contrast how Congress, the President and the courts function in foreign policy, and explain how other nations’ choices affect the United States.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Think about our unit’s T-shirt: cotton grown in one country, sewn in another, sold in a third. If the United States signs a trade treaty with those countries, who gets a say? Read to find out how treaties are made.
According to the reading, what share of senators present must agree before a treaty moves forward?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Foreign policy is shared on purpose. The framers of the Constitution divided power so no single branch could control how the nation deals with the world. Each branch has its own job.
The President leads day to day. The President is commander in chief of the armed forces, negotiates treaties, names ambassadors and meets with other leaders. The State Department carries out the President’s foreign policy.
Congress checks and funds. Congress can declare war, controls spending (including for the military and foreign aid) and has power to regulate trade with foreign nations. The Senate approves treaties by a two-thirds vote and confirms ambassadors.
The courts decide cases. Federal courts, led by the Supreme Court, hear cases involving treaties and foreign affairs. They decide what laws and treaties mean and whether actions by the other branches follow the Constitution. Courts act only when a real case is brought to them.
Worked example 1: Destiny maps a trade deal. Destiny traces a sample trade treaty: the President’s team negotiates it; the Senate Foreign Relations Committee studies it; the full Senate votes, needing 67 of 100 senators if all are present; Congress passes laws to carry it out; and if a company later sues over how it is applied, a federal court decides the case.
Worked example 2: Andre links the world to his family. Andre reads that when another nation raises taxes on goods it buys from the United States, called tariffs, American farmers and factories may sell less there. When the United States raises tariffs, imported goods can cost more at home. He writes: “Choices made by other nations, and by our own government, can change prices for families here.” People disagree about when tariffs help or hurt, so his booth presents both views.
The U.S. role in the world. As a large economy and a founding member of many international groups, the United States trades, gives aid, makes alliances and helps set rules. Its choices affect other nations, and their choices affect us.
Use the reading and the mini lecture.
Draft the Trade and the World booth’s branches panel.
Write a 75-word panel that explains how the three branches share foreign policy. Use the treaty process as your example and cite the Senate page.
Explain one way the United States plays a role in world affairs and one way another nation or international group can affect American families. Present any disagreement fairly.
No single branch decides how America deals with the world, and that is by design.
Exit ticket: why might the framers have required two-thirds of the Senate, not just half, to approve a treaty?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 10, guided practice 12, drafting 8, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: that the President alone controls foreign policy; that the Senate ratifies treaties (it approves a resolution; ratification is the formal exchange); that courts give advice on policy (they decide cases).
Nonpartisan note: tariffs and trade deals are debated across parties. Present the reasons people give for and against without endorsing a side or a current official.
Supports: a three-column organizer with Constitution article references. Stretch: compare a treaty with an executive agreement.
Answer guide: President: negotiates treaties, commander in chief, names ambassadors. Congress: declares war, funds, regulates foreign trade, Senate approves treaties and ambassadors. Courts: decide cases about treaties and whether actions are constitutional. Two-thirds answers: a bigger majority means broad agreement before the nation is bound. Branch powers come from the Constitution (archives.gov/founding-docs/constitution-transcript).
United States Senate, About Treaties · U.S. government work, public domain
A treaty is a formal written agreement between nations. The U.S. Constitution, in Article II, section 2, gives the President the power to make treaties, but only with the “advice and consent” of the Senate. Two-thirds of the senators present must agree.
The President, or people the President chooses, negotiates a treaty with other countries. Then the treaty goes to the Senate. First, the Senate Committee on Foreign Relations studies it. Then the full Senate votes on a resolution to approve it. The Senate does not ratify a treaty by itself. Ratification happens when the United States and the other nations formally exchange the signed papers.
A treaty can wait in the committee for a long time. The Senate has approved nearly all treaties presidents have sent. When a treaty did not have enough support, Senate leaders sometimes chose not to bring it to a vote, and it was later withdrawn.
In recent years, presidents have often made executive agreements with other countries instead. These do not need Senate approval, but they still count under international law.
“provided two-thirds of the Senators present concur” (U.S. Constitution, Article II, section 2, as quoted by the U.S. Senate)
Source: United States Senate, About Treaties (senate.gov)