choose a local, practical issue, match it to the level of government that can act, and plan a civic action proposal that meets our criteria.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Think of one small problem you see on the way to school: a faded crosswalk, a dark path, a park with no shade. Who do you think has the power to fix it? Write your guess, then read today’s short reading.
In Pennsylvania, must a borough council let the public comment before it makes a decision?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Civic designers, welcome to Build. In this unit we asked a driving question: how can we research a real community issue and present a civic action proposal to the right level of government? For the next two weeks your team will build that proposal and present it to a classroom panel or an invited guest. Contacting a real official is optional. It is never required.
What a civic action proposal is. It is a short, researched plan that names a problem, shows evidence, names who can solve it, and suggests realistic steps. Our issue must be local (close to home), practical (it can really be done) and nonpartisan (it is not about supporting a party or candidate). Good examples: a crosswalk near school, lighting in a park, library hours, a bench at a bus stop, litter on a trail.
Why the right level matters. A borough or township council handles local streets, parks and local rules called ordinances. A school board handles school policies. Allegheny County runs county services and parks. The state handles state roads and state law. Congress handles national issues. Sending a park-bench idea to Congress wastes everyone’s time. Sending it to the council that owns the park can work.
Worked example 1: Marisol picks a level. Marisol’s team wants a crosswalk painted near the middle school. She checks who owns the road. If it is a local street, the decision belongs to the borough or township. If it is a state road, PennDOT, the state transportation department, must be involved. She writes: “Right level: local, unless the road is a state route. Question mark: find out who owns the road.”
Worked example 2: Devon turns a complaint into a proposal. Devon starts with “The park is boring.” That is an opinion. He revises: “The park has no lighting on its main path, so families leave before dark. We propose two solar path lights, decided by the township commissioners.” Now it names a problem, a step and a decision-maker.
Rights and responsibilities. Citizens have the right to speak at public meetings, petition and vote when old enough. With those rights come responsibilities: get facts right, listen to others and follow fair meeting rules. The political process works only when people take part responsibly.
Our criteria and constraints. The panel will judge every proposal by these rules.
| Criterion | What it means |
|---|---|
| Researched | Every fact traces to a named source. Any invented number is labelled sample. |
| Right Level | We name the level of government (local, county, state or national) and the body or role that can act, such as a borough council or a school board. |
| Fair | We show more than one viewpoint, speak respectfully and do not endorse any party or candidate. |
| Practical | Our steps are realistic, with a cost estimate and an idea of where the money could come from. |
| Clear | A guest can follow our proposal in about four minutes. |
| Constraints | One-page proposal plus one visual. Four minutes to present, two for questions. Roles, not names of current officeholders. Contacting officials is optional. |
Work with your team and keep the reading open.
Start your own planning page.
Write your team's issue as one problem sentence: who is affected, where, and why it matters. Put a question mark next to any fact you still need to check.
Using the reading, explain one right citizens have at a Pennsylvania public meeting and one responsibility that goes with it.
A strong proposal starts with the right question: not just “what is wrong?” but “who can fix it, and how will we show them?”
Exit ticket: why does taking part in the political process, even at a small local meeting, matter for responsible citizens?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 9, guided practice 13, planning page 7, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that the President or Congress decides everything; that public comment means the council must do what speakers ask; that nonpartisan means having no opinion (students may argue for a practical solution, they just do not endorse parties or candidates).
Supports: provide a level-of-government sort card (local, county, state, national). Approve issues before teams commit; steer away from issues that single out private people or businesses. Stretch: ask a team to find out who owns their road or park. Civics here is nonpartisan: we study how decisions are made and how to argue fairly, never which party, candidate or ballot position to support.
Answer guide: rights: speak during public comment, attend, record; responsibilities: follow time limits, be accurate and respectful. Exit tickets should connect participation to decisions being better informed and to holding government accountable. Part 1 of this unit introduced levels of government and lawmaking; this lesson restates the criteria so it stands alone.
Pennsylvania Office of Open Records, Sunshine Act · Commonwealth of Pennsylvania public information; retold in our own words with a link to the source
Pennsylvania has a law called the Sunshine Act. The name comes from an idea: government works best when its decisions happen in the light, where people can see them. The law covers state and local bodies that do the public’s business, such as councils, boards, authorities and commissions.
When a quorum (enough members to do business) meets to discuss or vote, the meeting must be open to the public. People must get notice of the date, time and place. Since 2021, the agenda, or list of items to discuss, must be posted at least 24 hours ahead, including online if the agency has a website.
Most important for citizens, the public may comment on matters before the agency. The agency must give a reasonable chance to comment before it decides. It may set fair rules, such as a time limit, and it may limit comment to people who live or pay taxes in the area. Answering questions is not required, but the state recommends it.
Meetings may be recorded on audio or video. The minutes, or official notes, must list each member’s vote and the names of citizens who spoke and their topics. Votes may not happen in closed sessions.
Source: Pennsylvania Office of Open Records, Sunshine Act (openrecords.pa.gov)