
write and defend a claim-evidence-reasoning explanation of the variation the seed library sees, judging whether my evidence is enough and whether it shows cause or only correlation, then brainstorm trial and guide ideas.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. A volunteer says, “The big beans came from the sunny bed, so sun gives beans better genes.” Write what is right and what is wrong about that sentence.
Growing a bean plant in full sun changes the alleles in the seeds it passes on.
Pulling the unit together. The seed library sees two kinds of variation. Some is heritable: yellow kernels on purple ears, speckled and plain beans from one pod. Some is environmental: big beans from the sunny bed. Today you write one claim-evidence-reasoning explanation that sorts the variation by its cause, using every investigation so far.
Your evidence bank.
Sentence starters. Claim: “The variation in ___ is mainly caused by ___.” Evidence: “In our data, ___, which shows ___.” Reasoning: “This happens because during meiosis / replication / growth ___.” Counter-claim: “Someone might argue ___, but ___.”
Worked example 1: a CER for the yellow kernels. Claim: yellow kernels on “purple” ears are inherited, from hidden p alleles. Evidence: 7 of 10 packets saved near yellow corn grew yellow kernels, against 2 of 30 saved elsewhere (sample data); a Pp × Pp ear gives about 1/4 yellow, and our ears fit 3 : 1 (χ2 = 0.384). Reasoning: pollen from yellow corn gave Pp kernels that looked purple; when those plants made gametes, meiosis separated P and p, so about a quarter of the next kernels were pp. Counter-claim: “a new mutation made them yellow.” Mutations are rare, about one uncorrected error per billion bases copied, so a mutation cannot explain yellow kernels in 7 of 10 packets.
Worked example 2: is the evidence enough? Judge your evidence with three questions. How many sources, and what kinds? Lab counts, a model and a textbook are three different kinds, which is stronger than one. Is it reliable? Pooled class data are more reliable than one ear; illustrative data show a method, not a real result. Cause or correlation? The returned-seed table shows an association; the meiosis model supplies a mechanism, and a controlled cross would test it. A claim backed by a pattern, a mechanism and a test is far stronger than a pattern alone.
| Evidence | Kind of source | Reliable? Why | Shows cause or correlation? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Returned-seed table | |||
| Kernel chi-square | |||
| Meiosis model | |||
| Sun-shade bean means | |||
| OpenStax section 14.6 |
Ideate: from explanation to plan. The library needs a seed-saving guide and a trial plan. Brainstorm at least five ideas, each tied to a cause of variation: isolate corn varieties by distance or planting date; save seed from many plants, not just the biggest; a common-garden bed where two seed lots grow side by side; the same seed lot in sun and shade beds; random placement using numbered stakes; a chi-square check of each returned lot. Wild ideas are welcome; we judge them in 4.07.
Draft your CER with your team, then answer.
Judge your evidence, then Ideate.
Fill in the evidence table. Then write three sentences: is your evidence sufficient for your claim, which piece is weakest, and does any of it show only correlation?
Ideate: list five ideas for the seed-saving guide or trial plan. Tag each with the cause of variation it controls or tests, and star the two your team likes best.
Our science is ready. Next phase, we design the garden trial.
Exit ticket: in three sentences, explain how the same pair of parents can produce offspring that differ, and why a sunny garden cannot change the alleles a seed carries.
How confident are you that you can defend a claim about the sources of genetic variation, judging whether my evidence is sufficient and causal.
Materials: Lab Notebooks with 4.01–4.05 data, the returned-seed table, CER organizer, sticky notes for the Ideate wall, the class Wonder Board.
Setup: before drafting, revisit the Wonder Board and mark the questions the unit has now answered.
Listen for: “the environment changes the genes”; “mutation explains every difference”; evidence quoted without numbers.
Support / stretch: give the sentence starters on a card and a two-column cause sorter (heritable, environmental). Stretch: explain a trait that depends on both, such as seed length, and propose how to estimate how much of its variation each cause contributes.