compare the consequences of breaking Pennsylvania laws and federal laws and explain how due process and appeals protect individuals.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. A proposal can ask for a new rule. Before we ask for one, we should know what happens when rules are broken, and how people stay protected. Which court do you think hears most criminal cases in America: state or federal? Read to check.
Which courts hear most criminal cases?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Two sets of laws. People in Pennsylvania live under Pennsylvania laws and federal laws at the same time. Most everyday crimes, such as theft or vandalism, break state law. Some acts, such as counterfeiting money or mail fraud, break federal law. A few acts can break both.
Different consequences. For a Pennsylvania crime, the county district attorney prosecutes in state court, starting with a magisterial district judge and, for serious crimes, the county Court of Common Pleas. Penalties follow Pennsylvania law and can include fines, probation or state prison. For a federal crime, a U.S. Attorney prosecutes in a U.S. District Court, such as the one for the Western District of Pennsylvania in Pittsburgh. Penalties follow federal law and can include federal prison, fines and restitution, or repayment to victims.
Even officials face consequences. The Sunshine Act is a Pennsylvania law. A council member who willfully breaks it can be fined $100 to $1,000 for a first offense, and the agency cannot pay the fine for them.
Protections for every person. The Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments promise due process: government must follow fair procedures before taking anyone’s life, liberty or property. The Fourteenth Amendment also promises equal protection of the laws. The right to appeal lets a higher court fix mistakes.
Worked example 1: Keisha compares penalties. Keisha makes a two-column chart. State: graffiti on a park wall, county district attorney, state court, possible fine and cleanup costs. Federal: damaging a mailbox, U.S. Attorney, federal court, federal penalties. She notes: “Same kind of act, different law, different system.”
Worked example 2: Omar checks his proposal for fairness. Omar’s team wants a curfew at a skate park. He asks: would the rule treat all people equally? Is there a fair way to warn people before a fine? He revises to a posted closing time with clear signs, which respects due process and equal protection.
Use the reading, the chart and the case study.
Write the Rights and Rules Check for your proposal.
Does your proposal create or change a rule? Explain how it would treat everyone equally and how people would be warned fairly before any penalty.
Explain one difference between the consequences of breaking a Pennsylvania law and breaking a federal law. Use evidence from the reading or lecture.
Clarence Earl Gideon was charged with breaking into a bar in Panama City, Florida. He could not afford a lawyer and asked the judge to appoint one. The judge refused, so Gideon defended himself. He was convicted and sentenced to five years in a Florida state prison.
In prison, Gideon studied law. He argued that his Sixth Amendment right to a lawyer had been violated. The Florida Supreme Court said no, so he wrote to the U.S. Supreme Court, which agreed to hear his case. On March 18, 1963, the Court ruled unanimously for Gideon: people accused of crimes have a right to a lawyer in state and federal courts. At a new trial, with a lawyer, Gideon was found not guilty.
One person’s written request, and the right to appeal, changed the rules for everyone.
Think about it: How did due process and the right to appeal protect Gideon? Which participation tool from our unit does his letter resemble?
Laws carry consequences, and fair process protects everyone, including people accused of breaking them.
Exit ticket: why might the government protect the rights of a person accused of a crime?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture 9, case study 6, guided practice 11, writing 5, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: that all crimes go to federal court; that due process protects only innocent people; that the U.S. Supreme Court must hear every appeal (it may decline).
Supports: provide the two-column chart template. Keep examples minor and avoid real local cases or people. Stretch: research how magisterial district judges handle summary offenses such as littering.
Answer guide: charts: state, county district attorney, magisterial district court or Court of Common Pleas, state penalties; federal, U.S. Attorney, U.S. District Court, federal penalties. Case study: due process required a lawyer; appeal let the Supreme Court correct the trial; his letter resembles a petition. Exit tickets: mistakes happen, and fair process protects everyone. Gideon facts are from the U.S. Courts Supreme Court Landmarks page; federal case steps are from uscourts.gov, Criminal Cases.
United States Courts, Comparing Federal & State Courts · U.S. government work, public domain
The United States has two court systems working side by side. The U.S. Constitution created the Supreme Court, and Congress created the lower federal courts, such as 94 district courts and 13 courts of appeals. Each state’s constitution and laws create that state’s courts.
The two systems hear different kinds of cases. State courts hear most criminal cases, most contract disputes, injury cases, wills and family matters. Federal courts hear cases about whether a law follows the U.S. Constitution, cases under federal laws and treaties, disputes between states, and bankruptcy.
Judges are chosen differently, too. The President nominates federal judges and the Senate confirms them. They usually serve for life. State judges may be elected, appointed for a set term or chosen by a mix of both.
Both systems have a path of appeal, a request for a higher court to review a decision. A federal case can go from a district court to a court of appeals, and the U.S. Supreme Court may agree to hear it. A state case goes to the state’s higher courts. State courts have the final word on state law, but questions about the U.S. Constitution can be taken to the U.S. Supreme Court.
Source: United States Courts, Comparing Federal & State Courts (uscourts.gov)