
construct and defend an evidence-based explanation, with a system model, of how the body maintains core temperature in extreme heat, why the system can fail, and how our cooling plan helps.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. The co-op committee will read your explanation. In one sentence, what is the most important thing they should understand about why heat illness happens?
In the temperature feedback loop, which is the control center?
The question. How does a person working outdoors on a 105 °F afternoon keep a core temperature near 37 °C, why does that system sometimes fail, and how can our cooling plan help?
What a strong explanation contains. A scientific explanation is not a list of facts; it is a causal chain supported by evidence. Yours has five parts.
Worked example: one link of the chain. Claim: high humidity makes heat illness more likely. Evidence: sweat only removes heat when it evaporates, and evaporation slows as air fills with water vapor; evaporation is the only path for heat loss when air is hotter than skin. Reasoning: if the effector (sweating) still runs but cannot remove heat, core temperature keeps rising while the body loses water; once temperature passes about 40 °C, proteins begin to lose shape, as the catalase curve showed for yeast, and the control center itself is affected.
Data you may use. Your own lab data, the class sample datasets from 1.04, 1.05 and 1.08, and public-domain CDC/NIOSH descriptions of heat illness. Cite every source. If you describe an effect you did not measure, say where the information comes from.
Sensitivity. You never need to describe a real person’s health. Write about a hypothetical worker, athlete or firefighter.
Presentation. In four minutes, live or recorded, walk the committee (classmates, staff or family playing its members) through your model and answer one question about your evidence. A strong answer names the specific data that support the step being questioned.
Plan and check your draft with these prompts.
Work on the stage your teacher assigns.
Draft the “change in conditions” section: name your condition, the exact step of the loop it affects, and how the loop could become overwhelmed. Then say how your cooling plan would help, citing your version 2 data.
Task: Write an evidence-based explanation for the farm co-op’s safety committee of how a hypothetical outdoor worker in 105 °F heat maintains a core temperature near 37 °C, and why heat illness happens when the system is overwhelmed. Include a labeled feedback-loop model, at least three organ systems with a tissue or cell type named for each, evidence from at least three unit labs, a prediction for one changed condition (humidity, dehydration or protective clothing), and a recommendation built on your cooling sleeve and work-rest routine. Paper models photographed or scanned are fully acceptable.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| System model (HS-LS1-2) | Model shows sensors, control center, effectors and heat flows, correctly places at least three interacting organ systems with named tissues or cells, and states how it differs from the real body. |
| Feedback mechanism (HS-LS1-3) | Explains negative feedback accurately and uses pulse-recovery and sleeve data as evidence, with their limits. |
| Protein function (HS-LS1-1) | Uses the catalase data to explain why temperature must be controlled, linking gene, protein shape and function. |
| Changed condition and design | Predicts the effect of the chosen condition on a specific step, explains how the system can be overwhelmed, and shows how the cooling plan helps. |
| Use of evidence | Every claim is tied to specific data or a cited source; calculations are correct. |
| Communication | Clear structure; the presentation answers a question about evidence accurately. |
Next: the unit checkpoint, then a 360° field trip.
Exit ticket: which question from our Wonder Board can you now answer? Write the question and your answer.
How confident are you that you can build and defend an evidence-based explanation of homeostasis in extreme heat.
Materials: lab notebooks with all unit data, sleeve version 2 results, rubric copies, a timer for presentations.
Timing: the task runs across about three sessions: plan and draft, peer review and revision, presentations. Writing can continue as homework.
Listen for: lists of facts with no causal links; “sweat is cold”; evidence quoted without numbers.
Support / stretch: give a causal-chain organizer and sentence starters (“Because ___, the ___ cannot ___, so ___”). Stretch: add a second changed condition and compare the two.