
analyze the aims and negotiating roles of the leaders at Paris, the terms of the Treaty of Versailles and the Fourteen Points, and the causes and effects of the United States’ rejection of the League of Nations.
Instruction
In January 1919, delegates from more than thirty countries gathered in Paris to make peace. The defeated powers were not invited to negotiate; they were handed terms. Five treaties followed, one for each defeated state, and the most important was signed with Germany at Versailles on 28 June 1919 — five years to the day after the assassination in Sarajevo.
The Big Four and their aims. Woodrow Wilson of the United States came with his Fourteen Points: open diplomacy, freedom of the seas, lower trade barriers, arms reduction, adjustment of colonial claims, borders drawn along lines of nationality, and a League of Nations to keep the peace. Georges Clemenceau of France, whose country had lost about 1.4 million soldiers and whose northeast lay in ruins, wanted security: a Germany too weak ever to invade again, and reparations to rebuild. David Lloyd George of Britain had promised voters to make Germany pay, but privately feared a humiliated Germany would seek revenge. Vittorio Orlando of Italy wanted the territory promised to Italy in 1915, and walked out when he did not get all of it.
The terms for Germany. Germany lost about 13 percent of its European territory, including Alsace-Lorraine to France and land to a restored Poland; its army was limited to 100,000 men, with no air force; the Rhineland was demilitarised; its colonies were taken; and Article 231 made it accept responsibility for the war’s loss and damage — the basis for reparations, set in 1921 at 132 billion gold marks. Germans called it the Diktat, the dictated peace.
The world outside Europe came to Paris too. Japan proposed a clause affirming the equality of races in the League Covenant; it won a majority of votes in committee but Wilson, as chair, ruled that it needed unanimity, and it was dropped. China, an Allied country, asked for the return of the German concession in Shandong; the treaty gave it to Japan instead, and in China the news set off the May Fourth Movement of 1919, a turning point for Chinese nationalism. A young Vietnamese man later known as Ho Chi Minh submitted a petition asking for rights for his people; it was ignored. Emir Faisal spoke for Arab independence. Instead, Germany’s colonies and the Ottoman Empire’s Arab lands became mandates under Article 22, administered by Britain, France, Japan and others as a “sacred trust of civilization” — colonial rule in a new form.
Worked example: promise versus outcome. Take Point V. Promise: the interests of colonized populations must have equal weight. Outcome: the mandate system gave former German and Ottoman territories to other empires, and the colonies of the victors were not discussed at all. Judgment: the promise was applied, if at all, only to the losers’ empires. Your chart does this for four points.
America says no. Wilson brought the treaty home, but the Constitution requires a two-thirds vote of the Senate for ratification. Republican senators led by Henry Cabot Lodge wanted reservations, especially to Article 10 of the Covenant, which they feared could commit the United States to war without a vote of Congress. Wilson refused to compromise, suffered a stroke during a speaking tour in 1919, and the Senate rejected the treaty in November 1919 and again in March 1920. The United States never joined the League. Without it — and without Germany and the Soviet Union at first — the League lacked the power to enforce its decisions, a weakness the aggressors of the 1930s would exploit.
Could it have been different? (HI.4) Historians still debate whether the treaty was too harsh to accept and too weak to enforce, as the economist John Maynard Keynes argued in 1919, or whether later leaders’ choices, not the treaty itself, led to the next war, as the historian Margaret MacMillan has argued.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Reading: Wilson’s promises and the treaty’s terms
Woodrow Wilson, Address to Congress (the Fourteen Points), 8 January 1918, Points I, V and XIV; Treaty of Versailles (28 June 1919), Article 231; Covenant of the League of Nations, Article 22 · Public domain
As you read, mark every phrase that a colonized person in 1919 might have read as a promise.
Point I: Open covenants of peace, openly arrived at, after which there shall be no private international understandings of any kind but diplomacy shall proceed always frankly and in the public view.
Point V: A free, open-minded, and absolutely impartial adjustment of all colonial claims, based upon a strict observance of the principle that in determining all such questions of sovereignty the interests of the populations concerned must have equal weight with the equitable claims of the government whose title is to be determined.
Point XIV: A general association of nations must be formed under specific covenants for the purpose of affording mutual guarantees of political independence and territorial integrity to great and small states alike.
Treaty of Versailles, Article 231: The Allied and Associated Governments affirm and Germany accepts the responsibility of Germany and her allies for causing all the loss and damage to which the Allied and Associated Governments and their nationals have been subjected as a consequence of the war imposed upon them by the aggression of Germany and her allies.
Covenant, Article 22: To those colonies and territories which as a consequence of the late war have ceased to be under the sovereignty of the States which formerly governed them and which are inhabited by peoples not yet able to stand by themselves under the strenuous conditions of the modern world, there should be applied the principle that the well-being and development of such peoples form a sacred trust of civilisation…
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
What was Clemenceau’s main aim at the peace conference?
The United States joined the League of Nations after the Senate ratified the Treaty of Versailles.
Why did news from Paris set off the May Fourth Movement in China?
Complete the promise-versus-outcome chart for Points I, V, XIV and one other point of your choice: quote the promise, describe the outcome with evidence, and judge whether it was kept, partly kept or broken. Then write one paragraph: what difference might United States membership have made to the League, and what evidence makes you more or less confident?
How confident are you that you can analyze the peacemakers’ aims, the treaty’s terms and the effects of the United States’ rejection of the League?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Order: (a) Treaty of Versailles signed; (b) Fourteen Points; (c) Senate’s second rejection of the treaty; (d) reparations set at 132 billion gold marks; (e) May Fourth Movement.
Check your answer
Answer: (b) 8 January 1918 → (e) May 1919 → (a) 28 June 1919 → (c) March 1920 → (d) 1921.The treaty was signed five years to the day after the Sarajevo assassination; the reparations total came two years later. - Define mandate as used in Article 22 of the League Covenant, and give two examples.
Check your answer
Answer: A territory taken from Germany or the Ottoman Empire and administered by an Allied power under League supervision. Examples: Syria and Lebanon (France); Iraq, Palestine and Transjordan (Britain).A strong answer notes that colonized peoples often saw mandates as colonial rule under a new name.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- Source Article 231: “The Allied and Associated Governments affirm and Germany accepts the responsibility of Germany and her allies for causing all the loss and damage…” Who wrote it, and why did Germans call the treaty a Diktat?
Check your answer
Answer: The victorious Allies wrote it; Germany was not allowed to negotiate the terms, only to sign. Germans therefore saw the treaty, and this clause especially, as a dictated peace.A strong answer identifies the authors, the conditions under which Germany ‘accepted’, and why that matters for reading the clause. - Promise versus outcome: Point V promised that in colonial questions “the interests of the populations concerned must have equal weight.” How did the settlement treat that promise in China and in the Ottoman Arab lands?
Check your answer
Answer: China’s request for Shandong was refused and the German rights went to Japan; Ottoman Arab lands became British and French mandates rather than independent states. The promise was applied, if at all, only to the defeated empires’ territories, and not in the populations’ favor.A strong answer quotes the promise, gives specific outcomes, and judges whether it was kept. - Perspectives: how would Clemenceau and a German voter of 1919 each describe the treaty’s terms for Germany?
Check your answer
Answer: Clemenceau: necessary security for a France invaded twice in fifty years, and reparations to rebuild. The German voter: a humiliating, dictated peace that took territory, colonies and the army and blamed Germany alone.A strong answer states each view in its holder’s terms and connects it to that country’s experience of the war.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Review (World History A, Unit 4): which event of 1914 does the date of the Versailles signing, 28 June 1919, deliberately recall?
Check your answer
Answer: The assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand in Sarajevo on 28 June 1914.The choice of date linked the peace directly to the crisis that began the war, which reinforced the treaty’s message of German responsibility.
All Fourteen Points, the War-Guilt Clause, and the Two Articles the Senate Fought Over
Woodrow Wilson, address to a joint session of Congress, 8 January 1918; Treaty of Versailles, 28 June 1919, Articles 231 and 232; Covenant of the League of Nations, Articles 10, 16 and 22 · Public domain
Why this reading. Lesson 1.1 asks you to chart four of the Fourteen Points against what the treaty actually did, and then to judge what difference American membership might have made to the League. The lesson quotes three points; you need all fourteen to choose a fourth, and you need the two articles of the Covenant that the Senate fought over — Articles 10 and 16 — to say what membership would have committed the United States to. Both are here in full.
A. The Fourteen Points
Woodrow Wilson, address to a joint session of Congress, 8 January 1918. A work of the United States government: public domain. Transcribed from the Avalon Project text.
The first five points are general; points VI to XIII are territorial; point XIV creates the League.
- Open covenants of peace, openly arrived at, after which there shall be no private international understandings of any kind but diplomacy shall proceed always frankly and in the public view.
- Absolute freedom of navigation upon the seas, outside territorial waters, alike in peace and in war, except as the seas may be closed in whole or in part by international action for the enforcement of international covenants.
- The removal, so far as possible, of all economic barriers and the establishment of an equality of trade conditions among all the nations consenting to the peace and associating themselves for its maintenance.
- Adequate guarantees given and taken that national armaments will be reduced to the lowest point consistent with domestic safety.
- A free, open-minded, and absolutely impartial adjustment of all colonial claims, based upon a strict observance of the principle that in determining all such questions of sovereignty the interests of the populations concerned must have equal weight with the equitable claims of the government whose title is to be determined.
- The evacuation of all Russian territory and such a settlement of all questions affecting Russia as will secure the best and freest cooperation of the other nations of the world in obtaining for her an unhampered and unembarrassed opportunity for the independent determination of her own political development and national policy and assure her of a sincere welcome into the society of free nations under institutions of her own choosing; and, more than a welcome, assistance also of every kind that she may need and may herself desire.
- Belgium, the whole world will agree, must be evacuated and restored, without any attempt to limit the sovereignty which she enjoys in common with all other free nations.
- All French territory should be freed and the invaded portions restored, and the wrong done to France by Prussia in 1871 in the matter of Alsace-Lorraine, which has unsettled the peace of the world for nearly fifty years, should be righted, in order that peace may once more be made secure in the interest of all.
- A readjustment of the frontiers of Italy should be effected along clearly recognizable lines of nationality.
- The peoples of Austria-Hungary, whose place among the nations we wish to see safeguarded and assured, should be accorded the freest opportunity to autonomous development.
- Rumania, Serbia, and Montenegro should be evacuated; occupied territories restored; Serbia accorded free and secure access to the sea; and the relations of the several Balkan states to one another determined by friendly counsel along historically established lines of allegiance and nationality; and international guarantees of the political and economic independence and territorial integrity of the several Balkan states should be entered into.
- The Turkish portion of the present Ottoman Empire should be assured a secure sovereignty, but the other nationalities which are now under Turkish rule should be assured an undoubted security of life and an absolutely unmolested opportunity of autonomous development, and the Dardanelles should be permanently opened as a free passage to the ships and commerce of all nations under international guarantees.
- An independent Polish state should be erected which should include the territories inhabited by indisputably Polish populations, which should be assured a free and secure access to the sea, and whose political and economic independence and territorial integrity should be guaranteed by international covenant.
- A general association of nations must be formed under specific covenants for the purpose of affording mutual guarantees of political independence and territorial integrity to great and small states alike.
B. What the treaty said instead
Treaty of Peace between the Allied and Associated Powers and Germany, signed at Versailles 28 June 1919, Articles 231 and 232. Published before 1930: public domain.
Article 231. The Allied and Associated Governments affirm and Germany accepts the responsibility of Germany and her allies for causing all the loss and damage to which the Allied and Associated Governments and their nationals have been subjected as a consequence of the war imposed upon them by the aggression of Germany and her allies.
Article 232 (first paragraph). The Allied and Associated Governments recognize that the resources of Germany are not adequate, after taking into account permanent diminutions of such resources which will result from other provisions of the present Treaty, to make complete reparation for all such loss and damage.
Read those two together. Article 231 is the sentence Germans called the war-guilt clause; Article 232 is the Allies admitting, in the next breath, that Germany could not pay what Article 231 made it liable for. Point I promised open covenants; Germany was not in the room when these were written.
C. The League: what membership would have meant
Covenant of the League of Nations, Part I of the Treaty of Versailles, 1919, Articles 10, 16 and 22. Published before 1930: public domain. British spellings (“civilisation”) are the treaty’s own.
Article 10. The Members of the League undertake to respect and preserve as against external aggression the territorial integrity and existing political independence of all Members of the League. In case of any such aggression or in case of any threat or danger of such aggression the Council shall advise upon the means by which this obligation shall be fulfilled.
Article 16 (first two sentences). Should any Member of the League resort to war in disregard of its covenants under Articles 12, 13 or 15, it shall ipso facto be deemed to have committed an act of war against all other Members of the League, which hereby undertake immediately to subject it to the severance of all trade or financial relations, the prohibition of all intercourse between their nationals and the nationals of the covenant-breaking State, and the prevention of all financial, commercial or personal intercourse between the nationals of the covenant-breaking State and the nationals of any other State, whether a Member of the League or not. It shall be the duty of the Council in such case to recommend to the several Governments concerned what effective military, naval or air force the Members of the League shall severally contribute to the armed forces to be used to protect the covenants of the League.
Article 22 (first two paragraphs). To those colonies and territories which as a consequence of the late war have ceased to be under the sovereignty of the States which formerly governed them and which are inhabited by peoples not yet able to stand by themselves under the strenuous conditions of the modern world, there should be applied the principle that the well-being and development of such peoples form a sacred trust of civilisation…
The best method of giving practical effect to this principle is that the tutelage of such peoples should be entrusted to advanced nations who by reason of their resources, their experience or their geographical position can best undertake this responsibility, and that this tutelage should be exercised by them as Mandatories on behalf of the League.
The remaining paragraphs of Article 22, which we summarize rather than quote, sort the mandates into three classes: communities of the former Ottoman Empire whose independence could be “provisionally recognised” with advice from a Mandatory (Class A); territories in central Africa administered under conditions the Mandatory must guarantee (Class B); and territories such as South West Africa and the Pacific islands, administered under the Mandatory’s own laws as integral portions of its territory (Class C).
D. Why the United States did not join
The following paragraph is written by the course authors, not quoted, because we were not able to check a transcription of the reservations against the printed Congressional Record.
The Constitution requires two-thirds of the Senate to approve a treaty. The Senate Foreign Relations Committee, chaired by Henry Cabot Lodge of Massachusetts, reported the treaty with fourteen reservations. The reservation that mattered most concerned Article 10: it stated that the United States assumed no obligation to preserve the territorial integrity or political independence of any other country, or to use its armed forces under Article 10, unless Congress — which alone holds the power to declare war — should so provide in each case. Wilson instructed his supporters to vote against the treaty with the reservations attached, and it failed. The United States Senate rejected the Treaty of Versailles on 19 November 1919 — the first time in its history that it had rejected a peace treaty — and rejected it again in March 1920.
Use this when you write. Read Article 10 and Article 16 again and ask what the League could actually do in 1935 without the United States: it could recommend contributions of force, and it could require its members to cut off trade. Then ask what Article 16 would have been worth with the world’s largest economy inside it — and what the Senate’s objection tells you about how much of that power the United States was ever willing to hand over.
Sources: President Woodrow Wilson’s Fourteen Points, 8 January 1918 (Avalon Project, Yale Law School) (avalon.law.yale.edu); The Covenant of the League of Nations (Avalon Project, Yale Law School) (avalon.law.yale.edu); Treaty of Versailles, Part VIII: Reparation (Wikisource transcription) (en.wikisource.org); Senate Rejects the Treaty of Versailles (United States Senate) (senate.gov)