explain the causes and results of the Whiskey Rebellion and how a tax raises the price of a good.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. In 1794, several thousand angry farmers gathered at Braddock’s Field. That is right next to our East Allegheny community. Why were they so upset? Read to find out.
What made the farmers so angry?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A tax is money people must pay to the government. The government uses it to pay for things, like the nation’s debts. When a maker must pay a tax on each gallon, the maker usually raises the price to cover it. So a tax often makes the price of a good go up.
Worked example 1: Elijah’s sample price. This is sample data, not real 1791 prices. Elijah imagines a gallon of whiskey that sells for 50 cents. A tax of 10 cents a gallon is added. The maker now sells it for 60 cents. Elijah writes, “The tax made the price go up by 10 cents.” He knows that in the real tax, rates ran from 6 to 18 cents a gallon.
Causes and results. The cause of the anger was the tax, plus the hard trip over the mountains. The results included attacks, an army marching west and, later, the end of the tax. The rebellion also showed that the new national government could enforce its laws.
Fact or opinion? Historians read old letters full of strong feelings. “Congress passed a whiskey tax in 1791” is a fact. “The tax was the most unfair law ever” is an opinion. Our guide uses facts and can show opinions as quotes from people of the time.
Worked example 2: Sofia’s two viewpoints. Sofia writes: “Leaders in Philadelphia thought the tax was needed to pay the nation’s debts. Western farmers thought it was unfair because whiskey was how they sold their grain.” She shows both sides without picking one.
A local stop. Braddock’s Field is near our school. The Oliver Miller Homestead in South Park, run by Allegheny County, is a Whiskey Rebellion site. Visitors can see the Miller family’s stone house.
Use the reading and Elijah’s sample price.
Draft the Whiskey Rebellion stop or add to your own stop.
Write a cause-and-result chain for the Whiskey Rebellion with a cause and two results.
Write one fact and one opinion about the whiskey tax. Then explain how you can tell them apart.
History happened right here. The trail guide will help families see it.
Exit ticket: explain how the whiskey tax made the price of whiskey go up.
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 9, guided practice 12, drafting 8, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that the tax was on drinking only; that a big battle happened; that rebels were simply right or wrong. Keep the focus on taxes, transport and government, not on drinking. Do not stage a rebellion or tax-collector skit.
Supports: number line for the price problem. Stretch: why did small makers pay more per gallon than big ones?
Answer guide: cause = 1791 tax plus hard transport; results = attacks on collectors, the July 1794 shooting, Washington’s militia, arrests and pardons, repeal by 1802. Fact/opinion: facts are checkable. Price answers: the maker pays the tax and raises the price to cover it. Sources disagree about where on the Miller lands the first shots were fired, so the guide should say the homestead is a Whiskey Rebellion site without claiming more.
U.S. Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau, The Whiskey Rebellion · U.S. government work, public domain
After the Revolutionary War, the new nation owed a lot of money. In 1791, Congress passed a tax on whiskey and other strong drinks to help pay it. Alexander Hamilton, the head of the Treasury, pushed for the tax.
Farmers in western Pennsylvania were angry. It was hard to carry grain over the mountains to sell. So farmers turned extra grain into whiskey, which was easier to carry. Many people even used whiskey like money. The tax felt like a tax on their crops and their cash. Small makers often paid more per gallon than big ones.
Some tax collectors were threatened or hurt. In July 1794, a crowd attacked the house of tax officer John Neville. A farmer named Oliver Miller was killed in the shooting. Later, several thousand rebels gathered at Braddock’s Field. President Washington called up about 13,000 militia soldiers and led them west himself.
The rebellion ended without a big battle. About 150 people were arrested. Only two were found guilty of treason, and Washington pardoned them. Congress ended the whiskey tax by 1802.
Source: U.S. Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau, The Whiskey Rebellion (ttb.gov)