describe the levels of Pennsylvania’s courts and the job of the judicial branch.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Two classmates disagree about a game rule. Who could fairly decide? What makes a decider fair?
Where would most people go first for a small court case in our area?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
What courts do. Lawmakers write laws, and the executive branch carries them out. Courts decide what laws mean when people disagree. They also decide whether a law follows the state constitution.
The court ladder. Minor courts are at the bottom. The Court of Common Pleas holds trials. In our area, it is the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas. The Superior and Commonwealth Courts hear appeals. The Commonwealth Court hears many cases about state and local governments. The Supreme Court is at the top. The court system calls it the oldest appeals court in the nation.
Judges are elected. In Pennsylvania, voters elect judges. Judicial elections are held in odd-numbered years. Most judges serve ten-year terms. Then voters decide in a yes-or-no vote whether to keep them.
Worked example 1: climbing the ladder. In a sample case, a store owner and a customer disagree. A trial court decides. The owner thinks there was a mistake. Nadia writes, “The owner can appeal, so a higher court checks the decision.”
Worked example 2: a jury or not? Ben guesses the Supreme Court uses a jury. He checks the reading and corrects himself: “Juries are mainly in the Courts of Common Pleas, not the Supreme Court.”
Why this matters for our proposal. Courts settle disputes about laws. Most community problems are not court cases, so our proposal will usually go to a lawmaking or executive body instead.
Build a court ladder on chart paper as you answer.
Complete the court ladder in your notebook.
Draw the court ladder with five steps. On each step write the court's name and one fact about it. Add the leader's title at the top.
We have studied all three branches. Next time we ask how governments pay for everything they do.
Exit ticket: what is one difference between a trial court and an appeals court?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 8, ladder build 12, notebook 7.
Accuracy: court levels and jury facts come from the pacourts.us “How the Courts Operate” page; “oldest appellate court in the nation” is from the pacourts.us Supreme Court page; election in odd years, ten-year terms and yes-or-no retention are from “How Judges Are Elected.” Magisterial district judges serve six-year terms and run in regular elections rather than retention votes.
Likely misconceptions: that courts only handle crimes; that every case has a jury; that the Governor controls court decisions.
Supports: a ladder template with the names pre-printed. Stretch: what would happen without appeals?
Answer guide: levels let mistakes be checked and let small cases be handled close to home. Trial courts hear evidence; appeals courts check decisions.
Unified Judicial System of Pennsylvania, How the Courts Operate · Unified Judicial System of Pennsylvania public information page; facts retold in our own words
Pennsylvania’s courts are the judicial branch. Courts hear cases and decide how laws apply. The state’s court system has several levels, like the steps of a ladder.
The bottom step is the minor courts. These include magisterial district judges, who work in local offices across the state, and special courts in Philadelphia and Pittsburgh. One of their jobs is a first hearing to decide whether a criminal case should go on to a trial.
The next step is the Courts of Common Pleas. These are the main trial courts. A trial is where evidence is shown and a decision is made. Juries are mainly found here. A jury is a group of citizens who listen and decide the facts.
Above them are two appeals courts, the Superior Court and the Commonwealth Court. An appeal asks a higher court to check a lower court’s decision. The Superior Court hears many appeals of criminal cases.
At the top is the Supreme Court. It hears final appeals. There are no juries in the Supreme Court or the Superior Court.
Source: Unified Judicial System of Pennsylvania, How the Courts Operate (pacourts.us)