reflect on our trail guide and explain how a Native nation’s story continued and changed after the founding.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Our guide ends around 1824. But the people in it did not stop in 1824. In 1.14 you met the Seneca leader Cornplanter. Reread his story with a new question: what does it teach us about our own guide?
Cornplanter was a leader of which Native nation?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Reflection means looking back to learn. Today you look back at our guide and at yourself as a historian.
Stories keep going. The Lenape moved west, and Delaware nations live today in Oklahoma and Ontario. The Seneca still have ties to the Cornplanter Grant. Black churches founded in the 1790s, like Mother Bethel, still have congregations. A fair guide shows that these peoples did not vanish.
Continuity and change in one story. Change: the Seneca lost most of the Grant to the Kinzua Dam lake. Continuity: Cornplanter’s heirs still own the land above the water, and Seneca traditions continue.
Worked example 1: Jasmine compares viewpoints. Jasmine writes: “Some people saw the Grant as a gift from Pennsylvania. The reading points out that the Seneca already lived there. So the Seneca might see it as keeping their own land. The word we choose shows a point of view.”
Worked example 2: Rafael reflects on criteria. Rafael writes: “Our guide was most accurate on the 1780 law because we had two sources. It was least complete on Native nations after 1800. Next time I would add a Cornplanter stop.” He names a strength, a gap and a next step.
Our driving question. Why did so much of the nation’s founding happen in Pennsylvania, and whose stories are often left out? Your answer now has evidence behind it.
Discuss with your team, then answer.
Write your final reflection.
Answer our driving question in a short paragraph: why did so much of the nation's founding happen in Pennsylvania, and whose stories are often left out? Use two pieces of evidence.
Compare how the Seneca and Pennsylvania officials might have seen the Cornplanter Grant differently.
Historians keep stories alive by telling them accurately and fairly. You did that.
Exit ticket: whose story from our guide will you remember most? Why?
How confident are you that you can I can explain how the people in our guide shaped Pennsylvania and the nation.
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 7, team discussion 10, reflection writing 12, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that Native history ended in the 1700s; that a grant from a government is always a gift. The source does not give the grant year; other sources date the Warren County grant to the 1790s, so the summary avoids a specific year.
Supports: reflection frames (“Our guide was strongest at ___ because ___.”). Stretch: research the Seneca Nation of Indians today using its own official materials.
Answer guide: driving-question answers mention Philadelphia as capital and meeting place (Independence Hall, the Constitution) and name left-out stories (Ona Judge, the Free African Society, the Lenape at Fort Pitt, the Seneca). Viewpoint answers: officials may have seen a reward or gift; the Seneca may have seen it as keeping a homeland and later losing it to the dam.
Pennsylvania Historic Preservation (blog of the Pennsylvania State Historic Preservation Office), The Cornplanter Grant · Copyright Pennsylvania Historic Preservation; retold in our own words with a link to the source
Cornplanter was a Seneca leader. The Seneca are one of the Haudenosaunee nations. In the 1780s and 1790s, Cornplanter sided with the young United States. He helped bring Native nations of the Ohio Country to talks about peace.
Pennsylvania granted Cornplanter and his family three pieces of land. The Seneca already lived on this land, so calling it a “gift” can be misleading. He soon lost two pieces but kept land in Warren County, along the Allegheny River. It became known as the Cornplanter Grant.
The Grant was a center of Seneca life. People gathered wild plants for medicine, made baskets and longbows, hunted, fished and played a winter game called Snow Snake. Cornplanter’s half-brother, Handsome Lake, was a Seneca prophet whose teachings are the basis of the Longhouse religion.
In 1965, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers built Kinzua Dam on the Allegheny River. The lake behind it covered most of the Grant. The Seneca and their supporters fought the dam but lost. Cornplanter’s heirs still own the land above the water.
Source: Pennsylvania Historic Preservation (blog of the Pennsylvania State Historic Preservation Office), The Cornplanter Grant (pahistoricpreservation.com)