show what I have learned about Pennsylvania and the birth of the nation, including stories that are often left out.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Take a slow breath. You have been working like a historian for weeks. Read the passage first. You will use it as evidence on the checkpoint.
How confident are you that you can I am ready to use evidence from the reading and from our unit.
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
This checkpoint is your chance to show your thinking. It covers time, sources, people, places, maps, documents and the stories often left out. Read each question fully. Use the reading, a Pennsylvania map and what you remember from our trail guide.
For written answers, use claim, evidence, reasoning. State your answer. Give a fact or detail. Explain how the fact supports your answer.
Worked example 1: Ruby answers a change question. Question: how did slavery change in Pennsylvania after 1780? Ruby writes: “Slavery slowly shrank. The reading says there were about 3,737 enslaved people in 1790 and 64 in 1840. This shows the law worked, but very slowly.”
Worked example 2: Mateo notices sources disagree. This page says there were no enslaved people by 1850. The National Park Service page we read says the last known enslaved person was recorded in the 1850s. Mateo writes, “The sources do not agree. Historians check more records before deciding. I can say slavery lasted until about 1850 or a little later.”
Be careful with this history. Behind every number is a real person. A strong answer remembers that enslaved people worked for their own freedom.
Part A. Answer on your own. Use the reading and a Pennsylvania map.
Part B. Answer each question in 2 to 4 sentences with evidence.
1. Our puzzle: why was freedom so slow in Pennsylvania after 1780? Give the causes and one result. Explain why the law still mattered.
2. Who made today's reading and the 1780 law, and when? Use one detail from the reading as evidence. Then explain why the PHMC page and the NPS page might give different end dates for slavery.
3. Explain how slavery and resistance to it shaped life in Pennsylvania. Name Ona Judge or the Free African Society. Then explain how Native Americans, Europeans and Africans each contributed to early Pennsylvania.
4. Give one example of cooperation and one of conflict between Native nations and settlers or the United States. Then give one example of conflict like the Whiskey Rebellion and explain its causes and results. Show how two groups saw it differently.
5. Choose one document (Penn's Charter, the Charter of Privileges, the 1776 Declaration of Rights or the 1780 law) and one artifact (the Liberty Bell or a Conestoga wagon). Explain what each tells us. Then explain why Independence Hall or Fort Pitt is an important historic place.
6. Explain how one way of making a living and one way of moving goods changed in Pennsylvania. Name one thing that stayed the same. Use a map to describe where it happened. Also explain how the beliefs of Quakers or Native peoples shaped Pennsylvania.
7. What does the Pennsylvania Constitution do for people today? Then compare the Pennsylvania Preamble with the U.S. Preamble: one way alike, one way different, and what one U.S. goal means.
Look back through your answers. Add evidence wherever you can.
Which answer best shows your growth as a historian? Why?
How confident are you that you can I can explain how Pennsylvania helped found the nation and whose stories are often left out.
Pacing: reading 7 minutes, directions and examples 4, Part A 10, Part B 17, closure 2. Allow extended time; Part B may split across two sittings.
Evidence map: Part A: order 8.1.6.A:1a; absolute location 7.1.6.A:2a; opinion 8.1.6.C:1a; tax 6.3.3-5.E:1a; cooperation 8.2.6.D:1a and 8.3.6.D:1a; preamble 5.1.6.F:1a. Part B: Q1 8.1.6.C:2a, 8.2.6.D:3a; Q2 8.1.6.B:1a, 8.1.6.B:2a; Q3 8.3.6.D:2a, 8.3.6.A:2a, 8.3.6.A:1a, 8.2.6.A:1a; Q4 8.3.6.D:1a, 8.2.6.D:1a, 8.2.6.D:2a, 8.1.6.B:3a; Q5 8.2.6.B:1a, 5.1.6.D:1a, 8.2.6.B:2a, 8.3.6.B:1a, 8.2.6.B:3a, 8.3.6.B:2a; Q6 8.2.6.C:1a, 8.2.6.C:2a, 8.1.6.A:2a, 7.1.6.A:1a, 8.2.6.C:3a; Q7 5.1.6.D:2a, 5.1.6.F:2a, 5.1.6.F:1a.
Supports: read aloud, allow oral responses, provide a Pennsylvania map and sentence frames. Remind students the content includes slavery and violence.
Answer guide (3 points each): 3 = correct, specific evidence, clear reasoning; 2 = correct with limited evidence; 1 = partly correct or unsupported. Q1: gradual design, age-28 rule, registration, loopholes, opponents; it mattered as the first such law. Q2: Pennsylvania lawmakers in 1780; the PHMC page is a modern state archive summary; differences may come from different records or counting methods. Q4: Fort Pitt treaty versus broken promises and Gnadenhutten; Whiskey Rebellion causes = tax and transport, results = militia, arrests, repeal; views = national leaders versus western farmers. Q7: rights such as free speech, worship and clean air; both begin with the people, the U.S. lists goals while Pennsylvania gives thanks for liberty.
Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Our Documentary Heritage, An Act for the Gradual Abolition of Slavery, March 1, 1780 · Pennsylvania state government page; retold in our own words with a link to the source; the 1780 act's text is public domain
Pennsylvania’s lawmakers passed the gradual abolition law in 1780. The vote was 34 to 21. It was the first law of its kind in America. It was also the slowest of the northern laws to end slavery, and it freed few people right away. Children born after the law had to serve until age 28.
Not everyone agreed. In 1781 some lawmakers tried to weaken or cancel the law. Abolitionists stopped them. In 1788 the law was made stronger.
Slowly, the number of enslaved people fell. Some enslavers freed people. The Pennsylvania Abolition Society bought freedom for some. Some people escaped. Count records show about 3,737 enslaved people in 1790, 1,706 in 1800, 795 in 1810 and 64 in 1840. This page says there were none by 1850.
The law’s opening words explain why lawmakers acted. They had just fought for their own freedom from Britain, and they wrote that it was their duty to extend a portion of that freedom to others.
“we conceive that it is our duty, and we rejoice that it is in our Power, to extend a Portion of that freedom to others”
— An Act for the Gradual Abolition of Slavery, 1780
Source: Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission, Our Documentary Heritage, An Act for the Gradual Abolition of Slavery, March 1, 1780 (phmc.state.pa.us)