write a claim-evidence-reasoning answer to the unit puzzle using evidence from the whole part, and fairly compare viewpoints on global supply chains.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Reread our puzzle: a T-shirt may be made from cotton grown in one country, sewn in another and sold in a third. Write the best one-sentence answer you can give right now.
Which idea from this unit do you think explains the puzzle best?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Bringing it together. We now have evidence from every investigation: scarcity forces choices, prices come from supply and demand, competition pushes costs down, and trade rules built since 1944 lowered tariffs. Today we use them to answer our puzzle.
A strong argument. It has a claim that answers the question, evidence from named sources, reasoning that connects evidence to claim, and a counterclaim: a fair statement of another view, with a response.
Worked example 1: from weak to strong. Nadia’s first claim: “Shirts are cheap because of trade.” It is vague. Her revision: “A T-shirt made across three countries can cost less because each country specializes in the step it does at lowest cost, and competition among producers keeps prices down.” Her evidence: the U.S. supplied more than 35 percent of world cotton exports, and over 70 percent of U.S. cotton yarn and fabric exports go to Honduras, the Dominican Republic and Mexico, where shirts are sewn.
Worked example 2: adding a counterclaim. Eli adds: “Some people argue that global supply chains cost American workers jobs, because sewing that once happened in U.S. factories moved abroad. That is a real cost for those workers and towns. Still, the evidence shows consumers pay less and U.S. cotton farms gain customers.” He stated the other view fairly before responding.
Other perspectives. Workers in sewing countries gain jobs, but people also raise concerns about pay and working conditions there. Long supply chains can also break, as when a disaster or shipping delay leaves shelves empty. A complete answer notices these perspectives.
Ready for Build. In Part 2 you will turn this thinking into booths for The Smart Choices Economy Fair and add personal finance tools for visitors.
Gather evidence from today’s reading and your earlier notes.
Write your full answer to the unit puzzle.
Why would making a T-shirt in three countries cost less? Write a CER paragraph with at least two pieces of evidence from named sources, clear reasoning, and one fair counterclaim with your response.
We solved our puzzle with evidence. In Part 2 we build the fair.
Exit ticket: which booth will your answer help most, and what is one question visitors might ask you?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 7, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, CER writing 8.
Accuracy: reading facts are from the ERS cotton page (also used in 2.01). That U.S. apparel sewing jobs declined as production moved abroad is well established; concerns about wages and conditions in sewing countries are real and debated. No company or brand is named.
Nonpartisan: students may argue that trade helps or hurts more; grade the use of evidence and the fairness of the counterclaim, not the side chosen.
Likely misconceptions: that only wages explain lower costs (also specialization, scale and competition); that the counterclaim weakens an argument.
Supports: CER organizer with an evidence bank from 2.01-2.13. Stretch: add how a tariff would change the puzzle’s answer.
Answer guide: strong answers cite specialization (U.S. cotton, sewing abroad), competition and lower trade barriers; counterclaims address U.S. job losses, working conditions or supply chain risks, followed by a reasoned response.
USDA Economic Research Service, Cotton Sector at a Glance · U.S. government work, public domain
Let us read our first source again, this time as economists. The United States grows a lot of cotton, but India and China grow more. Even so, in the years this page describes, the United States was the world’s top cotton exporter, supplying more than 35 percent of the raw cotton sold between countries. (Brazil has since passed it in some years, a reminder that trade rankings change.)
U.S. farms are well suited to the crop. Cotton grows across 17 southern states, from Virginia to California, and Texas alone grows about 40 percent. In the 2019 marketing year, farms produced nearly 20 million bales, a crop worth about $7 billion.
Much of what happens next takes place outside the country. The United States sends cotton yarn and fabric abroad, and more than 70 percent of those exports go to Honduras, the Dominican Republic and Mexico. Those are places where clothing is sewn.
A single bale, about 480 pounds, can become roughly 1,200 T-shirts. That means one American field can supply shirts that are sewn in another country and sold in many more.
Each country in this chain does a different job, which is the heart of specialization.
Source: USDA Economic Research Service, Cotton Sector at a Glance (ers.usda.gov)