revise my trail stops against the guide criteria and add a story that is often left out.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Look at your stop. Count the people you name. Are any of them Black Pennsylvanians or members of Native nations? Today you will make sure your stop is fair. Start with the reading.
Who founded the Free African Society in 1787?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Revision means seeing again. Today you look at your stops with fresh eyes and make them stronger. Use the criteria and your feedback from 1.22.
| Criterion | What it means |
|---|---|
| Accurate | Every fact traces to a named source. Names and dates are checked. |
| Fair | We name Native nations, Black Pennsylvanians and women, tell stories that are often left out and show more than one point of view. |
| Clear | A family can read it without help. Hard words are explained. |
| Complete | Each stop tells who, what, when, where and why it matters. |
| Constraints | Two stops per team. Main text of 75 words or fewer. One source box and one “Story Often Left Out” box per stop. No costumes or role-play. |
Fair means more than one kind of story. Slavery is part of Pennsylvania’s story. So is the way free Black Pennsylvanians built schools, churches and help groups. The Free African Society shows people shaping their own lives.
Worked example 1: Hannah’s revision. Hannah’s Independence Hall stop named only famous delegates. She adds a box: “Story Often Left Out: In 1787, while delegates wrote the Constitution nearby, Richard Allen and Absalom Jones started the Free African Society to help Black families.” Source: National Park Service.
Worked example 2: Devon cuts words. Devon’s main text is 112 words. The limit is 75. He cuts repeated words, splits a long sentence in two and moves a date to the timeline strip. Now it is 71 words and easier to read.
Revision checklist. (1) Every fact has a source. (2) A Native nation or Black Pennsylvanian is named where the evidence supports it. (3) Main text is 75 words or fewer. (4) Who, what, when, where and why it matters are all there. (5) Legends and opinions are labeled.
Revise with a partner. Use the checklist.
Make your revisions.
Revise one of your stops using all five checklist items. Write what you changed and why.
Explain how Native Americans, Europeans and Africans each contributed to early Pennsylvania. Use one example for each from our unit.
Your guide is almost ready for visitors.
Exit ticket: what is the most important change you made today? How does it help a visitor?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture 7, partner revision 16, independent work 8, closure 2. This is the revision flex lesson.
Likely misconceptions: that revision means only fixing spelling; that fairness means adding a name with no evidence. Every added story must come from a source.
Supports: printed checklist; word-count help; small groups formed from 1.23 station data. Stretch: write a short caption for the trail map.
Answer guide: Allen and Jones answers: founded mutual aid, cared for the sick and widows, helped children learn and work, founded churches. Contribution answers: Lenape guides and treaty-makers; European lawmakers and builders; African and African American Pennsylvanians who resisted slavery and built communities. Do not describe forced labor as a voluntary contribution.
National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park, Preamble and Articles of Association for the Free African Society · U.S. government work, public domain
In April 1787, the same year the Constitution was written, Richard Allen and Absalom Jones started the Free African Society in Philadelphia. Black Philadelphians got little help from others, so they decided to help each other. This is called mutual aid.
Members paid one shilling each month. After a year, members in need could get money each week. The society cared for people who were sick. It helped families when someone died. A widow could keep getting help without paying. The society helped pay for children’s schooling and found them apprenticeships, jobs where they learned a trade.
Members had rules. They met each month and paid a small fine if they missed a meeting, unless they were sick.
The society grew into a church community. In 1793 Absalom Jones founded the African Episcopal Church of St. Thomas. In 1794 Richard Allen founded Mother Bethel African Methodist Episcopal Church. Both leaders shaped Black life in the new nation.
Source: National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park, Preamble and Articles of Association for the Free African Society (nps.gov)