use our proposal criteria to write a clear problem statement and give examples of the rights and responsibilities of citizens.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Look at your planning page from Part 1. Read your problem out loud to a partner. Can your partner tell what is wrong, where it is and who it affects?
Is staying informed about your community a right or a responsibility?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Civic investigators, welcome to Build. In Part 1 you learned which government answers which call. You chose your door and started a planning page. Now we turn that page into our Community Problem-Solver Proposal. We will share it with a classroom panel or an invited guest.
A proposal is a plan that asks for help. It names a problem, asks the right government for help and shows a realistic way to fix it. A strong proposal does not complain. It gives evidence and a plan.
Our criteria. Every proposal will be judged by these rules. Keep this table in your folder.
| Criterion | What it means |
|---|---|
| Clear problem | We say what the problem is, where it is and who it affects. |
| Right door | We name the government that can help (township or borough, school board, Allegheny County or the state), the leader’s role, and why. |
| Evidence | We use at least two sources. One is a primary source or data. We check our facts. |
| Realistic plan and cost | We list steps, a sample cost and who pays. |
| Citizens help too | We show what people, including kids, can do. |
| Fair and respectful | We stay nonpartisan, share more than one viewpoint and never attack people. |
| Constraints | One page with seven sections. A three-minute talk. Local and practical. Roles, not names. No party or candidate support. |
Our seven sections. 1 The problem. 2 Our door: who can help. 3 Evidence. 4 The plan and cost. 5 Who pays. 6 How citizens can help. 7 Sources. We will build one or two sections in each Build lesson.
Worked example 1: Maya’s problem statement. Maya first writes, “The park is bad.” That does not tell what, where or who. She revises this sample: “The swing set at our borough park has two broken swings. Younger kids who play there have fewer safe places to swing.” Now a reader knows what, where and who.
Worked example 2: Andre’s rights and responsibilities. Andre lists what his proposal uses. Right: the freedom to express himself. Responsibilities: stay informed, respect other opinions and take part in the local community. He adds, “Some neighbors may want the money spent on something else. I will listen to them too.”
Work with your team. Keep the reading and the criteria table open.
Write Section 1 of your proposal.
Section 1, The Problem: write your problem statement. Then name the level of government you chose in Part 1 and one way it is organized differently from the national government.
Name one right and one responsibility from the reading that your proposal uses. Explain how in one sentence each.
A good proposal starts with a clear problem and a citizen who cares enough to be informed.
Exit ticket: who in our community would be helped most if your problem were solved?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 7, mini lecture 9, guided practice 12, Section 1 draft 5, closure 2.
Criteria: Part 1 ended with a planning page and the idea of “choosing our door.” This lesson sets the criteria table for all of Part 2. Post it on the wall.
Civics note: steer topics to local, practical issues (parks, crossings, sidewalks, libraries, litter). Redirect any topic that endorses a party, candidate or ballot position. No one has to contact an official.
Likely misconceptions: that rights have no limits or responsibilities; that a proposal is the same as a complaint.
Supports: frame: “The ___ at ___ is ___, so ___ are affected.” Stretch: add a number, such as how many people use the place.
Answer guide: rights: expression, worship, fair trial, vote, run for office. Responsibilities: support the Constitution, obey laws, stay informed, take part, respect others, pay taxes, jury service. Organization contrast: local governments have councils or boards and a mayor or similar role; the nation has Congress, a President and federal courts.
U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, Should I Consider U.S. Citizenship? · U.S. government work, public domain
U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services is the national government office that helps people become citizens. One of its pages lists what citizenship gives people and what it asks of them.
Rights are freedoms that belong to you. The page lists the freedom to express yourself and to worship as you wish. It lists the right to a fair trial by a jury, which is a group of citizens who decide a case. Citizens also have the right to vote for public officials and to run for office themselves.
Responsibilities are duties, or things you should do. The page asks citizens to support the Constitution and to obey federal, state and local laws. It asks them to stay informed about issues in their community and to take part in the democratic process. Citizens should respect the rights, beliefs and opinions of others. They should take part in their local community, pay their taxes honestly and on time, and serve on a jury when called.
Rights and responsibilities go together. When we speak up about a community problem, we use our freedom to express ourselves. When we do it with facts and respect, we meet our responsibilities too.
Source: U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, Should I Consider U.S. Citizenship? (uscis.gov)