
argue from documents how far the First World War and its peace explain the rise of totalitarian regimes, comparing their common and dissimilar traits, aggression and human costs.
Instruction
The question. How far do the First World War and its peace settlement explain the rise of totalitarian regimes in the Soviet Union, Italy and Germany?
Italy. Italy was on the winning side but got less territory than it was promised; nationalists called it a “mutilated victory.” Strikes, factory occupations and fear of socialist revolution followed. Benito Mussolini, a former socialist and war veteran, founded the Fascist movement in 1919; his black-shirted squads attacked socialists and unions. After the “March on Rome” in October 1922, King Victor Emmanuel III appointed him prime minister. By 1925-1926 he had banned other parties and a free press. Fascism glorified the nation, war and the leader; a slogan attributed to Mussolini demanded everything within the state and nothing outside it. Italy invaded Ethiopia in 1935, using poison gas.
Germany. The Weimar Republic was born in defeat and blamed by nationalists for signing Versailles; the myth that the army had been “stabbed in the back” by civilians spread widely. Hyperinflation in 1923 and then the Depression made the republic look helpless. Adolf Hitler’s Nazi party won 2.6 percent of the vote in 1928, 18.3 percent in 1930 and 37.3 percent in July 1932, becoming the largest party. Conservative politicians persuaded President Hindenburg to appoint Hitler chancellor on 30 January 1933, believing they could control him. After the Reichstag fire in February, emergency decrees suspended civil rights, and the Enabling Act of March 1933 let Hitler make laws without parliament. Within months, other parties were banned, unions abolished, and the first concentration camps opened for political opponents. Jews were driven from public life step by step.
Common traits. Scholars such as Hannah Arendt (1951) and Carl Friedrich and Zbigniew Brzezinski (1956) described a totalitarian model: one official ideology; a single mass party led by one leader, with a cult of personality; a secret police using terror; a monopoly of the press, radio and film; control of the economy to some degree; and camps. All three regimes fit much of this model.
Dissimilar traits. The Soviet ideology aimed at a classless society and named class enemies; Nazism aimed at a racial community and named racial enemies, above all Jews; Italian Fascism centered on the state and nation. The Soviet state owned the economy; the Nazi and Fascist states directed private businesses that stayed in private hands. The Bolsheviks seized power by revolution and civil war; Mussolini and Hitler were appointed through legal channels by conservative elites. Italy’s regime was less complete than the other two — the monarchy and the Church kept some independence. Critics of the totalitarian model argue that grouping the regimes together can hide these differences.
Weighing causes. The war is not the only cause. The Great Depression, the choices of elites who appointed Mussolini and Hitler, long-standing antisemitism, and Russia’s history of autocracy all mattered. A strong thesis weighs the war against at least one other cause.
Formal style (WHST.9-10.1.d). Write in the third person, avoid loaded words, and when you describe human costs, be precise: give ranges and sources rather than adjectives.
The defense. Three minutes, live or recorded, answering one of the three counterarguments set out at the end of this lesson’s reading: that the Depression rather than the war explains Hitler’s rise, that the choices of particular men explain it, or that Bolshevik Russia breaks the rule altogether. Choose the one that most threatens your thesis.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which is a dissimilar trait between Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union?
Hitler became chancellor after the Nazis won an outright majority of the vote in a free election.
How confident are you that you can argue how far the war and peace explain totalitarianism, comparing regimes and weighing other causes?
Unit 1 checkpoint
Do this before you start the task. It covers the whole unit and tells you what to review first.
What did Clemenceau most want from the peace?
The United States joined the League of Nations.
Article of the Treaty of Versailles made Germany accept responsibility for the war’s loss and damage.
Which became a British mandate?
Why do historians chart the 1923 hyperinflation on a logarithmic scale?
The 1923 Greek-Turkish population exchange was based on religion.
Who called the young people scarred by the war ‘a lost generation’?
Postwar disillusionment helped totalitarian movements because…
Lenin’s secret police, founded in December 1917, was the .
The Soviet press openly reported the 1932-1933 famine in Ukraine.
Which is a dissimilar trait of Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union?
The Nazis won an outright majority in a free election before Hitler became chancellor.
Submit: From Broken Peace to Dictatorship DBQ essay (800-1,000 words) + 3-minute oral defense
Task: Using at least five documents from Unit 1, argue how far the First World War and its peace explain the rise of totalitarian regimes, comparing at least two of the Soviet Union, Italy and Germany.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Evidence plan. Thesis; a comparison table of two or three regimes (origins, ideology, methods, aggression, human costs, common and dissimilar traits); five sourced documents; one competing cause to weigh.
- Stage 2 — Self-checked draft. Check that the comparison is balanced, the other cause is weighed fairly, and statistics are attributed. Save a revision note listing what you changed.
- Stage 3 — Revised final. 800-1,000 words in formal style with document citations.
- Stage 4 — Oral defense. Three minutes, live or recorded (equal credit), answering one of the three counterarguments set out in this lesson’s reading.
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Thesis (WHST.9-10.1.a) | Precise claim about how far the war explains the rise of totalitarianism. |
| Comparison (WH.10.7.3) | Common and dissimilar traits, aggression and human costs of at least two regimes compared accurately. |
| Weighing causes (WH.10.6.3, 9-12.WH.1.CC.B / 9-12.WH.1.CC.D) | War and peace weighed against at least one other cause; valid reasoning, no single-cause fallacy. |
| Evidence (WHST.9-10.1) | At least five documents cited accurately; statistics given with ranges and sources. |
| Style and revision (WHST.9-10.1.d, WHST.9-10.5) | Formal, objective tone; substantive revision after your self-check. |
| Oral defense (SL.9-10.4) | Clear, logical, evidence-based response to the counterargument. |
Eight Documents on the Road from the Broken Peace to Dictatorship
Fourteen Points (1918); Treaty of Versailles, Article 231 (1919); Statistisches Reichsamt exchange-rate table (1925); official German election statistics 1928-1933; Reichstag Fire Decree (1933) and Enabling Act (1933) in US government translations; Reich Citizenship Law (1935), doc. 1416-PS; Khrushchev’s report to the 20th Party Congress, US State Department text (1956) · Public domain
Why this reading. The task in lesson 1.5 asks you to argue from at least five documents how far the First World War and its peace explain the rise of totalitarian regimes. This is that document set: eight sources, each with a sourcing note, plus three tested ways of grouping them and the three counterarguments you may be asked to answer in your defense. Documents A and B you have met in lesson 1.1; the other six appear nowhere else in the course.
Document A — The promise
Woodrow Wilson, address to a joint session of Congress, 8 January 1918, Point XIV. US government work; public domain.
“A general association of nations must be formed under specific covenants for the purpose of affording mutual guarantees of political independence and territorial integrity to great and small states alike.”
Sourcing: a war leader speaking to his own legislature while the war is still being fought. Purpose: to state aims that would make the enemy’s people want peace, and to hold his allies to something.
Document B — The settlement
Treaty of Versailles, 28 June 1919, Article 231. Published before 1930; public domain.
“The Allied and Associated Governments affirm and Germany accepts the responsibility of Germany and her allies for causing all the loss and damage to which the Allied and Associated Governments and their nationals have been subjected as a consequence of the war imposed upon them by the aggression of Germany and her allies.”
Sourcing: a legal clause written by the victors to establish liability for reparations, signed by a German delegation that had no power to negotiate. It is the single most quoted sentence in German nationalist politics for the next twenty years.
Document C — The money
Statistisches Reichsamt, Zahlen zur Geldentwertung in Deutschland 1914 bis 1923 (Berlin, 1925), Table II.1, p. 6: monthly average marks per US dollar, Berlin. German official statistics, 1925; public domain.
| January 1914 | January 1922 | January 1923 | December 1923 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.21 | 191.81 | 17,972 | 4,200,000,000,000 |
Sourcing: a government statistical office compiling its own country’s catastrophe two years afterwards. Reliable as measurement; silent about what it did to people. Pair it with Document D, which shows what happened to votes.
Document D — The votes
Share of the vote won by the NSDAP in Reichstag elections. Figures from official German election statistics (Statistik des Deutschen Reiches, vols. 372, 382 and 434) as compiled by the German Bundestag’s historical exhibition. Facts from official statistics; the table is our compilation.
| Election | NSDAP share of the vote |
|---|---|
| 20 May 1928 | 2.6% |
| 14 September 1930 | 18.3% |
| 31 July 1932 | 37.3% |
| 6 November 1932 | 33.1% |
| 5 March 1933 | 43.9% |
Sourcing and honesty: the underlying figure for July 1932 is about 37.27 per cent; the Bundestag’s table rounds it to 37.4, other compilations to 37.3. We print 37.3 and tell you about the disagreement, which is what you should do with any figure that differs between sources. Two things this table proves and one it does not. It proves the Nazi vote was trivial in 1928 and that it collapsed between July and November 1932. It does not prove why — and note that the 5 March 1933 election was held after Hitler was already chancellor and after the Reichstag Fire Decree (Document E), so it was not a free election.
Document E — Emergency
Decree of the Reich President for the Protection of the People and State, 28 February 1933 (Reichsgesetzblatt 1933 I, p. 83), §1. English translation from Nazi Conspiracy and Aggression, vol. III, doc. 1390-PS (US Government Printing Office, 1946), as edited by the staff of the German Historical Institute. The underlying translation is a US government work; the editing is the GHI’s, and we name it.
“Articles 114, 115, 117, 118, 123, 124, and 153 of the Constitution of the German Reich are suspended until further notice. Thus, restrictions on personal liberty, on the right to free expression of opinion including freedom of the press, on the right to assembly and the right to association; interventions into the privacy of communications by post, telegraph, and telephone; warrants for house searches, orders for confiscations, and restrictions on property, also beyond the legal limits otherwise prescribed, are permitted.”
Sourcing: issued the day after the Reichstag fire, under an emergency article of the Weimar constitution, and signed by President Hindenburg — a legal instrument of the republic used to end the republic. It was never repealed. Count the freedoms suspended in one sentence.
Document F — Dictatorship by statute
Law to Remove the Distress of the People and the State (the Enabling Act), 24 March 1933 (Reichsgesetzblatt 1933 I, no. 25, p. 141), Articles 1 and 2. English translation from US Department of State, Division of European Affairs, National Socialism (Washington: US Government Printing Office, 1943), Appendix, doc. 11, pp. 217–218, as edited by the staff of the German Historical Institute. US government translation; public domain.
Preamble: “The Reichstag has passed the following law, which is, with the approval of the Reichsrat, herewith promulgated, after it has been established that it meets the requirements for legislation altering the Constitution.”
Article 1. “National laws can be enacted by the Reich Cabinet as well as in accordance with the procedure established in the Constitution. This also applies to the laws referred to in Article 85, Paragraph 2, and in Article 87 of the Constitution.”
Article 2. “The national laws enacted by the Reich Cabinet may deviate from the Constitution as long as they do not affect the institution of the Reichstag and the Reichsrat. The powers of the President remain unaffected.”
Sourcing: a law passed by an elected parliament, by the two-thirds majority needed to amend the constitution, with Communist deputies already arrested or in hiding and the building surrounded by SA men. Read the preamble again: it is careful to record that the constitutional requirements were met. Dictatorship here does not arrive by breaking the law; it arrives by using it.
Document G — Citizenship by blood
The Reich Citizenship Law, 15 September 1935, Article 2. Translation in Nazi Conspiracy and Aggression, vol. IV, doc. 1416-PS (US GPO, 1946). Public domain.
“A citizen of the Reich is only that subject, who is of German- or kindred blood and who, through his conduct, shows that he is both desirous and fit to serve faithfully the German people and Reich. … Only the citizen of the Reich enjoys full political rights in accordance with the provision of the laws.”
Sourcing: a statute promulgated at a party rally. Use it as evidence of the dissimilar trait: Nazism defined the political community racially. Compare the Soviet state, which defined its enemies by class.
Document H — The other dictatorship, judged from inside
Nikita Khrushchev, report to the closed session of the 20th Congress of the CPSU, 25 February 1956; US Department of State text printed in the Congressional Record, 4 June 1956, pp. 9389–9402. US government translation; public domain.
“It was determined that of the 139 members and candidates of the party’s Central Committee who were elected at the 17th Congress, 98 persons, i.e., 70 per cent, were arrested and shot (mostly in 1937-1938). … Of 1,966 delegates with either voting or advisory rights, 1,108 persons were arrested on charges of anti-revolutionary crimes, i.e., decidedly more than a majority.”
Sourcing: a successor condemning his predecessor to a closed audience he needs on his side. Highly credible on facts that damage his own party, less so on what it leaves out.
Three ways to group these — pick one and test it
Grouping 1: by what the war and the peace directly caused. A and B (a promise and its contradiction) → C (the economic wreckage that followed from reparations and occupation) → D (the electoral collapse of the center). This is the strongest case for the war as the explanation — and its weak point is the gap between 1928 and 1930 in Document D, which is the Depression, not the war.
Grouping 2: by method of taking power. D, E and F together show a party that was voted for, appointed, and then legislated itself into dictatorship. Set that against the Soviet route in lesson 1.4: revolution, civil war and the dissolution of an elected assembly. Same destination, opposite roads — and the road is your dissimilar trait.
Grouping 3: by whom the regime declared its enemy. G names the enemy by blood; H shows a regime whose victims were overwhelmingly its own members and citizens, named by class and by accusation. This grouping is the one that best supports a thesis about what the totalitarian model hides.
The counterargument you must answer
Your oral defense answers one of these three. Choose the one that most threatens your thesis, state it in its strongest form, and then answer it.
- It was the Depression, not the war. The Nazi vote was 2.6 per cent in 1928, nine years after Versailles and five years after the hyperinflation. It rose sevenfold only after the world economy collapsed in 1929. If Versailles caused Hitler, why did it take eleven years and a banking crisis?
- It was the choices of particular men. Nobody had to make Hitler chancellor. Hindenburg and the conservatives around him appointed him in January 1933, against the November election result, because they believed they could use him. The Enabling Act needed the votes of the Catholic Centre Party. Structures do not vote; people do.
- Russia is the case that breaks the rule. The Bolsheviks took power in 1917, before there was any peace settlement at all, in a country that left the war. If the peace of 1919 explains totalitarianism, it cannot explain the first totalitarian state.
How to answer one well. Do not deny the facts in the counterargument; they are true. Argue about weight and about mechanism: say what the war did that made the later cause effective. For example, the Depression hit the United States, Britain and France too, and they did not become dictatorships — so the question becomes what was different about Germany in 1930, and the war is part of that answer.
Sources: Decree of the Reich President for the Protection of the People and State, 28 February 1933 (German History in Documents and Images) (germanhistorydocs.org); The Enabling Act, 24 March 1933 (German History in Documents and Images) (germanhistorydocs.org); Reichstagswahlergebnisse und Mandate in der Weimarer Republik (Deutscher Bundestag) (bundestag.de); The Reich Citizenship Law, doc. 1416-PS (Avalon Project, Yale Law School) (avalon.law.yale.edu)