define the fiscal policy tools of the federal government and compare viewpoints on how to use them, in a claim-evidence-reasoning paragraph.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. List three things in our community that government pays for. Then list one way government gets money.
Which part of the federal budget usually uses more than half of all funding?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
What fiscal policy is. Fiscal policy is the federal government’s use of taxing and spending to affect the economy. Congress and the president share the job through the budget we just read about.
Tool 1: taxes. The federal government collects money mostly through taxes. The U.S. Treasury lists the main sources: individual income taxes (the largest), payroll taxes that fund Social Security and Medicare, corporate income taxes, excise taxes on certain goods, and customs duties on imports, plus fees such as national park entry. Changing tax rates changes how much money households and businesses have left to spend.
Tool 2: spending. Government spends on programs, workers and projects, from Social Security checks to highways to national defense. More spending puts more money into the circular flow; less spending takes some out. When spending is more than the money collected, the government runs a deficit and borrows, which adds to the national debt.
Worked example 1: a pay stub. Kenji earns $200 at a part-time job (sample). His stub shows Social Security tax at 6.2 percent ($12.40) and Medicare tax at 1.45 percent ($2.90). His employer pays a matching amount. Kenji sees fiscal policy in his own paycheck.
Worked example 2: sorting the budget. Amira sorts items: Social Security payments are mandatory; funding for national park staff is discretionary; payments to people who lent the government money are interest. She notices that Congress can easily change only the discretionary part each year without changing other laws.
Real disagreements. People and parties disagree about fiscal policy. Some argue for lower taxes and less spending, so households and businesses keep more of their money and the debt grows more slowly. Others argue for more spending on programs and services, paid for by taxes or borrowing, to help people and build for the future. Economists also disagree about when using these tools helps most, such as during a recession. Our job is to understand each view, not to choose for visitors.
Writing CER. A claim answers the question. Evidence is facts from sources. Reasoning explains why the evidence supports the claim. Today you will write one about the budget.
Use the reading and the mini lesson. Stay fair to every viewpoint.
Write a claim-evidence-reasoning paragraph.
Question: why is it hard for Congress to change most of the federal budget in a single year? Write a claim, two pieces of evidence from the reading, and your reasoning.
Fiscal policy is how the federal government taxes and spends. Next we leave the country’s budget and follow trade between Pennsylvania and the world.
Exit ticket: name one fiscal policy tool and one way it could affect a family in our community.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 12, guided practice 10, CER 5.
Accuracy: budget shares and process from USA.gov. Revenue sources from the Treasury’s Fiscal Data “America’s Finance Guide” revenue page, which says individual income tax is the top source. Employee payroll tax rates (6.2 percent Social Security, 1.45 percent Medicare) are current law; Social Security tax applies up to an annual wage cap. Kenji’s pay is sample.
Nonpartisan: do not let the viewpoint discussion become a vote on parties or leaders. Require students to state the opposing view as its supporters would. Monetary policy by the Federal Reserve is a different tool; if asked, note it is not fiscal policy.
Likely misconceptions: deficit and debt are the same; the president alone sets the budget; most spending is voted on fresh each year.
Supports: CER frame. Stretch: why might economists disagree about spending more in a recession?
Answer guide: CER claims should note that mandatory spending (over half) and interest are set by existing laws and past borrowing, leaving about a third for yearly decisions.
USA.gov, Federal budget process · U.S. government work, public domain
The federal government plans its money in a yearly budget. Its fiscal year, or budget year, runs from October 1 of one year through September 30 of the next.
The budget has three main areas. Mandatory spending pays for programs required by law, such as Social Security, Medicare and veterans’ benefits. It typically uses over half of all funding. Discretionary spending is the money Congress decides on each year for federal agencies. It usually makes up about a third. Interest on the debt, the cost of money the government has borrowed, usually uses less than 10 percent.
Making a budget takes more than a year. Federal agencies send requests to the White House Office of Management and Budget. That office helps build the president’s budget proposal, which the president sends to Congress early in the year. Twelve subcommittees hold hearings on different parts. The House and Senate each write a version, and the two must be joined into one version of each funding bill.
Finally, Congress sends the bills to the president, who can sign them into law or veto them, which means reject them.
Source: USA.gov, Federal budget process (usa.gov)