decide whether a number is rational or irrational using two tests, a fraction of integers or a decimal that ends or repeats, and justify each choice.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Here are ten number cards: √49, √50, 0.3 (the 3 repeats), π, 22/7, −5, 0.1010010001…, 1.414, √2 and 0.125. Sort them into two piles, rational and irrational, before today’s lesson. Star the ones you are unsure about.
Which card do you think is the hardest to sort?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Two tests, one answer. A number is rational if you can write it as a/b with integers a and b (b not 0). That is the same as saying its decimal ends or repeats. A number is irrational if it fails both: no fraction of integers, and a decimal that never ends and never repeats. Together, the rational and irrational numbers make up the real numbers, every point on the number line.
A shortcut for square roots. If A is a perfect square, √A is a whole number, so it is rational: √49 = 7. If A is a whole number that is not a perfect square, √A is irrational: √2, √50.
Worked example 1: three tricky cards. Leah sorts three cards. Step 1: 0.3 (the 3 repeats) never ends, but it repeats, and 0.3 (the 3 repeats) = 1/3. Rational. Step 2: √49 has a square-root sign, but 7 × 7 = 49, so √49 = 7 = 7/1. Rational. Step 3: 0.1010010001… never ends. Its pattern is “one more 0 each time,” so no block of digits ever repeats. Irrational.
Worked example 2: close is not equal. Ibrahim compares √50 and 7.07. Step 1: 50 is not a perfect square (7² = 49, 8² = 64), so √50 is irrational. Step 2: 7.07 stops, so 7.07 = 707/100 is rational. Step 3: check: 7.07² = 49.9849, not 50. Step 4: 7.07 is a rational approximation of √50, a close neighbor on the number line, but a different number.
Watch the wording. “Never ends” alone does not make a number irrational: 0.3 (the 3 repeats) never ends. And “has a square root sign” does not either: √49 is 7. Always check both tests.
For our placards. One placard can be a “number zoo” sign: two enclosures labeled rational and irrational, with three animals (numbers) in each and a one-line reason for each.
For each number, name the test you used.
Finish your number zoo.
Sort all ten Do Now cards again. Next to each, write the test that decided it. Did any of your first answers change?
Which list has only irrational numbers?
Make up your own irrational number with a pattern, like 0.1010010001…. Explain why it never repeats.
We can sort any number. Next we get faster and sharper at estimating the irrational ones.
Exit ticket: is √36 rational or irrational? Is √37? Justify both.
Pacing: card sort 6 min, reading 6, mini lesson 11, guided practice 12, exit ticket 5.
Accuracy: Pi in the Sky facts (grades 5-12; real JPL problems; Mars earthquakes, Jupiter helium rain, planets around other stars; earlier topics; Ota Lutz, JPL senior education specialist; irrational = digits do not repeat or show a pattern and no ratio of two integers) are from the NASA page (updated 2024-11-06). Checks: 7.07² = 49.9849; 0.81 (the 81 repeats) = 81/99 = 9/11; √100 = 10; √121 = 11; √36 = 6. The statement that √A is irrational for every whole number A that is not a perfect square is a theorem; state it, do not prove it.
Likely misconceptions: “every number with a √ is irrational”; “every decimal that never ends is irrational”; “0.1010010001… has a pattern, so it repeats”; “negative numbers are not rational.”
Supports: a flowchart: Is it a fraction of integers? Does the decimal end? Does a block repeat? Is the radicand a perfect square? Stretch: is √(4/9) rational? (Yes: 2/3 × 2/3 = 4/9.)
Answer guide: rational: √49, 0.3 (the 3 repeats), 22/7, −5, 1.414, 0.125; irrational: √50, π, 0.1010010001…, √2. 7.07 × 7.07 = 49.9849 ≠ 50. Exit ticket: √36 = 6, rational; 37 is not a perfect square, so √37 is irrational.
NASA Science, Celebrate Pi Day the NASA Way · NASA content, generally not subject to U.S. copyright (NASA media usage guidelines)
Every year NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory posts a “Pi in the Sky” math challenge for students in grades 5 through 12. The problems are real problems that JPL scientists and engineers solve with pi. They have covered earthquakes on Mars, helium rain on Jupiter and planets that orbit other stars. Earlier problems showed how space probes collect information, how scientists search for distant planets and how astronomers predict solar eclipses.
A JPL education specialist, Ota Lutz, helped create the challenge. She says adults enjoy the problems too, and anyone can try them, even without knowing about space. The problems give people a small look at what goes on at JPL.
The page also explains what kind of number pi is. Pi is irrational. That means two things. First, its digits go on forever without repeating or showing a pattern. Second, it cannot be written as a ratio of two integers. Integers are the whole numbers and their negatives, such as −1, −2 and −3.
Those two facts are exactly the tests we can use to sort any number.
Source: NASA Science, Celebrate Pi Day the NASA Way (science.nasa.gov)