measure circles to estimate pi, compare pi with its rational approximations 3.14 and 22/7, and place them on a number line.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Your team has a can, a plate, a roll of tape and a jar lid. Predict: if you wrap a string once around each and compare it with the distance across, will the big plate and the small lid give very different ratios?
Circumference ÷ diameter for a big plate and a small lid will be…
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
What we measure. The diameter of a circle is the distance straight across through the center. The circumference is the distance around. Pi (π) is circumference ÷ diameter, the same for every circle.
How to measure. Wrap a string once around the object, mark where it meets, and lay it along a ruler. Measure the diameter across the widest part of the top. Measure to the nearest tenth of a centimeter.
Worked example 1: a can. Maya’s team measures a can (sample data): circumference 25.1 cm, diameter 8.0 cm. Step 1: divide: 25.1 ÷ 8.0 = 3.1375. Step 2: round to the hundredth: 3.14. Step 3: their plate gives 69.1 ÷ 22.0 ≈ 3.14 and their tape roll gives 47.0 ÷ 15.0 ≈ 3.13. Step 4: the ratios cluster around 3.14. Measuring errors of a millimeter explain the small differences.
Worked example 2: a giant circle. Carlos uses the NASA numbers. Step 1: circumference ÷ diameter = 24,900 ÷ 7,900. Step 2: 7,900 × 3 = 23,700, with 1,200 left over; 1,200 ÷ 7,900 ≈ 0.15. Step 3: so the ratio is about 3.15. Step 4: it is not exactly pi because the page gives rounded numbers (“more than 7,900” and “roughly 24,900”), but it is close.
Rational stand-ins for pi. Pi is irrational: π = 3.14159… never ends or repeats. People use rational approximations: 3.14 = 314/100, and 22/7 ≈ 3.143. Compare them place by place: 3.140 < 3.1416 < 3.143. So 3.14 is a little too small and 22/7 is a little too big.
On the number line. Draw a line from 3.1 to 3.2 marked in hundredths. π sits just past 3.14, much closer to 3.14 than to 3.15. 22/7 sits just past 3.14 too, a bit to the right of π.
Record your team’s measurements in a table: object, circumference, diameter, ratio. Label it as our own measured data.
Use your team’s data and the reading.
Find the ratio for every object your team measured, to the nearest hundredth. Then find the mean of your ratios.
Draw a number line from 3.1 to 3.2 in hundredths. Place 3.14, π, 22/7 and your team's mean ratio.
A circle has diameter 10 cm. Which is the best estimate of its circumference?
Pi is the same for every circle, and we can only approximate it. Next we sort all our numbers into rational and irrational families.
Exit ticket: is 3.14 a little too big or a little too small for π? Is 22/7? Explain with decimals.
Pacing: Do Now 4 min, measuring stations 14, reading 5, mini lesson 8, guided practice 6, exit ticket 3. If measuring runs long, move the reading to the start of the next lesson.
Materials: per team, string, a centimeter ruler, scissors and 3-4 round objects (empty clean cans with smooth rims, paper plates, tape rolls, lids). See the safety note.
Accuracy: Earth (more than 7,900 miles across at the equator, circumference roughly 24,900 miles), the molecule-sized error, “more than 30,000 times thinner than a hair,” the 46-billion-light-year radius and 37 decimal places for hydrogen-atom accuracy are from the JPL article (updated 2026-03-04). Maya’s can, plate and tape numbers are sample data. Checks: 25.1/8.0 = 3.1375; 69.1/22.0 = 3.1409; 47.0/15.0 = 3.1333; 34.6/11.0 = 3.1454; 24,900/7,900 = 3.1519; 22/7 = 3.142857…; π = 3.14159…. Dividing decimals is a grade 6 skill.
Likely misconceptions: measuring the radius instead of the diameter (ratio near 6.3); thinking 22/7 is pi; thinking a ratio of 3.13 proves pi is “different for small circles.”
Supports: a data table with columns already labeled; a pre-marked number line. Stretch: which is closer to π, 3.14 or 22/7? (22/7 is about 0.0013 away; 3.14 is about 0.0016 away.)
Answer guide: reasons: string stretches or slips, diameter not through the center, rounding to the millimeter; pi is a fixed ratio, so the errors are in measurement. Exit ticket: 3.14 < 3.1416, so 3.14 is a little too small; 22/7 ≈ 3.1429 > 3.1416, so it is a little too big.
NASA/JPL Edu, How Many Decimals of Pi Do We Really Need? · NASA/JPL-Caltech. JPL is run for NASA by Caltech, so this is not strictly a U.S. government work; JPL allows educational use with credit. Retold in our own words
In this JPL article, engineer Marc Rayman shows how close the 15-decimal value of pi, 3.141592653589793, gets us to the truth.
First he brings the math home to our planet. Earth is more than 7,900 miles across at the equator. Its circumference is roughly 24,900 miles. That is how far you would travel if you went all the way around, ignoring hills, valleys, buildings and waves.
If you used the 15-decimal pi to figure out that trip, how wrong would the answer be? Only about the size of a molecule. Rayman says the error would be more than 30,000 times thinner than a human hair.
Then he goes as big as possible: the known universe, with a radius of about 46 billion light-years. To find the circumference of a circle that size, accurate to the width of one hydrogen atom, you would need only 37 decimal places of pi.
The article admits pi is an interesting number with an endless string of digits. But no question about exploring space, from the tiniest scale to the largest, needs very many of them.
Source: NASA/JPL Edu, How Many Decimals of Pi Do We Really Need? (jpl.nasa.gov)