tell the difference between public and private goods and services and support a claim with evidence from Allegheny County’s services.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. A county park and a private trampoline park both let kids play. Write one way they are alike and one way they are different.
Who usually pays for a county park?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Public and private. A public good or service is provided by a government, usually paid for by taxes, and meant for the whole community. A private good or service is sold by a business or person to the customers who pay for it.
Some are in between. A public pool may charge a small fee, and a private company may be hired to plow a town’s roads. Ask two questions: Who provides it? Who pays?
Claim, evidence, reasoning. A claim answers the question. Evidence is facts from a source. Reasoning explains how the evidence supports the claim.
Worked example 1: a public service. Kenji writes: “Claim: Food safety checks are a public service. Evidence: The county page says the Health Department checks food safety. Reasoning: The government does it to protect everyone who eats out, not just one customer.”
Worked example 2: a private service. Rosa writes: “Claim: A haircut at a barbershop is a private service. Evidence: The shop is a business, and only the customer pays. Reasoning: A business, not the government, provides it for a price.”
Why this matters for our proposal. If our problem needs a public service, our proposal names a government as its door. If a business provides it, a government may not be the right door.
Sort the cards into Public, Private or In Between. Use the reading.
Write your own CER paragraph.
Choose one service from the county page. Write a full claim, evidence and reasoning paragraph that shows whether it is public or private.
We can sort public and private services. Next time we compare all three levels of government side by side.
Exit ticket: name one public and one private service you used this week.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 7, mini lesson 8, card sort 12, CER 8.
Accuracy: the services and parks come from the county Government page opened 2026-11-19. Avoid naming or promoting any business in the private examples.
Likely misconceptions: that anything free is public; that anything with a fee is private.
Supports: a CER frame: “I claim ___ because the source says ___. This shows ___.” Stretch: explain an in-between case.
Answer guide: the library is a public service when a public body funds it and opens it to all; strong reasoning uses who provides and who pays.
Allegheny County, Government · Allegheny County public information page; facts retold in our own words
Allegheny County’s government page lists many services the county provides for the people who live there. These are public services, because the government provides them for the community.
The Health Department runs clinics and gives shots that prevent illness. It checks air quality and food safety, and it works to keep children safe from lead.
The county runs large parks, including Boyce, Deer Lakes, Hartwood Acres, North, South and White Oak parks. It also holds special events.
The county helps older adults through its Area Agency on Aging. It helps veterans, children and families, and people who need food, housing or other support.
The county keeps property records, issues licenses such as dog licenses and marriage licenses, and runs elections. Its courts include the Court of Common Pleas.
The page also lists elected county offices, called row offices, including the Treasurer, the Controller and the Sheriff.
Source: Allegheny County, Government (alleghenycounty.us)