choose a community issue, argue with claim, evidence and reasoning which level of government should hear it, and plan a fair proposal.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look back at your 1.06 exit ticket about where citizens have the most power. Has your answer changed? Write one sentence.
In Pittsburgh, how many signatures from eligible voters does a resident need on a petition to request a City Council public hearing?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Putting it together. You have studied rights and duties, three levels of lawmaking, agencies, courts, conflict skills, elections, leadership, interest groups and media. Now your team will answer our driving question for one real issue.
Choosing an issue. A good issue is local and practical (parks, safety, libraries, streets, recycling), affects real people, has evidence you can find, and has a decision maker you can reach. Avoid issues where the only question is which party is right.
Choosing the level. Ask: Who owns or runs this? Who has the legal power to change it: a council, a board, an agency, the General Assembly or Congress? What are their steps and timing? A request to the wrong body may be polite, but it cannot succeed.
Worked example 1: a CER for the level. Maya’s team chooses faded crosswalk paint near a park. Claim: our borough council is the right audience. Evidence: the street is a borough street, and local ordinances and budgets are passed at public meetings with time for public comment. Reasoning: the body that owns the street and passes its budget can act fastest.
Worked example 2: planning for other views. Kenji’s team wants longer library hours. They list who might disagree: people worried about cost and staff who would work late. They plan a compromise to suggest: one later evening a week as a trial. They also list the leadership qualities from 1.12 that their audience is likely to value: careful use of money and listening to residents.
Our criteria. The panel will judge every proposal by five criteria. Researched: every fact traces to a named source, and invented numbers are labelled sample. Right Level: it names the level of government and the body or role that decides. Fair: it shows more than one viewpoint, speaks respectfully and does not endorse any party or candidate. Practical: its steps are realistic, with a cost estimate and an idea of where the money could come from. Clear: a guest can follow it in about four minutes.
Next steps. In Part 2 you will research more deeply, draft, get feedback and present your proposal. Today’s plan is the blueprint.
Use the reading, your Wonder Board and your notes from 1.01-1.13.
Complete your team’s proposal plan.
Fill in the plan: issue; who it affects; the government body and level; its steps and next meeting date; two pieces of evidence you have; two you still need; one other viewpoint; and one possible compromise.
Write a CER paragraph answering the driving question for your issue. Use at least two sources from this unit.
Our evidence points to a level and an audience. In Part 2 we build the proposal and present it.
Exit ticket: finish the sentence for our audience: “We came to you because…”
Pacing: Do Now 4 min, reading 7, mini lesson 7, practice 10, planning 12.
Sources: the reading is a Carnegie Mellon civic guide (copyrighted; summarized only). Its county steps go beyond what the county’s own page states; teach them as “according to this guide” and, if possible, confirm with the Home Rule Charter or Council staff. Numbers such as 8 of 15 assume all seats are filled.
Issue screening: approve each team’s issue. Keep issues local and practical; steer away from issues that turn on party identity. Students do not contact officials until Part 2, with teacher and family approval.
Likely misconceptions: that one person with a good idea can change a law alone; that the most famous official is always the right audience.
Supports: a one-page plan template and a bank of sources from 1.01-1.13. Stretch: map a two-level issue (for example, a state road through a borough) and plan a request to each.
Answer guide: a strong plan names the correct body, its steps and timing, real evidence, at least one other viewpoint described fairly, and a realistic compromise. Keep plans for Part 2.
Carnegie Mellon University, Student Affairs, Voter Resources: Municipal Advocacy · Copyright Carnegie Mellon University; summarized in our own words, not copied
This guide from a Pittsburgh university explains how residents can take part in local lawmaking. At Allegheny County Council, a member introduces an ordinance or resolution at a meeting. The Council President assigns it to a committee, which may hold hearings and suggest changes. The full Council considers it at two meetings at least seven days apart. Passing it takes a majority of seated members, usually 8 of 15.
The County Executive can sign it or veto it. If the executive takes no action, it becomes law after seven days. Council can override a veto with a two-thirds vote, 10 of 15, within 30 days.
Pittsburgh City Council works in a similar way. The mayor can sign or veto a bill, and Council can override a veto with six of nine votes. In the city, residents can request a public hearing with a petition signed by 25 eligible voters. The guide says the county has no similar petition process.
To speak at County Council, a resident submits a request at least 24 hours ahead and gets three minutes. City Council registration closes one hour before the meeting. Registered speakers get three minutes.
Source: Carnegie Mellon University, Student Affairs, Voter Resources: Municipal Advocacy (cmu.edu)