write a claim, evidence and reasoning answer about why freedom came slowly, using the story of the people Washington enslaved in Philadelphia.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look back at our Wonder Board question: “Why did Pennsylvania’s law free people so slowly?” Write one reason you can already give from lessons 1.01 and 1.08.
When President Washington lived in Philadelphia, what do you think he did about the people he enslaved?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Making a claim. A claim answers the question. Evidence is facts from sources. Reasoning explains why the evidence supports the claim. Today’s question is our unit’s puzzle: why was freedom so slow?
Evidence we have gathered. The 1780 law kept already-enslaved people enslaved (1.01, 1.08). Children had to serve until age 28 (1.01). Some visitors could keep enslaved people in the state for up to six months (1.08). And powerful people found ways around the law (today).
Worked example 1: a weak answer. Rosa writes, “Freedom was slow because people were mean.” Her answer has feeling but no evidence from a source.
Worked example 2: a stronger answer. Ethan writes, “Claim: freedom was slow because the law had limits and powerful people avoided it. Evidence: the law kept enslaved people enslaved, and Washington moved the people he enslaved back to Virginia to avoid it. Reasoning: if a law has loopholes and even the president gets around it, many people stay enslaved.”
People who made their own freedom. Ona Judge was a young woman who worked as Martha Washington’s maid. She chose freedom, at great risk, and kept it for more than fifty years. Hercules did the same. Our trail guide must show enslaved people as actors in their own story.
Point of view. Washington saw the people he enslaved as property and called their escapes losses. Ona Judge said later that she knew if she went back to Virginia, she would never be free. Comparing these views helps us understand what was at stake.
Use the reading and your notes from lessons 1.01 and 1.08.
Write your claim, evidence and reasoning paragraph.
Answer our unit puzzle: Why was freedom so slow in Pennsylvania? Write a claim, two pieces of evidence from two different lessons, and your reasoning.
Write a short trail guide stop that honors Ona Judge. Tell who she was, what she did and why it matters.
Enslaved people pushed against slow freedom. Next we meet free Black Philadelphians who built schools, churches and a mutual aid society.
Exit ticket: what is one reason freedom was slow, and one way people fought for it?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 10, practice 7, writing 10.
Accuracy: NPS names nine people; the NPS early Black Philadelphia timeline says Washington moved to Philadelphia in 1790 with nine enslaved people. Ona Judge’s words in the mini lesson paraphrase her 1845 interview, which the NPS quotes on its Ona Judge article. Hercules escaped from Mount Vernon in 1797 while Washington was in Philadelphia. The outdoor exhibit at the President’s House Site has been the subject of a dispute in 2026; check its current status before referring students to it.
Care: no role-play, reenactment or “escape” games. Students analyze sources only. Present Washington accurately: a founder who also enslaved people and worked to keep them enslaved.
Supports: CER frame and an evidence bank. Stretch: add a counterclaim (the law did reduce slavery over time) and answer it.
Answer guide: strong claims combine the law’s limits with how people avoided it, cite two lessons, and reason clearly. Trail stops show Ona Judge’s choice and courage.
National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park, President's House Site: Enslaved People in the Washington Household · U.S. government work, public domain
From 1790 to 1797, President George Washington lived in a house in Philadelphia, then the nation’s capital. He brought enslaved people from his Mount Vernon home in Virginia. The National Park Service names them: Austin, Christopher Sheels, Giles, Hercules, Joe (later Joe Richardson), Moll, Ona Judge, Paris and Richmond.
Pennsylvania’s Gradual Abolition Act could have led to their legal freedom if they stayed in the state too long. So Washington sent them back to Virginia from time to time to stop that. Hercules, a skilled cook, understood why.
In 1796, Ona Judge escaped from the President’s House and reached Portsmouth, New Hampshire. Washington asked an official there to send her back. The official spoke with her and refused. Later, another attempt to seize her failed when New Hampshire’s John Langdon warned her. Ona Judge lived free in New Hampshire until she died in 1848.
In 1797, Hercules also escaped to freedom. Washington’s efforts to recapture him failed.
Source: National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park, President's House Site: Enslaved People in the Washington Household (nps.gov)