
distinguish negative from positive feedback, investigate heart-rate recovery after light exercise, and argue which claims about homeostasis the data support.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Find your pulse at your wrist. Count beats for 15 seconds and multiply by 4. What would you expect it to do right after you climb three flights of stairs, and then five minutes later?
After two minutes of stepping, how will your heart rate fall back toward resting?
What a feedback loop is. A homeostatic system has four parts. A sensor detects a variable (temperature, blood glucose, carbon dioxide). A control center, often in the brain, compares it with a set point. Effectors (muscles or glands) act to change the variable. The result feeds back to the sensor, closing the loop. In negative feedback, the response opposes the change: when core temperature rises, the hypothalamus signals sweat glands and skin blood vessels to shed heat, and as temperature falls the signal weakens. Most homeostasis runs on negative feedback, because it pulls a variable back toward its set point.
Two more examples. After a meal, blood glucose rises. Cells in the pancreas sense it and release insulin, which causes liver and muscle cells to take up glucose, so the level falls back. Between meals, glucose falls and the pancreas releases glucagon, which signals the liver to release stored glucose. During exercise, muscles produce more carbon dioxide; sensors detect the rise and the brain increases breathing and heart rate. When exercise stops, the signal fades and heart rate falls back toward resting.
Positive feedback amplifies a change instead. In a ripening fruit, the gas ethylene triggers ripening, and ripening fruit makes more ethylene, which is why one ripe banana in a bag speeds the others. Blood clotting is another: each step recruits more clotting factors. Positive feedback is useful when a process must finish quickly, but it does not maintain a steady state. Heat stroke can behave like a runaway: at very high temperatures, proteins stop working properly, cooling becomes less effective, and temperature climbs further.
Worked example 1: reading recovery data (sample data). Resting pulse 72 beats per minute (bpm); immediately after two minutes of stepping, 138 bpm; then 118, 102, 90, 82 and 76 bpm at one-minute intervals. The drop from the peak after 3 minutes is 138 − 90 = 48 bpm. The student had risen 138 − 72 = 66 bpm above resting, so after 3 minutes they had recovered 48 ÷ 66 ≈ 73% of the way back. The drops get smaller each minute (20, 16, 12, 8, 6 bpm): the further the pulse is from the set point, the faster it falls.
Worked example 2: answering a counter-claim. Suppose someone claims, heart rate falls after exercise simply because the heart gets tired. If the heart were tiring, it could not speed up again on demand; yet a second bout of stepping raises it just as high. A scientific argument has a claim, evidence (specific data) and reasoning (the principle that links them), and a strong one answers a counter-claim. The data, not the loudness of the speaker, decide.
Planning the investigation. The change in the environment is two minutes of exercise; the response is heart rate over time. Decide before you start how many people you will test, what you will hold constant (step height, pace, room temperature) and how you will know whether the pulse has stabilized (back within 5 bpm of resting).
Lab procedure: pulse recovery after light exercise.
| Time after exercise (min) | Resting | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Heart rate (bpm) | |||||||
| Drop in the last minute (bpm) | — | — |
Dataset route. Anyone who does not step analyzes the sample dataset above plus two more provided records, for equal credit.
Reading: OpenStax Biology 2e, chapter 33, section on homeostasis (CC BY 4.0).
Use your class data or the sample dataset.
Finish the lab analysis.
Calculate how many bpm your pulse (or a dataset pulse) rose above resting, and what percentage of that rise had been recovered at 3 minutes. Identify two sources of error and explain how pooling class data reduces their effect.
We measured a feedback loop working. Next, we ask what heat does to the proteins that run it.
Exit ticket: name the sensor, control center and effector in the loop that brings your heart rate back down after exercise.
How confident are you that you can explain negative feedback with a sensor, control center and effector, and support the explanation with data.
Materials: stopwatches or phone timers, a sturdy step or bottom stair about 20 cm high, data tables, graph paper or a free spreadsheet, printed sample dataset.
Timing: this lab spans two 50-minute periods: data on day 1, graphing and argument on day 2.
Privacy: pool data by participant number only; never post individual heart rates with names.
Listen for: “negative feedback is bad” (negative means opposing the change) and confusing sensor with effector.
Support / stretch: give a pre-labeled graph grid. Stretch: fit the drops to a pattern (each drop is about 80% of the last) and predict the pulse at 7 minutes.