ask a research question that evidence can answer, tell primary sources from secondary sources and check facts before using them.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Which question can evidence answer? A: “Is our park the best park?” B: “How many people use our park path each Saturday morning?” Explain your choice.
Which is a primary source about a park path?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Good research starts with a good question. A question like “Is our park the best?” asks for an opinion. A question like “How many swings are broken, and since when?” can be answered with evidence.
Primary and secondary sources. A primary source was made at the time by someone who was there: a photo you take, a count you make, a meeting record, an official budget. A secondary source explains or summarizes other sources later: a news story, a textbook, a website article. Strong proposals use both.
Fact, rumor and legend. A fact can be checked. A rumor is a story passed along without proof. Historians check even famous stories. For example, many people believe the Liberty Bell rang on July 4, 1776. The National Park Service says there is no evidence it rang that day. Good researchers say “there is no evidence” instead of repeating a story.
Worked example 1: Keisha’s research question. Keisha’s team studies a sample problem: a crosswalk near a school. Her first question is, “Is the crosswalk scary?” She revises it: “How many students cross there each morning, and can drivers see the lines?” Now the team can count and take photos.
Worked example 2: Owen’s source check. Owen hears a classmate say, “The library is closing forever.” He asks, “Who said that, and how do they know?” He checks the library’s own posted hours, a primary source. The library is open. The rumor goes in the trash, not in the proposal.
Cite every source. Section 7 lists each source: who made it, its title and where to find it. That lets the panel check our work.
Sort sources and sharpen questions with your team.
Start Section 3 and Section 7.
Section 3, Evidence: write two facts for your proposal. Label each one primary or secondary, and explain how you checked it.
Section 7, Sources: list each source with who made it, its title and where to find it.
A panel trusts a proposal it can check.
Exit ticket: how would you check a rumor you heard about your problem?
Pacing: Do Now 4 min, reading 6, mini lecture 10, guided practice 12, Sections 3 and 7 drafts 6, closure 2.
Data collection: counts and photos happen only on school grounds or with a family adult, from the sidewalk. Never send students into traffic. Offer a sample data table if teams cannot collect safely.
Accuracy: the Liberty Bell fact (no evidence of ringing July 4 or 8, 1776) is from the NPS Liberty Bell page, used in Part 1 lesson 2.02.
Likely misconceptions: that anything online is a primary source; that secondary sources are always wrong; that a famous story must be true.
Supports: a sorting mat with sample sources. Stretch: find a record in DocsTeach about a Pennsylvania topic.
Answer guide: questions should be countable or checkable. Primary examples: photos, counts, official schedules, budgets, minutes. Secondary: news stories, articles, textbooks. Checks: ask who made it and how they know, and confirm with an official or original source.
National Archives, Finding Primary Sources for Teachers and Students · U.S. government work, public domain
The National Archives keeps important records of the United States government. Its education page helps students and teachers find primary sources. A primary source is an original record made at the time, such as a letter, photo, map or report.
The page points to DocsTeach, which offers thousands of primary source documents from the National Archives for classroom use. It also points to the National Archives Catalog, a searchable list of records for student projects, and to online exhibits filled with documents and photos.
Some links lead to famous records, such as 100 milestone documents of American history and the papers of the nation’s founders. Other links help beginners: guides for choosing a topic and starting research, and practice activities for new researchers.
The page also cares about honesty in research. It links to guides on how to cite records, which means telling readers exactly where your information came from. It offers a document analysis worksheet, a set of questions that helps you study a source carefully before you use it.
Source: National Archives, Finding Primary Sources for Teachers and Students (archives.gov)