Which Plan Is Better?
When does one plan become cheaper than another?
The mystery: Two runners start at different places and speeds. Where and when do they meet?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
compare a pay-each-visit plan with a flat annual pass using a table, and describe what our consumer guide must show families.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. A family loves Shenandoah National Park in Virginia, a few hours’ drive from Pittsburgh. A car pass costs $30 for each trip, or the family can buy a park annual pass for $55.
For how many trips in a year does the annual pass start to save money?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Meet our audience. Our guide is for East Allegheny families who have to choose between plans: a park pass, a gym membership, a phone plan or a ride service. Families are busy. A good guide shows the numbers clearly and teaches a method they can use again.
Two kinds of plans. Some plans charge the same amount every time you use them. The total grows at a constant rate, so it is proportional to the number of uses. Other plans charge one flat price no matter how often you go.
Worked example 1: the park table. Sofia compares the plans for 0 to 4 trips. Step 1: car pass cost = $30 × trips: $0, $30, $60, $90, $120. Step 2: annual pass cost = $55 for any number of trips. Step 3: compare row by row. At 1 trip, $30 < $55, so the car pass is cheaper. At 2 trips, $60 > $55, so the annual pass is cheaper. Step 4: conclude: the annual pass wins for 2 or more trips.
Worked example 2: is it proportional? Dante checks the car pass plan. Step 1: ratios: 30 ÷ 1 = 30, 60 ÷ 2 = 30, 120 ÷ 4 = 30. Step 2: 0 trips cost $0. Step 3: the cost is proportional to trips, with a unit rate of $30 per trip. The annual pass is not proportional: 55 ÷ 1 = 55 but 55 ÷ 5 = 11, and 0 trips still cost $55 if you bought it.
The guide’s big idea. The “better” plan depends on how much you use it. Our guide will show families the point where the plans switch, so each family can decide for itself.
Plans our guide could compare. Families suggested park passes, gym plans with a sign-up fee, phone plans and ride costs. We will use real prices where a public source gives them and label invented prices as sample.
Use the reading’s prices. Build a table before you answer.
Plan our guide.
List three plans East Allegheny families might compare (for example a gym, a phone, a bus pass). For each, write what the family pays at the start and what they pay for each use or month. Label invented numbers as sample.
Sample gym: $8 per visit with no fee, or $40 for a month of unlimited visits. What is the fewest monthly visits for which the unlimited plan is cheaper?
Write two Wonder Board questions our guide should answer for families.
We know our audience and our first comparison. Next we investigate rates in tables, starting with pay for each hour of work.
Exit ticket: explain to a family why “the annual pass is better” is only true some of the time.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, planning and exit ticket 7.
Accuracy: Shenandoah prices ($30 private vehicle for 7 days, $55 annual, Standard Pass $15-$30, America the Beautiful free-$250, 80/20 fee split, no cash) were read on the park page on 2026-11-20. The $80 America the Beautiful resident price is from the NPS Entrance Passes page (used in 2.12). Treat each trip as a separate week, since one $30 pass covers 7 days. The gym prices are sample data.
Likely misconceptions: “the more expensive plan is always worse”; treating the flat plan as proportional. Ask: what does 0 trips cost in each plan?
Supports: a three-column table (trips, car pass, annual pass). Stretch: at what number of trips does the $55 annual pass save more than $100? (6 trips: $180 – $55 = $125; 5 trips save only $95.)
Answer guide: 4 trips: $120 – $55 = $65. The three-park family: America the Beautiful, because the reading recommends it for more than one park; they should still compare its $80 price with three Standard Passes. Accept reasoning that uses the reading. Exit ticket: the annual pass is better only for 2 or more trips.
National Park Service, Shenandoah National Park: Fees & Passes · U.S. government work, public domain
The National Park Service runs Shenandoah National Park in Virginia. Every visitor must have an entrance pass, whether they drive Skyline Drive or hike in from the park boundary. The park does not accept cash.
The page lists three kinds of passes. A Standard Pass costs between $15 and $30. For a private car, it costs $30 and covers the car and all its passengers for seven days in a row, starting on the day it is bought. An Annual Pass for Shenandoah costs $55 and covers entrance for one year. The America the Beautiful pass, which costs from free up to $250 depending on who buys it, works at many federal sites.
The park gives simple advice. If you are visiting once, choose the Standard Pass. If you will visit this park several times, choose the Annual Pass. If you will visit more than one national park or federal recreation site, choose America the Beautiful.
The page also explains where the money goes. Eighty percent of entrance fees pay for projects that help visitors, such as trail work and fixing historic buildings. The other 20 percent helps parks that do not charge fees.
Source: National Park Service, Shenandoah National Park: Fees & Passes (nps.gov)