Our Civic Action Proposal
How can we research a real community issue and present a civic action proposal to the right level of government?
The mystery: A bill can be introduced in Congress and never get a vote, while a local ordinance can change a street within weeks. Where does a citizen have the most power to make change?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
sort community questions by the level of government that handles them and describe the local governments that serve our area.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Write the name of the place where you live. Is it a city, a borough or a township? If you are not sure, write your best guess.
About how many active township governments does Pennsylvania have?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Layers of government. Every person in our community lives under several governments at once: the United States, Pennsylvania, Allegheny County, a city, borough or township, and a school district. Each one handles different jobs.
Our area. Allegheny County has 130 municipalities. The East Allegheny School District serves North Versailles Township and the boroughs of East McKeesport, Wall and Wilmerding. Each has its own elected leaders who pass local ordinances.
Who handles what? In general, the federal government handles things like the military, the mail and national money. The state handles things like driver’s licenses, state roads and state parks. Counties often run courts, elections, county parks and health services. Municipalities often handle local streets, police, zoning and trash pickup. Real cases can overlap, so we always check.
Worked example 1: sorting a question. Priya’s question is “Who runs our elections?” She learns that in Pennsylvania, counties run elections, following state and federal law. She places her sticky note under “county” and draws arrows to “state” and “federal.”
Worked example 2: when you are not sure. Diego asks, “Who fixes the potholes on our main road?” It depends on who owns the road: the borough, the county or the state. Diego writes “check road owner” on his note. A good investigator labels what is still unknown.
Today’s workshop. We will sort the Wonder Board into federal, state, county, municipal and school district columns, plus a column for “we need to find out.”
Use the reading and talk with your team before you answer.
Build your own government layers chart.
Make a chart with five rows: federal, state, county, municipality, school district. For each row, write the name of the government that serves you and one job it does.
Pick one issue from the Wonder Board that you might want for our civic action proposal. Explain why it matters to people in our community.
We know who is who. Next we investigate the rights and responsibilities of the citizens who make these governments work.
Exit ticket: why might having many local governments help citizens? Why might it confuse them?
Pacing: Do Now 4 min, reading 8, mini lesson 8, Wonder Board sort 15, closure 5.
Accuracy: the Census counts are 2010 geography; keep the year attached. The Allegheny County municipality list shows 130 municipalities, including North Versailles (township) and East McKeesport, Wall and Wilmerding (boroughs). Some students may live in other municipalities; welcome that.
Likely misconceptions: that the county runs the schools; that a borough is part of a township; that local government has no real power.
Supports: provide a sorting mat with column headers and example jobs. Stretch: find a question that truly belongs to two levels and explain why.
Answer guide: strong exit tickets note that local government is close and easier to reach, but that many layers can make it hard to know who is responsible.
U.S. Census Bureau, Guide to 2010 State and Local Census Geography: Pennsylvania · U.S. government work, public domain
The U.S. Census Bureau counts people, and it also counts governments. Its guide to Pennsylvania, based on the 2010 Census, shows how the state is divided.
Pennsylvania has 67 counties. Philadelphia is special: the county and the city are joined and work as one government.
Inside the counties are smaller units. The Census Bureau found 1,546 townships with working governments. It also counted 1,015 incorporated places, which are communities with their own local governments: 954 boroughs, 57 cities, 3 places called municipalities and 1 town. A borough or city is separate from the townships around it, and the guide says these local governments have the same kinds of powers.
Pennsylvania also had 501 school districts. A school district is a government too. It has an elected school board that makes decisions about public schools.
The numbers are from 2010, so a few may have changed since then. Still, they show why Pennsylvania is known for having a large number of local governments. For a citizen, that means many places where decisions are made close to home.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Guide to 2010 State and Local Census Geography: Pennsylvania (census.gov)