Our Community Problem-Solver Proposal
Which local, county or state government could help solve a real problem in our community, and how can we make a strong proposal?
The mystery: When a pothole opens on a street, a library needs new books or a park needs a crossing guard, different governments answer the call. How do people know whom to ask?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
describe services that different governments provide and explain why our proposal must go to the right level of government.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Picture three problems near our school. A pothole opens on a street. The library needs new books. A busy park needs a crossing guard. Who would you call about each one?
Do you think one government fixes all three problems?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Welcome, civic investigators. In Unit 1 you were historians. Now you will study how Pennsylvania governs today. Your big job is a Community Problem-Solver Proposal. You will choose a real problem in our community and write a proposal to the government that can help.
Our community. East Allegheny School District serves North Versailles Township, East McKeesport and Wilmerding. All three are in Allegheny County, in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Each of these places has its own government.
Levels of government. Think of nesting boxes. The smallest box is our township or borough. It sits inside Allegheny County. The county sits inside Pennsylvania. Pennsylvania is one of the fifty states of the United States. Each box has its own leaders and its own jobs.
Worked example 1: matching a problem to a level. Aaliyah wants a stop sign fixed on her street. She asks, “Is this a local job or a state job?” Many neighborhood streets are cared for by the local government, but some big roads are state roads. She writes, “First, I must find out who owns this road.” That is a smart first step.
Worked example 2: a service from far away. Mateo’s older sister is getting her driver’s license. Mateo learns from the reading that state offices handle driver’s licenses. He writes, “Driver’s licenses are a state service, so our borough would not be the right place to ask.”
Our promise. A good proposal goes to the right door. In this unit we will collect evidence about each level of government. We will treat every opinion with respect, because good citizens can disagree and still work together.
Keep the reading open. Point to the sentence that helps each answer.
Start your Civic Investigator notebook.
List three services you or your family used this week, such as a road, a school or a park. Next to each, guess which level of government provides it.
Write one question about how our community is governed. Put it on a sticky note for the Wonder Board.
We met our puzzle and our audience. Next time we will look at shared symbols and start sorting our questions.
Exit ticket: why does it matter which government we send our proposal to?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 10, guided practice 10, notebook and Wonder Board 7.
Likely misconceptions: that the President or the Governor runs every service; that the school district and the township are the same government (they are separate). Some roads in our area are state roads, so the road owner matters.
Supports: draw the nesting boxes on chart paper and keep it up all unit. Stretch: ask students where the national government fits for services such as mail.
Civics note: keep the problem list practical and local (parks, safety, libraries, sidewalks). Do not steer students toward any party or candidate.
Answer guide: strong answers match a problem to a level and give a reason, for example “The library is probably local because it serves our town.” Exit tickets should say the right government has the power or job to help.
USAGov, State and local governments · U.S. government work, public domain
USAGov is a website run by the United States government. One of its pages helps people find their state and local governments. It explains that there are different levels of government. The national government serves the whole country. Each state has its own government. Towns, cities and counties have local governments.
Every state has a governor, the leader of the state. Every state also has an attorney general. The page calls this person the top legal officer of the state.
The page lists many kinds of help that state offices give. Some help people get a driver’s license. Some help people register and vote. Others protect shoppers from scams, run health departments and keep birth records, or plan for emergencies such as floods and storms.
The page also shows how to find contact information for local governments in each state. That matters, because a service is a job a government does for the people. To get help, you need to know which government does that job.
Source: USAGov, State and local governments (usa.gov)