explain how government agencies create, change and enforce rules, from a federal agency like the FCC to a local zoning hearing board.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. A law says radio stations must serve the public. Who decides the details, like which station gets which channel number? Write your guess.
Can ordinary people comment on a new federal rule before it is final?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Why agencies? Laws often set big goals. Agencies fill in the details and enforce them. Enforcing a rule can mean inspections, licenses, warnings or fines.
An independent federal agency: the FCC. The Federal Communications Commission regulates communications such as radio, television and phone service. The U.S. Code says it has five commissioners appointed by the president with the consent of the Senate, each for a term of five years. No more than three may belong to the same political party. That design is meant to keep the agency from being controlled by one party.
A local agency: the zoning hearing board. Many Pennsylvania municipalities have a zoning ordinance that says what can be built where. A zoning hearing board, made of appointed residents, holds public hearings and decides requests for exceptions, called variances, and appeals. Neighbors can come and speak.
Worked example 1: tracing authority. Nadia asks, “Where does an agency get the power to make a rule?” From the reading, she writes: “Congress passes a law that gives the agency rulemaking power. The proposed rule must name that legal authority.”
Worked example 2: a local hearing. Ben’s neighbor wants to build a garage closer to the property line than the zoning ordinance allows. Ben explains, “She asks the zoning hearing board for a variance. The board holds a public hearing, listens to neighbors and decides. If someone disagrees, they can appeal to court.”
For our proposal. Some community issues are not decided by lawmakers at all but by an agency, board or department. Finding the right decision maker is part of good civic research.
Use the reading and the mini lesson. Number the rulemaking steps first.
Write a public comment.
Imagine a sample proposed rule: “All public parks must post their closing hours at every entrance.” Write a respectful public comment of 4-6 sentences that supports, opposes or suggests a change, with one reason and one piece of evidence.
Agencies turn laws into rules. Next we see how courts protect rights when people are accused of breaking rules.
Exit ticket: name one federal and one local body that makes or enforces rules, and one way a citizen can take part in each.
Pacing: Do Now 4 min, reading 10, mini lesson 8, practice 10, comment 8.
Sources: the reading is a CRS In Focus (public domain), opened on everycrsreport.com. FCC structure is from 47 U.S.C. 154 on govinfo.gov (five commissioners, five-year terms, party cap equal to a bare majority, which is three). fcc.gov blocked automated requests when this was written. Zoning hearing boards are set up under the Pennsylvania Municipalities Planning Code; details vary by municipality.
Likely misconceptions: that agencies can make any rule they want; that regulations are not “real” law; that public comments are votes (they are input, not a vote count).
Supports: a four-box rulemaking organizer. Stretch: find one open comment period on Regulations.gov on a local-feeling topic, such as parks or school meals.
Answer guide: benefit: experts know technical details; risk: unelected officials make binding rules, which is why notice, comment and checks exist. Strong public comments are specific, polite and evidence-based.
Congressional Research Service, An Overview of Federal Regulations and the Rulemaking Process (IF10003, updated July 15, 2026) · U.S. government work (Congressional Research Service), public domain
Federal agencies issue regulations, detailed rules that carry out programs Congress creates by law. A valid regulation has the force of law, so people and businesses must follow it. Congress gives agencies the power to make rules, largely because agencies have technical experts. Congress keeps control by watching agencies, changing their laws, or overturning their rules.
Most rules follow a process called notice and comment, set by a law called the Administrative Procedure Act. First, the agency publishes a proposed rule in the Federal Register, the government’s daily publication of rules and notices. The proposal names the agency’s legal authority. Second, the public may comment, usually for at least 30 days, often through the website Regulations.gov. Third, the agency reviews the comments and may change the rule. Fourth, it publishes the final rule with an explanation and responses to the comments. A final rule usually takes effect at least 30 days later.
Checks remain. Congress can overturn a rule by passing a resolution of disapproval. Courts can throw out rules that are unreasonable, go beyond the agency’s legal power, or break the Constitution.
Source: Congressional Research Service, An Overview of Federal Regulations and the Rulemaking Process (IF10003, updated July 15, 2026) (everycrsreport.com)