explain how the 1791 whiskey tax affected prices and compare the views of western Pennsylvania farmers and the national government.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. A farmer near Pittsburgh in 1791 grows a lot of rye and corn. The road over the mountains to Philadelphia is long and rough. How could the farmer get value from all that grain?
Why did many western farmers turn grain into whiskey?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Back to taxes and prices. In lesson 1.05 we learned a tax adds to a price. The whiskey tax added cents to every gallon. A large eastern distiller could raise prices for cash-paying customers. A small western farmer had few cash customers, so the tax came out of his own pocket.
Worked example 1: sample price math. Leila uses sample numbers. A gallon of whiskey sells for 50 cents. A tax of 9 cents is added. She writes, “50 + 9 = 59 cents. Buyers pay more, or the farmer earns less if he cannot raise the price.” (The real tax was 6 to 18 cents a gallon; the selling price is a sample.)
Point of view 1: the national government. Hamilton and Washington believed the nation had to pay its war debts. They believed laws passed by Congress must be obeyed everywhere, or the new government would fail.
Point of view 2: western farmers. Many farmers felt the tax was unfair to them. They had little cash, far to travel, and no nearby court. They also complained that the government was not protecting them or opening the Mississippi River for trade.
Worked example 2: comparing views. Ava writes, “Hamilton saw the tax as a fair way to pay the nation’s bills. A Washington County farmer saw it as a tax on his main crop. They lived in different places and had different money, so they saw the same law differently.”
Peaceful protest and violence. Many westerners protested by writing petitions and meeting. Some turned to violence, which put people in danger and brought an army. Both views are part of our trail guide’s Pittsburgh story.
Use the reading. Show math for price questions.
Two-view chart.
Make a two-column chart: the national government's view and western farmers' view. Give two reasons for each. Then write one sentence explaining why where people lived shaped their view.
Use the sample numbers to explain how the tax affected a small farmer's earnings.
One law, two views. Next we hear from a Seneca leader of western Pennsylvania and choose the big ideas for our trail guide.
Exit ticket: do people always agree about a tax? Use the whiskey tax as evidence.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 10, practice 10, chart 7.
Accuracy: TTB gives rates of 6 to 18 cents per gallon, Neville’s house burned July 17, 1794, almost 13,000 militia, two treason convictions pardoned in 1795, repeal in 1802. Selling prices are samples. Washington County, Fayette County and Allegheny County were centers of resistance. Keep it brief; the grade 8 course covers the Washington administration in depth.
Neutrality: present both views fairly; students need not pick a side. Distinguish peaceful protest (petitions, meetings) from violence.
Likely misconceptions: that the rebels were simply lawbreakers or simply heroes; that the tax was on all drinks.
Supports: two-view chart template. Stretch: connect to the 1773 tea tax: how were the arguments alike and different?
Answer guide: government reasons: debts, rule of law. Farmer reasons: little cash, whiskey as money, distant court, poor roads, unequal rates. Exit tickets say people disagreed and give evidence.
Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (U.S. Department of the Treasury), The Whiskey Rebellion · U.S. government work, public domain
The new national government owed money from the Revolutionary War. In 1791, Congress passed the first nationwide tax on goods made in the United States, a tax on whiskey and other strong drinks. Treasury Secretary Alexander Hamilton pushed for it. It had to be paid in cash.
Western Pennsylvania farmers were angry. Roads over the mountains were poor, so they turned extra grain into whiskey, which was easier to carry. Many had little cash and used whiskey to pay for things. Small producers often paid more tax per gallon than big ones. Tax cases were heard in Philadelphia, about 300 miles from Pittsburgh.
Some people attacked tax collectors. In July 1794, armed men burned the home of tax official John Neville near Pittsburgh. Thousands gathered at Braddock’s Field.
President Washington called up almost 13,000 militia soldiers and rode west himself. The rebellion ended, and only two men were convicted. Washington later pardoned them. Congress ended the whiskey tax in 1802.
Source: Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau (U.S. Department of the Treasury), The Whiskey Rebellion (ttb.gov)