explain how federal and state courts are organized and describe the steps and rights that make up due process in a criminal case.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. A student is accused of breaking a school rule. List three things that would make the process fair before any consequence is given.
In a federal criminal case, who must prove guilt?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Due process. The Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments say government may not take a person’s life, liberty or property without due process of law. In simple words: government must follow fair, known rules before it punishes anyone.
Two court systems. According to the federal courts, the Constitution sets up a system where the national and state governments share power, and each has its own courts. Federal courts hear cases about the Constitution, federal laws and disputes between states. State courts handle most criminal cases, family matters and most contract and injury cases. Federal judges are nominated by the president, confirmed by the Senate and generally serve for life. In Pennsylvania, judges are elected.
Courts near us. Allegheny County’s Court of Common Pleas is the main state trial court for our county. Magisterial district judges hear smaller cases, like traffic tickets, close to home.
Worked example 1: rights at each step. Gabriel makes a two-column chart: step and protection. Grand jury: citizens check the evidence. First appearance: right to a lawyer. Pretrial: unfairly gathered evidence can be thrown out. Trial: the government must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
Worked example 2: why protect the accused? Lena asks why someone accused of a crime gets so many protections. She reasons, “Anyone could be wrongly accused. The rules protect innocent people and make sure the government proves its case.”
Courts and civic action. Courts do not take up an issue just because citizens ask. They decide real cases brought to them. That is one reason our proposal will go to lawmakers or agencies, not a court.
Use the reading and your step-and-protection chart.
Build a due process walkway.
Draw five stepping stones for a federal criminal case. On each stone, write the step and the right or protection that applies there.
Courts protect rights when a case is brought. Next we study how people settle disagreements, sometimes without a trial at all.
Exit ticket: in your own words, what does due process mean, and why does it protect everyone?
Pacing: Do Now 4 min, reading 10, mini lesson 8, practice 10, walkway 8.
Sources: the reading is uscourts.gov Criminal Cases. Court structure and judge selection are from uscourts.gov Comparing Federal & State Courts. Pennsylvania’s election of judges and the Court of Common Pleas are established facts; verify current local court names before class if you add detail.
Sensitivity: some students may have family members involved with courts. Keep examples general and never ask about personal experiences.
Likely misconceptions: that the accused must prove innocence; that most cases go to a jury trial; that the Supreme Court hears every case.
Supports: a word bank and a partly filled walkway. Stretch: compare the criminal standard (beyond a reasonable doubt) with the civil standard students meet next lesson.
Answer guide: due process means fair, known procedures before government punishes anyone; it protects everyone because anyone could be wrongly accused.
United States Courts, Criminal Cases · U.S. government work, public domain
Only the government can start a criminal case. In federal court, this is usually the U.S. Attorney’s office. A grand jury, a group of citizens, reviews the evidence and decides whether there is enough to require the person to stand trial.
At a first appearance, a judge explains the charges and decides whether the defendant, the person accused, will stay in jail before trial. Defendants who cannot afford a lawyer are told they have the right to one appointed by the court.
Next, the defendant answers the charges with a plea. More than 90 percent of federal defendants plead guilty rather than go to trial. Before a trial, the defense can ask the court to throw out evidence gathered in a way that broke constitutional rights.
At trial, the government has the burden of proof. Defendants do not have to prove they are innocent. The government must convince the jury of guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. If the verdict is not guilty, the government may not appeal, and the person cannot be tried again in federal court for the same crime. If the verdict is guilty, the judge decides the sentence.
Source: United States Courts, Criminal Cases (uscourts.gov)