
construct and defend an explanation, with a matter-and-energy model and calculations, of how a giant tree built its mass, where its carbon goes, and how the park can keep more carbon stored.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. The city council will read your carbon budget. Write the one sentence you most want them to remember.
A tree adds 250 kg of dry wood (about half carbon). About how much CO2 did it remove from the air?
The question. How did a giant tree build its enormous mass from air, water and light, where does its carbon go when it respires, dies, decays or burns, and how can the park keep more of it stored?
What your explanation must include.
A model worth drawing. Four boxes (atmosphere, tree, soil and decomposers, ocean) with arrows labeled photosynthesis, respiration, decomposition, combustion and dissolving. Use one color for matter arrows and another for energy arrows. Energy arrows start at the Sun and end as heat leaving the system.
Common errors to avoid. Saying plants get their food from the soil; saying energy is recycled; saying plants photosynthesize instead of respiring; and giving numbers without units. Your peer reviewer will look for all four.
Presentation. Four minutes, live or recorded, to the parks department (staff or family playing its members). Walk through your model and answer one question on how matter or energy is tracked in it.
Plan and check your draft with these prompts.
Work on the stage your teacher assigns.
Draft the “where the carbon goes” section with at least two exits. For each, name the process, the reservoirs it moves carbon between, and whether it is fast or slow.
Task: For the city parks department, explain with a labeled matter-and-energy model and at least one carbon calculation how a giant tree built its mass from carbon dioxide, water and light energy, how sugar carbon becomes the tree’s other molecules, and where the carbon goes through respiration, decomposition and wildfire. Use evidence from the leaf-disk lab, the yeast lab, the decomposition jars and the NOAA Mauna Loa record, and close with your version 2 park carbon plan. Hand-drawn models are fully acceptable.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Photosynthesis model (HS-LS1-5) | Balanced equation with a correct mass check; explains the sources of each atom and the role of light energy. |
| Sugar to biomolecules (HS-LS1-6) | Explains how sugar carbon forms cellulose, proteins and other molecules, including the elements from soil and the energy from respiration that drives these reactions. |
| Respiration and energy (HS-LS2-3) | Explains aerobic and anaerobic respiration as bonds broken and re-formed with net energy transfer to ATP and heat, day and night, in the tree and in decomposers. |
| Carbon cycling and the park plan (HS-LS2-5) | Model shows reservoirs and processes, including decomposition and combustion, with arrows in the right direction; the park plan is supported by a carbon estimate and states its limits. |
| Mathematics | Carbon calculation correct with units and clearly stated assumptions. |
| Evidence and communication | Claims tied to lab data and the NOAA record; the presentation answers a question accurately. |
Next: the unit checkpoint, then a 360° field trip.
Exit ticket: which question from our Wonder Board can you now answer? Write the question and your answer.
How confident are you that you can explain with a model and calculation how a tree builds its mass and where its carbon goes.
Materials: lab notebooks with all unit data, version 2 plans, rubric copies, colored pencils, a timer for presentations.
Timing: the task runs across about three sessions: plan and draft, peer review and revision, presentations.
Listen for: the four common errors; calculations without units; wildfire described in frightening detail (keep it to the chemistry of combustion).
Support / stretch: give a model template with the four boxes and a calculation frame. Stretch: compare the carbon released by burning a tree in one day with the carbon it took up over its lifetime, and explain why they are about equal.