explain how a proposal could become a rule at the local, state or federal level and how agencies like a zoning board make and enforce rules.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Our unit began with a puzzle: a bill can sit in Congress for years, while a local ordinance can change a street within weeks. Read the steps of a federal bill and count how many places it could stall.
According to the reading, where can an idea for a federal bill come from?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Three paths, one pattern. At every level, an idea is proposed, studied, debated, voted on and then carried out. The federal path goes through two chambers and the President. Pennsylvania’s General Assembly works the same way, with a House, a Senate and the Governor, who can sign or veto. A borough council or township board usually has one body, so the path is shorter.
The local path. In a Pennsylvania borough or township, a proposed ordinance is placed on a public agenda, advertised ahead of time, discussed at an open meeting with public comment, and then voted on by the council or commissioners. Some requests, like painting a crosswalk or fixing a light, do not need a new ordinance at all. Staff can carry them out within the budget.
Agencies make and enforce rules. Lawmakers cannot handle every detail, so they give agencies the power to apply laws. A local zoning hearing board decides requests to use land differently from the zoning rules. A planning commission advises on how land is used. At the national level, the Federal Communications Commission makes rules about radio, television and communications. Agencies hold hearings, take public comment and enforce their rules.
Worked example 1: Lena maps her path. Lena’s team wants a stop sign on a local street. Her path: write the request, ask the council or its staff to place it on the agenda, speak during public comment, the council asks staff or an engineer to study traffic, then votes. She adds: “If it is a state road, PennDOT must approve.”
Worked example 2: Malik spots an agency. Malik’s team wants a community garden on an empty lot. He learns that zoning rules say what each lot may be used for. If a garden is not allowed there, the zoning hearing board may need to approve an exception. He adds the board to his Right Level section.
Where citizens fit. At every step there is a door: petitions, testimony at hearings, public comment and contacting representatives. Our proposal should name the door we would use.
Use the reading and your process cards.
Finish the Right Level section of your proposal.
Write the decision path for your proposal in three to five sentences. Name the body or agency that would decide, and say whether a new ordinance is needed.
Explain one reason a federal bill might take much longer than a local decision. Use evidence from the reading.
Knowing the path tells you where to knock. The right door saves months.
Exit ticket: return to our unit puzzle. Where does a citizen have the most power to make change, and why?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture 9, career 2, guided practice 12, writing 7, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that every request needs a new law; that agencies make laws on their own without authority from lawmakers; that a veto is always final.
Supports: provide shuffled process cards for federal, state and local paths. Stretch: compare the Pennsylvania General Assembly’s path with Congress’s.
Answer guide: decision paths should name a real body type (council, commissioners, school board, zoning hearing board, PennDOT for state roads) and a citizen door. Federal delay reasons: two chambers, committees, identical versions, veto. Exit tickets usually argue local, citing shorter paths and public comment; accept well-reasoned alternatives. Career facts are from the BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook, Urban and Regional Planners.
USAGov, How laws are made · U.S. government work, public domain
A federal law starts as a bill, a written proposal for a new law. The idea can come from a member of Congress, from a promise made during a campaign, or from a petition that citizens send to their representative.
Next, the bill goes to a committee, a smaller group of lawmakers who study one subject. The committee researches the bill, debates it and may change it. Then the whole chamber, either the House or the Senate, votes.
If the bill passes, the other chamber repeats the process: committee review, changes and a vote. Both chambers must agree on exactly the same version. Then the bill goes to the President.
The President can sign the bill, making it law, or veto it, which means reject it. Congress can usually override a veto with a vote. If the President does not sign a bill and Congress has adjourned, or ended its session, the bill dies. This is called a pocket veto, and Congress cannot override it.
Each step is a place where a bill can be changed, slowed or stopped. That is one reason many bills never become law.
Source: USAGov, How laws are made (usa.gov)