plan two trail stops for our Freedom Trail Guide with a clear big idea, a real audience and criteria that keep them accurate and fair.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Picture a family from East Allegheny holding our trail guide outside Independence Hall. They have one minute to read our stop. What is the one thing they should remember? Read today’s short reading, then decide.
What was Independence Hall first built to be?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Trail guides, welcome to Build. In Part 1 you gathered evidence about how the nation was born in Pennsylvania and why freedom came so slowly for some people. Now that evidence goes to work. We are making The Pennsylvania Freedom Trail Guide for East Allegheny families and younger students. Remember our promise to trail users: every stop comes from evidence, says where each fact came from and tells hard truths with care.
What is a trail guide? It is a booklet that leads visitors from place to place. Each place is called a stop. Our stops include Independence Hall, the Liberty Bell, the 1780 law, the President’s House site, Mother Bethel Church, Fort Pitt at Point State Park, the Whiskey Rebellion sites near Pittsburgh, the Lancaster Turnpike and a stop about women of Philadelphia. Each team will write two stops, built from the three big ideas in its Trail Guide Evidence Plan.
A big idea is a claim, not a topic. “Independence Hall” is a topic. “Independence Hall is where leaders signed the Declaration of Independence and wrote the Constitution” is a big idea. A visitor can learn it, and you can prove it.
Worked example 1: Mariah’s big idea. Mariah first writes, “Independence Hall is the coolest building in America.” That is an opinion. Nobody can prove it. She checks the reading and writes, “Leaders signed the Declaration of Independence and wrote the U.S. Constitution in this building.” That is a fact she can trace to a source.
Worked example 2: Theo’s stop plan. Theo’s team plans the Independence Hall stop. Their plan lists a title, the location, a short main text, a timeline strip (1732, 1775, 1776, 1781, 1787), a source box and a “Story Often Left Out” box. Next to each part they write which note supports it. Any part without evidence gets a question mark.
Our guide criteria. Here they are in plain words. We will use them every day until the guide is done.
| Criterion | What it means |
|---|---|
| Accurate | Every fact traces to a named source. Names and dates are checked. |
| Fair | We name Native nations, Black Pennsylvanians and women, tell stories that are often left out and show more than one point of view. |
| Clear | A family can read it without help. Hard words are explained. |
| Complete | Each stop tells who, what, when, where and why it matters. |
| Constraints | Two stops per team. Main text of 75 words or fewer. One source box and one “Story Often Left Out” box per stop. No costumes or role-play. |
Work with your team. Keep the reading open.
Fill in your own stop plan.
Explain why Independence Hall is an important Pennsylvania historic site. Use two facts from the reading.
What does Independence Hall teach us about the people who worked there? Name one group whose story is often left out.
A trail guide makes a promise: we will tell you something true, and we will show you how we know.
Exit ticket: write one fact and one opinion about Independence Hall. Label each one.
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 9, team guided practice 13, stop plan 7, closure 3.
Team stops: Independence Hall and the Liberty Bell; the 1780 law and the President’s House site; Fort Pitt and the Treaty of Fort Pitt; the Whiskey Rebellion (Braddock’s Field and the Miller family homestead in South Park); the Lancaster Turnpike and Pennsylvania iron; Mother Bethel and the Free African Society; women of Philadelphia (Esther Reed, Sarah Franklin Bache, Ona Judge, with the Betsy Ross story labeled as legend, from 1.12). Adjust for class size. Teams start from the Trail Guide Evidence Plans they made in 1.14.
Likely misconceptions: that a topic is the same as a claim; that a strong opinion is a fact; that a site has only one story.
Supports: offer the frame “Visitors should know that ___ because ___.” Stretch: ask students to write the question their big idea answers.
Answer guide: importance answers use two facts, such as the Declaration and the Constitution. People answers may name Pennsylvania lawmakers, the delegates, and people who escaped slavery whose cases were heard there. Exit-ticket facts must be checkable; opinions use words like best or beautiful.
National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park, Independence Hall · U.S. government work, public domain
Work on a brick building in Philadelphia began in 1732. It was built as the Pennsylvania State House. All three parts of Pennsylvania’s colonial government met there. Today we call it Independence Hall.
Pennsylvania lawmakers lent their Assembly Room to the Second Continental Congress. In that room in 1775, Congress named George Washington to lead the Continental Army. Delegates debated and signed the Declaration of Independence there. The Articles of Confederation, the first plan for a national government, took effect in 1781.
In 1787, delegates met again in the same room to write the U.S. Constitution. Benjamin Franklin looked at the sun carved on the back of Washington’s chair and wondered if it was rising or setting.
The building has other stories too. Later, it was used for hearings about people who had escaped from slavery. A good trail stop tells the famous story and the stories that are often left out. Today Independence Hall is a World Heritage Site, a place honored as important to all people.
Source: National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park, Independence Hall (nps.gov)