explain the presidential election process, from primaries to the Electoral College, and compare arguments people make for and against the Electoral College.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. When you vote for president, are you voting directly for a person? Write yes, no or not sure, and one reason.
How many electoral votes does a candidate need to become president?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
The full path. According to USAGov, states and parties hold primaries and caucuses from about January to June of an election year. Parties hold national conventions from July to early September to nominate candidates. The general election is in early November. Electors cast their votes in December, Congress counts them in early January, and the president is inaugurated on January 20.
Arguments people make for it. Supporters say the Electoral College fits our federal system, in which states matter; that candidates must win support across many states rather than only in the largest cities; and that a close national race can be settled state by state.
Arguments people make against it. Critics say a candidate can win the presidency without winning the most votes nationwide, which happened in 2000 and 2016 and in the 1800s; that candidates focus on a few closely divided “swing” states; and that a vote can seem to count for more in some states than in others. Some propose a national popular vote, which would take a constitutional amendment or an agreement among states.
Worked example 1: doing the math. Zara checks Pennsylvania’s 19 electoral votes. Pennsylvania has 17 members in the U.S. House after the 2020 Census, plus 2 senators, which equals 19. She writes, “The number matches the rule in the reading.”
Worked example 2: a fair comparison. Noah writes one sentence for each side, then labels each as a value: supporters stress the role of states; critics stress that every vote should count equally. “Both sides care about fairness. They define it differently.”
Today’s task. You will explain the process accurately and describe both sides so well that someone on either side would say, “Yes, that is my argument.”
Use the reading and the process timeline.
Build an election-year timeline.
Make a timeline from January of an election year to January 20 of the next year with at least six labeled steps. Under the Electoral College step, add one supporting and one critical argument.
We weighed a real debate. Next we ask what makes someone a good public servant.
Exit ticket: what is one fact about the Electoral College that both supporters and critics would agree is true?
Pacing: Do Now 4 min, reading 8, mini lesson 10, practice 10, timeline 8.
Accuracy: reading facts are from archives.gov; the calendar is from USAGov’s presidential election process page; Pennsylvania’s 19 electoral votes are from pa.gov. Popular-vote and electoral-vote winners differed in 2000 and 2016, and in 1876 and 1888.
Nonpartisan rule: the Electoral College debate is not a party-line issue in every era; keep it about rules and values. Do not ask which side students favor. The 2000 and 2016 examples are facts about outcomes, not judgments about winners.
Likely misconceptions: that the Electoral College is a building; that electors are always free to vote however they like (state laws vary).
Supports: a timeline template and an argument sorting mat. Stretch: research the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact and explain how it would work, without endorsing it.
Answer guide: facts both sides accept: 538 electors, 270 to win, most states are winner-take-all.
National Archives, What is the Electoral College? · U.S. government work, public domain
The National Archives explains that the Electoral College is a process, not a place. The writers of the Constitution set it up partly as a compromise between having Congress choose the president and having citizens elect the president by popular vote.
There are 538 electors. A candidate needs a majority, 270 electoral votes, to become president. Each state has as many electors as it has members of Congress: one for each member of the U.S. House plus two for its two senators. The District of Columbia has three electors under the 23rd Amendment.
Each candidate has a group of electors in each state, usually chosen by the candidate’s party. When you vote for a presidential candidate, you are really voting for that candidate’s electors. State laws differ on how electors are chosen and what they must do.
Most states use a winner-take-all system: the candidate who wins the state’s popular vote gets all of its electors. Maine and Nebraska use a form of proportional representation instead, so their electors can be split between candidates. After the electors vote, Congress meets in a joint session to count the electoral votes.
Source: National Archives, What is the Electoral College? (archives.gov)