Our Civic Action Proposal
How can we research a real community issue and present a civic action proposal to the right level of government?
The mystery: A bill can be introduced in Congress and never get a vote, while a local ordinance can change a street within weeks. Where does a citizen have the most power to make change?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
describe the basic path of a federal bill and explain why our civic action proposal must go to the right level of government.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Think of one thing near school or home you would change if you could: a crosswalk, a park bench, library hours, a broken streetlight. Write it on a sticky note. Then guess who has the power to fix it.
Which usually moves faster: a new national law from Congress or a local rule about one street?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Welcome, civic investigators. This unit gives you a real job. Your team will choose a practical issue in our community, research it, and present a civic action proposal to the level of government that can actually act on it. Your audience will be real people who serve the public.
Three levels. The federal government in Washington, D.C., makes laws for the whole country. The state government in Harrisburg makes laws for Pennsylvania. Local governments, such as Allegheny County and our boroughs and townships, make rules called ordinances for their own communities.
Our puzzle. A bill in Congress can be introduced and never get a vote. A local ordinance can change a street within weeks. So where does a citizen have the most power to make change? We will not guess. We will find out.
Worked example 1: following the steps. Aaliyah reads the USAGov page and lists the federal path: introduced, committee, vote in one chamber, the same in the other chamber, agree on one version, then the president. She counts at least six places where a bill could stop. She writes, “A federal bill has many checkpoints, so it can take a long time.”
Worked example 2: matching an issue to a level. Marcus wants a crosswalk painted near a park. He asks, “Would Congress write a law about one crosswalk?” Probably not. A crosswalk on a local street is usually handled by the local government, or by the state if it is a state road. Marcus adds a question to the Wonder Board: “Who owns the road by the park?”
Our promise. Civic investigators look for evidence, name their sources, and treat people who disagree with respect. In this class we study how government works. No one will be told what party or policy to support.
Keep the reading open. Point to the sentence that gives you each answer.
Start your page for the class Wonder Board.
Draw a simple flowchart of the federal path from bill to law with at least five boxes. Circle two places where a bill could stop.
Write two questions you wonder about how change happens in our community. Put each on a sticky note for the Wonder Board.
We met our puzzle and our job. Next time we sort our questions by level of government.
Exit ticket: why might it matter which level of government our proposal goes to?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, Wonder Board 7.
Nonpartisan frame: set the norm on day one that we study processes and weigh evidence; no one is asked to share a party or how their family votes. Steer issues toward local, practical topics (parks, safety, libraries, streets).
Likely misconceptions: that the president makes laws alone; that every problem is solved by Congress; that local rules are not “real” laws.
Accuracy: congress.gov blocked automated requests when this lesson was written, so the reading uses USAGov. If you want a fuller version, the Library of Congress’s congress.gov legislative process pages cover the same steps.
Supports: give a partly drawn flowchart. Stretch: ask why the framers made lawmaking slow on purpose.
Answer guide: strong flowcharts show introduction, committee, first chamber vote, second chamber, agreement on one text, and the president, with veto and override as a branch. Exit tickets should mention that each level handles different problems and moves at different speeds.
USAGov, How laws are made · U.S. government work, public domain
Congress is the lawmaking branch of the federal government. It has two parts, or chambers: the House of Representatives and the Senate. A bill is a written idea for a new law.
Ideas for bills can come from members of Congress, from promises made during a campaign, or from citizens and groups who ask their representative for a change. After a bill is introduced, a committee, a small group of members, studies it, discusses it and may change it. Then the whole chamber votes. If the bill passes, the other chamber goes through a similar process.
The House and the Senate must agree on exactly the same words. Then the bill goes to the president, who can sign it into law or veto it, which means reject it. In most cases, Congress can vote to override a veto. If the president does not sign a bill and Congress is no longer in session, the bill is vetoed automatically. This is called a pocket veto, and Congress cannot override it.
The two chambers have some special jobs. Only the House can start bills about taxes. Only the Senate votes on presidential nominations and treaties.
Source: USAGov, How laws are made (usa.gov)