is about 2.86.)
Answer guide: MPG illusion: over 1,000 miles a 10 MPG car uses 100 gallons and a 15 MPG car about 66.7, saving about 33; at 30 and 35 MPG the use is about 33.3 and 28.6, saving about 5. Card sort: J 2.5 > K 2.4 miles per hour; X 2.5 pages per minute < Y 3. Exit ticket: $45 ÷ 5 = $9 per visit versus $8, so y = 8x is cheaper.
U.S. Department of Energy and U.S. EPA, fueleconomy.gov: Learn More About the Fuel Economy Label for Gasoline Vehicles · U.S. government work, public domain
We return to the fuel economy label explained on fueleconomy.gov. Today we look at how the label helps shoppers compare cars.
First, the label shows miles per gallon, or MPG. For each model year, the Environmental Protection Agency lists the best and worst fuel economy in each category of vehicle, such as small SUVs or pickup trucks, and the label tells shoppers where a car stands.
Second, the label shows gallons per 100 miles, called the fuel consumption rate. The page says MPG alone can mislead buyers. In its example over 1,000 miles, a jump from 10 to 15 MPG saves about 33 gallons, while a jump from 30 to 35 MPG saves only about 5 gallons. The jump is 5 MPG both times, but the savings are very different. That is why the page says gallons per mile, or per 100 miles, can give a fairer comparison.
Electric and natural gas vehicles use a related number, MPGe, which compares them with the energy in a gallon of gasoline. The label also gives each car a fuel economy rating from 1, the worst, to 10, the best.
Source: U.S. Department of Energy and U.S. EPA, fueleconomy.gov: Learn More About the Fuel Economy Label for Gasoline Vehicles (fueleconomy.gov)