describe and compare ways communities deal with scarcity, using drought and water supply as the case.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Our class has 30 students and 6 sample laptops for a project. List two fair ways to decide who uses them first.
During a drought, which tool do you think water utilities often use first?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Scarcity in a community. When there is not enough of something a whole community needs, people must decide who gets it, how much, and what gets cut. Every way of deciding helps some people and costs others something.
Four common tools. (1) Rules or rationing: limits, such as watering only on certain days. (2) Prices: charging more so people use less. (3) Conservation: using less and wasting less, like fixing leaks. (4) New supply: finding or building more, like a new reservoir or reusing treated water. Communities also use first-come-first-served, sign-up lists and lotteries for scarce space or time.
Worked example 1: a watering rule. In a sample town during a drought, the water authority lets even-numbered addresses water lawns on Tuesdays and odd-numbered addresses on Thursdays. Rosa lists the effects: water use drops, everyone is treated the same, but a family with a vegetable garden may lose crops. Rules are simple, but they do not fit every need.
Worked example 2: using price. A different sample town charges a higher rate for each gallon above a household’s normal use. Devon notes that people now have an incentive, a reason, to save water, and that families who truly need more can still buy it. But he also asks: is a higher price harder on families with less money? Both points are fair.
Closer to home. Western Pennsylvania usually has plenty of rain, but our state does sometimes declare drought watches and warnings for counties, and people are asked to save water. Scarcity can arrive anywhere.
No perfect answer. Economists compare tools by asking: Does it work? Is it fair? What does it cost, and who pays? Thoughtful people weigh these differently, which is why communities debate them.
Use the reading and the four tools. Discuss before you answer.
Apply the tools to a different scarce resource.
Our community has one public park field and three youth teams that want it on Saturday mornings. Propose a way to share it. Explain who gains, who gives something up, and why your plan is fair.
Communities choose among rules, prices, conservation and new supply. Next we follow money as it flows between households and businesses.
Exit ticket: which tool would you use first in a water shortage, and what is its biggest cost?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 10, guided practice 12, park problem 5.
Accuracy: the EPA page names the 2012 drought, weekly drought map updates, possible outdoor watering limits and possible higher prices. The two sample towns are invented. Pennsylvania’s drought watches and warnings are declared by the state; check the current status if students ask.
Nonpartisan: present both the efficiency argument for prices and the fairness concern. Do not declare one tool best.
Likely misconceptions: that scarcity is solved by one perfect rule; that higher prices are always unfair or always fair.
Supports: a two-column benefit/cost organizer. Stretch: combine two tools into one plan.
Answer guide: strong park plans name a method (rotation, sign-up, lottery, fee), identify who gains and who gives up time, and give a fairness reason.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, WaterSense: Drought & WaterSense · U.S. government work, public domain
A drought is a long period with much less rain or snow than usual. The Environmental Protection Agency says drought happens somewhere in the United States every year. It calls drought a slow motion natural disaster because it builds over weeks and months. Economic losses can reach billions of dollars, as they did in the 2012 drought.
Scientists track drought closely. A national drought map is updated every week, and the National Weather Service issues statements for areas in serious drought. In some places, especially the West, the trend is toward hotter and drier conditions.
Water utilities, the public or private systems that deliver water, must keep enough water for firefighting and other critical needs. During a drought they may limit outdoor watering. The EPA also warns that water shortages could raise the price customers pay.
Households can help. The EPA asks people to follow local water rules, fix leaks, choose water-saving fixtures, and water lawns less. It points out that grass does not need to be green all year. People can even catch the cold water that runs while a shower warms up and use it on plants.
Source: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, WaterSense: Drought & WaterSense (epa.gov)