explain what the Liberty Bell and Penn’s Charter of Privileges show about early Pennsylvania, and how later groups gave the bell new meaning.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. The Liberty Bell has a big crack. Before we read, guess: why do people care so much about a bell that cannot ring?
Who first called it the “Liberty Bell”?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
An artifact is evidence. An artifact is an object made by people. Historians ask: who made it, when, why, and what did people later think it meant? An artifact’s meaning can grow over time.
The charter behind the bell. In 1701, William Penn signed the Charter of Privileges. A charter is a document that grants rights. It promised religious freedom and gave an elected Assembly power to make laws. Fifty years later, the Assembly ordered a bell, likely to honor that promise.
Worked example 1: reading an inscription. Nora reads the words on the bell: “Proclaim Liberty Throughout All the Land Unto All the Inhabitants thereof.” She writes, “Inhabitants means people who live in a place. The bell says liberty for all of them. In 1753, many Pennsylvanians, including enslaved people, did not have that liberty.”
Worked example 2: a meaning that changed. Elijah compares two dates. In 1753 the bell was a State House bell. In 1835 abolitionists named it the Liberty Bell to push for ending slavery. He writes, “The bell stayed the same, but people gave it a new job.”
More people, more meaning. In 1915, women seeking the vote made the Justice Bell. They kept its clapper chained, silent, until women won the vote. Again and again, people used this Pennsylvania artifact to ask the nation to keep its promise.
For our trail guide. The bell’s stop can tell the whole story: Penn’s charter, the crack and the people who claimed its words.
Use the reading and a picture of the bell.
Artifact study card.
Fill in an artifact card for the Liberty Bell: Who made it? When? Why? What do its words say? Who later used it as a symbol, and for what?
What does the Charter of Privileges tell us about early Pennsylvania? Write two sentences.
The bell’s words promised liberty to all inhabitants. Next we read the 1780 law closely and ask how far it kept that promise.
Exit ticket: why do you think abolitionists chose this bell as their symbol?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 10, practice 10, artifact card 7.
Accuracy: the popular story that the bell rang on July 8, 1776 is not supported; NPS says the inscription “went unnoticed” during the war. The inscription is from Leviticus 25:10, about the Jubilee. NPS says Norris likely chose it for the Charter’s anniversary; keep the word “probably.” The 1915 and 1835 facts are beyond our 1824 end date and are used to show changing meaning.
Likely misconceptions: that the bell cracked when it rang for independence; that the bell was made for the Revolution.
Supports: a large image of the inscription with key words defined. Stretch: compare the Charter of Privileges with the 1780 law.
Answer guide: change-over-time answers cite 1753 (State House bell) and 1835 or 1915 (symbol for ending slavery or women’s vote). Exit tickets connect “all the inhabitants” to enslaved people.
National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park, The Liberty Bell · U.S. government work, public domain
In 1751, Isaac Norris, the Speaker of the Pennsylvania Assembly, ordered a bell from a London foundry for the State House tower. It cracked the first time it was tested. Two Philadelphia metalworkers, John Pass and John Stow, melted it down and recast it. The new bell is dated 1753.
Norris probably chose its words to honor the 50th anniversary of William Penn’s 1701 Charter of Privileges. That charter gave Pennsylvanians religious freedom and a voice in their own government. The bell’s words come from the Bible: “Proclaim Liberty Throughout All the Land Unto All the Inhabitants thereof.”
After the Revolution, abolitionists noticed those words. In 1835, an anti-slavery paper called it the Liberty Bell. No one wrote down when it first cracked again. In 1846, workers tried to repair a thin crack, but a new crack silenced the bell for good.
In 1915, Pennsylvania women working for the right to vote toured the state with a copy called the Justice Bell.
Source: National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park, The Liberty Bell (nps.gov)