explain how the Seneca leader Cornplanter and his people shaped western Pennsylvania, and use evidence from the unit to choose what changed and what endured.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look back through your notebook and the Wonder Board. Which question from lesson 1.01 can you now answer? Which still needs more evidence?
Do the descendants of a Seneca leader from the 1790s still own part of his land in Pennsylvania today?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A Seneca leader in a new nation. After the Revolution, the United States and Pennsylvania wanted western lands. In treaties in the 1780s, leaders of the Haudenosaunee, Lenape and Wyandot were pressured to give up most of the remaining land in western Pennsylvania. Cornplanter chose to work with the United States to protect his people. It was a hard choice in a hard time.
Change we can prove. Lines on maps moved Native lands west (1.03). Pittsburgh grew from a fort to a busy town (1.04, 1.09). Pennsylvania began to end slavery (1.01, 1.08). Philadelphia became the nation’s capital, and the state capital moved west (1.02).
Continuity we can prove. Native nations endured: Cornplanter’s heirs still own part of his land, and the Seneca Nation governs itself today. Black Philadelphians’ churches still stand (1.11). The rivers that made Pittsburgh important still flow (1.04).
Worked example 1: a change claim. Mateo writes, “Western Pennsylvania changed from Native homelands to farms and towns. Evidence: the 1768 treaty opened land to settlers, and by 1803 Pittsburgh had about 2,400 people.”
Worked example 2: a continuity claim. Aaliyah writes, “The Seneca endured. Cornplanter’s family kept their land for more than 150 years, and they still own part of it.” She uses the present tense on purpose.
From evidence to trail guide. Our guide asks why so much of the nation’s founding happened in Pennsylvania and whose stories are often left out. Today your team chooses three big ideas. In Part 2 you will build the trail stops for them.
Use the reading and your notes from the whole unit.
Fill in your team’s Trail Guide Evidence Plan.
For each of three big ideas, write a claim, two sources (who made each one) and one map or timeline connection. At least one idea must include Native nations, one must include Black Pennsylvanians, and one must include women.
Write a trail guide stop about Cornplanter. Tell who he was, what he did and how his people's story continues today.
You have gathered evidence and made sense of it. Next you start building a trail guide our community can trust.
Exit ticket: finish this sentence for trail users: “Before you walk this trail, we want you to know that…”
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 7, practice 8, planning 12.
Accuracy: the PA SHPO blog does not date the grant; the Pennsylvania act was passed in 1791 and patents were issued in 1796. Tracts: about 600 acres (Forest County), 300 (Venango County), over 700 (Warren County). The 1780s treaties referred to in the mini lesson are the second Treaty of Fort Stanwix (1784) and the Treaty of Fort McIntosh (1785). The Seneca-Iroquois National Museum in Salamanca, New York, is suggested by the blog for more learning.
Likely misconceptions: that Native nations left Pennsylvania entirely by 1800; that continuity means nothing changed.
Care: do not describe Longhouse religious practice beyond the reading’s mention.
Supports: a plan template and the source bank from 1.01-1.13. Stretch: identify a gap in the evidence and how the guide will say it honestly.
Answer guide: a strong plan has specific claims, named sources and map or timeline links, uses present tense for Native nations today, and treats slavery and resistance directly. Keep plans for Part 2.
Pennsylvania State Historic Preservation Office blog, The Cornplanter Grant: A Native American Traditional Cultural Property · Copyright Pennsylvania Historic Preservation (PA State Historic Preservation Office); summarized in our own words with a link
Cornplanter was a Seneca leader. The Seneca are one of the Six Nations of the Haudenosaunee. In the 1780s and 1790s, Cornplanter allied with the young United States. He helped bring Native nations of the Ohio Country to talks during the wars there.
Pennsylvania and the United States granted land to Cornplanter and his heirs, on land where Seneca people already lived. There were three pieces. He soon lost two, but he kept and lived on more than 700 acres in Warren County, along the Allegheny River. It became known as the Cornplanter Grant.
His half-brother, Handsome Lake, a Seneca prophet, also lived there. On the Grant, Seneca families kept their traditions alive for many years. They made baskets, gathered plants, hunted and fished.
In 1965, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers finished the Kinzua Dam. The lake it made covered most of the Grant. The Seneca and their supporters fought the dam but could not stop it. Cornplanter’s heirs still own the land above the water today.
Source: Pennsylvania State Historic Preservation Office blog, The Cornplanter Grant: A Native American Traditional Cultural Property (pahistoricpreservation.com)