review the unit by separating evidence from legend and explaining why an early American object is important.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Many people say the Liberty Bell rang on July 4, 1776. Do you think that is true? Write yes, no or not sure. Then read.
Is there evidence the Liberty Bell rang on July 4, 1776?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Review day. Today we practice the skills the checkpoint will ask for. The big one: telling evidence from legend.
Evidence and legend. Evidence is information from a source that supports a claim. A legend is a story many people tell that has no evidence. A legend can be fun, but our guide labels it clearly.
Why the bell is important. It was made for the State House. Its words honored Penn’s Charter. Abolitionists gave it its name. So the bell is part of the story of freedom in more than one way.
Worked example 1: Isabella sorts claims. Isabella sorts three claims. “The bell was recast in 1753” is evidence; the NPS gives the names and date. “The bell rang on July 4, 1776” is legend; the NPS says there is no evidence. “The bell is the best symbol in America” is opinion.
Worked example 2: Caleb writes a fair label. Caleb writes: “Abolitionists named this the Liberty Bell in the 1830s. They used its words to argue that liberty should be for all people, including the enslaved.” He connects the object to the people who gave it meaning.
Review stations. Rotate through four stations: (1) evidence or legend cards; (2) timeline order; (3) people and contributions; (4) documents and places. Use your notes and our trail map.
Station work. Answer as you rotate.
Check your own stops.
Find one sentence in your stop that might be a legend or an opinion. Rewrite it as a fact with a source, or label it.
Explain why the Liberty Bell is an important early American object. Give two reasons.
Historians are careful, not boring. Careful stories are the ones people can trust.
Exit ticket: which review station was hardest for you? What will you study before the checkpoint?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture 6, four stations at 6 minutes each, self-check 5, closure 2. This is the review flex lesson.
Likely misconceptions: that a legend is a lie (it is a story without evidence); that the bell cracked in 1776; that the bell was always called the Liberty Bell.
Supports: station cards with picture cues; a vocabulary bank. Use station data to form small groups for 1.24.
Answer guide: belief answers: Quaker belief in each person’s worth and religious freedom; Native nations’ treaty traditions. Importance answers: made for the State House; words linked to Penn’s Charter; symbol for abolitionists. Rewrites should add a source or a “legend says” label.
National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park, The Liberty Bell · U.S. government work, public domain
In 1751, Isaac Norris, the leader of Pennsylvania’s Assembly, ordered a bell from London for the State House. It cracked the first time it was rung. Two Philadelphia metalworkers, John Pass and John Stow, melted it down and made it again in 1753.
The bell’s words come from the Bible, Leviticus 25:10: “Proclaim Liberty Throughout All the Land Unto All the Inhabitants thereof.” Norris may have picked them to honor the 50th birthday of William Penn’s 1701 Charter of Privileges.
At first, few people noticed the words. Later, abolitionists, people working to end slavery, made the bell their symbol. A newspaper called the Anti-Slavery Record first called it the “Liberty Bell” in 1835.
Nobody wrote down when the famous crack began. It probably split in the early 1840s. In 1846, workers drilled the crack wider to stop it from spreading. Then a new crack ran up through the word “Liberty,” and the bell went silent. There is no evidence that it rang on July 4, 1776. That story is a legend.
Source: National Park Service, Independence National Historical Park, The Liberty Bell (nps.gov)