explain how political parties, primaries and general elections help citizens choose leaders, and compare two viewpoints on Pennsylvania’s closed primary.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. A club picks its own leader, then the whole school votes between club leaders for student council president. How is that like a primary and a general election?
In Pennsylvania, can a voter registered with no party vote in a Democratic or Republican primary for party nominees?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
What parties do. A political party is a group of people who share general ideas about government and work to elect candidates. The Constitution does not mention parties, but they formed early in our history. Today the two largest are the Democratic and Republican parties, and there are smaller, or third, parties too. Parties recruit candidates, hold primaries and conventions, and help voters learn what candidates stand for.
Campaigns. A campaign is the organized effort to win an election: speeches, debates, volunteers, ads and get-out-the-vote work. Citizens take part by volunteering, attending debates, giving to candidates, and of course voting.
A real disagreement. Some people support Pennsylvania’s closed primary. They argue that a party’s own members should choose its nominees, without voters from outside the party shaping the result. Others want open primaries. They argue that independent and third-party voters, who are a large group of registered voters, should have a say in choosing candidates for the general election. Lawmakers have proposed changes, and the debate continues. Both sides are making arguments about fairness.
Worked example 1: a claim with evidence. Imani writes: Claim: A Pennsylvania primary is a party’s choice, not a final choice. Evidence: the state guide says the top vote-getters move on to November. Reasoning: so all voters still choose the winner in the general election.
Worked example 2: stating a viewpoint fairly. Luis has an opinion on closed primaries but practices describing the other side first. He writes the strongest version of the argument he does not hold, then checks it with a partner who does hold it. “If they agree I described it fairly, I passed.”
Our classroom rule. You will not be asked which side you favor. You will be asked to explain each side accurately with evidence.
Use the reading and your notes on the two viewpoints.
Write a claim-evidence-reasoning paragraph.
Answer in a CER paragraph: How do primaries and general elections work together to let citizens choose leaders in Pennsylvania? Use at least two facts from the reading.
We explained a real debate fairly. Next we look at how the president is chosen and weigh viewpoints on the Electoral College.
Exit ticket: what is one skill you used today to describe a viewpoint you may not hold?
Pacing: Do Now 4 min, reading 8, mini lesson 10, practice 10, CER 8.
Nonpartisan rule: do not ask students to declare a side or share family party registration. Grade only accuracy and fairness of descriptions. The closed-versus-open debate crosses party lines; present it as a debate about rules, not about parties.
Accuracy: reading facts are from pa.gov (checked 2026-11-19). Advocates estimate more than a million Pennsylvania voters are registered outside the two major parties; if you cite a number, cite its source.
Likely misconceptions: that the primary winner automatically takes office; that independents cannot vote at all in May.
Supports: CER frame and a viewpoint T-chart. Stretch: compare Pennsylvania’s primary rules with one neighboring state’s.
Answer guide: strong CER paragraphs explain that parties pick nominees in the primary and all registered voters choose among nominees in November, citing dates and the closed primary rule.
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Voting and Election Information: Types of Elections · Public information from the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania; summarized
Pennsylvania holds several kinds of elections. In a primary election, voters in a political party choose that party’s candidates. Primaries are held on the third Tuesday of May in most years and on the fourth Tuesday of April in presidential years.
Pennsylvania has a closed primary. Voters registered as Republicans vote only for Republican candidates, and voters registered as Democrats vote only for Democratic candidates. The candidates with the most votes move on to the November election. All registered voters may vote in a primary if the ballot includes a constitutional amendment, a ballot question or a special election in their district.
The general election is held on the first Tuesday after the first Monday in November. Voters choose federal, state and local officials. In odd-numbered years, the November election is called a municipal election, because it includes county and local offices and judges but no federal or state offices.
A special election fills an office when an official can no longer serve. Every four years the general election includes the president. Pennsylvania has 19 electoral votes, and all 19 go to the candidates who win the state’s popular vote.
Source: Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Voting and Election Information: Types of Elections (pa.gov)