explain how Esther DeBerdt Reed and the Ladies Association shaped the war effort, compare views of their work, and separate evidence from legend.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Many people have heard that Betsy Ross sewed the first American flag. What kind of evidence would prove that story is true?
Historians have searched for records from 1776 about Betsy Ross and the first flag. What do you think they found?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Women in the founding years. Women in 1780 could not serve in the Assembly or Congress, and most could not vote. But they ran homes, farms and shops, raised money, nursed the sick, protested and, like Ona Judge, claimed their own freedom.
Evidence or legend? Evidence comes from records made at the time, like letters, newspapers or account books. A legend is a story passed down that may or may not be true. Betsy Ross was a real Philadelphia upholsterer who made flags. But no record from 1776 shows she made the first flag. Our guide can tell the legend, if it labels it as a legend.
Worked example 1: evidence of a contribution. Jada writes, “The Ladies Association raised money from more than 1,400 people and made more than 2,000 shirts. This is evidence because Esther Reed reported the money in a letter in 1780, and newspapers printed the plan.”
Worked example 2: comparing views. Sam compares Anna Rawle and Sarah Jay. He writes, “Rawle supported Britain, so she did not want the Continental Army to get help. Jay was married to a Patriot leader, so she praised it. Each woman’s side in the war shaped her view.”
Whose work is missing? The reading does not name Black women or poor women who may have given or sewn. Historians call this a gap in the evidence. We say so honestly instead of guessing.
For our trail guide. A stop about women can include Esther Reed, Sarah Franklin Bache, Eleanor Harris the teacher (1.11) and Ona Judge (1.10), with the Betsy Ross story clearly labeled as a legend.
Use the reading. Sort facts from legend.
Evidence or legend sort and a trail stop.
Sort these into Evidence or Legend and explain one: the Ladies Association made over 2,000 shirts; Betsy Ross sewed the first flag; Esther Reed published a broadside in June 1780.
Write a trail guide stop about women in Pennsylvania's founding years. Name at least two real women and what each did.
Women shaped the founding years, and good historians label legends. Next we head back west to compare two views of a tax on whiskey.
Exit ticket: why should our trail guide label a legend as a legend?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 10, practice 10, sort and stop 7.
Accuracy: Battlefield Trust dates the broadside and founding to June 1780 (some sources say June 10 or 12). Joseph Reed was President of Pennsylvania’s Supreme Executive Council, similar to a governor. The 300,000 figure is in inflated Continental dollars; avoid converting it. The Betsy Ross story was first publicly presented by her grandson William Canby in 1870; Ross was a real flag maker who was paid by the Pennsylvania navy board in 1777, but the first-flag claim has no 1776 evidence.
Likely misconceptions: that women did nothing in the founding; that a story told often must be true.
Supports: Evidence/Legend sorting cards. Stretch: find the gap in the reading and suggest what source could fill it.
Answer guide: evidence: shirts and broadside; legend: first flag. Views: Rawle (Loyalist side) vs. Jay (Patriot family). Trail stops name real women and real actions.
American Battlefield Trust, The Ladies Association of Philadelphia · Copyright American Battlefield Trust; summarized in our own words with a link
By 1780, the war for independence had lasted five years. Soldiers in the Continental Army were short of food and clothing. In May 1780, George Washington wrote to Pennsylvania’s leader, Joseph Reed, asking for more help.
In June 1780, Joseph Reed’s wife, Esther DeBerdt Reed, published a paper called “The Sentiments of an American Woman.” It urged women to give up comforts to help the soldiers, and it laid out a plan. Reed, Sarah Franklin Bache (Benjamin Franklin’s daughter) and other women formed the Ladies Association of Philadelphia.
The women divided the city into areas and went door to door asking for money. They asked women of every class to give what they could. More than 1,400 people gave. By July 4, 1780, they had raised over 300,000 Continental dollars. They used the money to make more than 2,000 shirts for soldiers. After Esther Reed died later that year, Sarah Franklin Bache led the group.
Not everyone agreed. Anna Rawle, who sided with Britain, criticized the fundraising. Sarah Jay, wife of John Jay, praised the women.
Source: American Battlefield Trust, The Ladies Association of Philadelphia (battlefields.org)