describe the advantages and disadvantages of competition for consumers in markets, and the government’s role in protecting competition.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Imagine a sample town where only one store sells school supplies. Then a second store opens across the street. List two things that might change for shoppers.
Which part of the federal government enforces laws that keep business competition fair?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
What competition is. Competition is when several sellers try to win the same buyers. Each seller wants customers to choose it, so it tries to offer a better deal.
Advantages for consumers. As the reading says, competition gives consumers more options and better prices, because businesses compete on price and quality. Economists add that it pushes sellers to create new products. Sellers who ignore customers can lose them to a rival.
Disadvantages and limits. Competition is not perfect for consumers either. A business that loses may close, and its workers may lose jobs in the community. Sellers competing on price may cut corners on quality or service when buyers cannot easily tell the difference. Lots of choices can take time to compare, and advertising can make choices confusing. And in some places, such as small towns, there may be too few buyers to support more than one seller.
Worked example 1: two shops. In a sample neighborhood, one pizza shop charged $14 for a large pie (sample). A second shop opens and charges $12. Within a month, the first shop lowers its price to $12 and adds a free salad deal. Ellie notes the advantage for consumers: lower prices and more value. She also notes the risk: if one shop cannot cover its costs, it may close.
Worked example 2: one seller. Rosa’s sample town has one hardware store, 20 miles from the next. She notes that it can charge more because shoppers have few other options. But she also notes a benefit: the town has a store at all, and its owner knows local needs. Rosa writes a balanced conclusion with both sides.
Government’s role. In a market economy, government does not usually set prices for most goods. But it does make and enforce rules, like antitrust laws, so that businesses compete fairly. People disagree about how much government should step in, and our fair will present those views fairly.
Use the reading and both worked examples.
Write a balanced visitor tip.
Write a “Smart Shopper Tip” card that explains how a consumer can benefit from competition (for example, comparing prices and quality) and one thing to watch out for. Do not name any brand or store.
Competition shapes price, quality and choice. Next we ask how the government measures whether prices across the whole economy are rising.
Exit ticket: in a town with one store, what could consumers do to get a better deal?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 12, guided practice 10, tip card 5.
Accuracy: the reading’s points come from the Justice Department’s “Antitrust Laws and You” page (last updated December 20, 2023). The disadvantages and the innovation point in the mini lesson are standard economics points, not from that page; say so if students ask. The FTC also enforces antitrust law. Pizza and hardware examples are sample.
Nonpartisan: how actively government should enforce competition rules is debated. Present it as a question, not a settled answer.
Likely misconceptions: that competition only means lower prices; that the government sets most prices in the U.S.
Supports: a T-chart of advantages and disadvantages. Stretch: ask when a single seller might make sense (for example, a water system).
Answer guide: balanced answers give one advantage (price, quality, choice, innovation) and one disadvantage (closures, corner-cutting, confusing choices) with examples. Exit tickets might mention traveling, buying online, or buying together.
U.S. Department of Justice, Antitrust Division, Antitrust Laws and You · U.S. government work, public domain
The Antitrust Division of the U.S. Department of Justice enforces the nation’s competition laws, called antitrust laws. Their goal is to keep markets competitive, which gives consumers more options and better prices. A consumer is anyone who buys and uses goods and services. In a competitive market, businesses compete on price and on how good their products are.
Two main laws do this work. The Sherman Act makes it illegal for businesses to work together to unreasonably limit trade, and illegal to monopolize a market, which means to take or keep total control of it by unfair means. The Clayton Act targets other practices that could hurt competition, including mergers that may greatly reduce competition. A merger is when two companies join into one.
Some actions are crimes. When competitors secretly agree to fix prices or wages, or to rig bids so that each takes a turn winning a contract, they can be prosecuted.
The page also warns about predatory pricing: a company sets prices very low on purpose to drive rivals out, then raises them. That can lead to higher prices for consumers and lower wages for workers.
Source: U.S. Department of Justice, Antitrust Division, Antitrust Laws and You (justice.gov)