analyze why a free press matters in a democracy and write a clear, accurate summary of our proposal that a reporter or guest could share.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. How do people in a town learn what their council decided last night? List every way you can think of. Then read about a printer who was jailed for what he published.
What argument did Andrew Hamilton make to defend John Peter Zenger?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Why a free press matters. The First Amendment says Congress shall make no law abridging, or limiting, the freedom of the press. A free press lets reporters tell the public what government is doing, including mistakes. In a democracy, citizens need accurate information to vote, speak and hold leaders accountable. Without a free press, leaders could hide what they do.
The press at the local level. Local newspapers, radio, TV and news websites cover council meetings, school boards and budgets. The Sunshine Act even requires public notice of meetings to be published in a newspaper. When local news shrinks, fewer people know what their governments decide.
Freedom with responsibility. Freedom of the press does not protect knowingly false, harmful statements. Good journalists check facts, use more than one source and correct errors. Student publications in schools have some limits: in Hazelwood v. Kuhlmeier (1988), the Supreme Court ruled that a public school may limit a school-sponsored newspaper when stories conflict with its educational mission.
Worked example 1: Sofia writes a press summary. Sofia’s team writes a 75-word summary of their park-lighting proposal. It answers who, what, where, when, why and how. She includes one checked fact with its source and labels the cost as an estimate. She removes the phrase “the council never cares,” because it is an opinion she cannot prove.
Worked example 2: Andre checks a news claim. Andre finds a post saying the library will close on Saturdays. Before using it, he checks the library’s own website and a local news story. Only one source supports the claim, and it says the change is just being discussed. He writes: “The library board is discussing Saturday hours.” Corroboration keeps his proposal accurate.
Our Getting the Word Out section. Each team writes a short summary a guest, a school newsletter or a reporter could share. Sharing it outside class is optional and needs teacher approval.
Use the reading and the worked examples.
Write the Getting the Word Out section.
Write a press summary of your proposal in 75 words or fewer. Answer who, what, where, when, why and how.
Using the Zenger case as evidence, explain why freedom of the press is important in a democracy.
A free press is the public’s window into government. Careful writers keep that window clear.
Exit ticket: what could happen in a town if no one reported on its council meetings?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture 9, guided practice 13, writing 8, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that free press means anything can be printed without consequence; that the press is part of government; that Andrew Hamilton is Alexander Hamilton.
Supports: provide a 5W1H summary frame. When students evaluate news, keep examples local and practical and avoid partisan outlets or topics. Stretch: compare Zenger (1735) with Hazelwood (1988).
Answer guide: summaries should stay within 75 words, include a checked fact and label estimates. Strong Zenger answers cite truth as a defense, the not-guilty verdict and the link to the First Amendment. Exit tickets: residents would not know decisions, mistakes or meeting dates; leaders would be less accountable. Hazelwood facts are from the U.S. Courts Supreme Court Landmarks page.
National Park Service, Federal Hall National Memorial, The Trial of John Peter Zenger · U.S. government work, public domain
In colonial New York, a printer named John Peter Zenger published writing that criticized the royal governor, William Cosby. Zenger was charged with seditious libel, meaning printing false and harmful statements that stirred people against the government.
The case was unfair from the start. In April 1735, the court disbarred, or removed, Zenger’s lawyers. It assigned a young lawyer with little experience. Zenger sat in jail for about a year before his trial began on August 4, 1735, in New York’s City Hall.
Zenger’s supporters hired Andrew Hamilton, an experienced lawyer from Philadelphia. He was not related to Alexander Hamilton. Andrew Hamilton argued that the truth is a defense against libel. In other words, printing true criticism of a leader should not be a crime. The jury agreed and found Zenger not guilty.
The National Park Service explains that the case inspired the city and helped advance the cause of freedom that led to the American Revolution about forty years later. It also helped pave the way for the First Amendment, which protects freedom of speech and of the press.
Source: National Park Service, Federal Hall National Memorial, The Trial of John Peter Zenger (nps.gov)