
explain the challenges and benefits of large land empires in Russia, China and the Middle East, describe how their governments changed to meet an interconnected world, and assess how class, ethnic and religious group, gender and age fixed people’s roles.
Instruction
A land empire is a state built by conquest and held together by roads, armies, tax collectors and rules about who may do what. Between about 1450 and 1750 four of them dominated Eurasia: the Ottoman Empire, the Mughal Empire in India, the Qing dynasty in China, and Russia. They shared problems: how to govern distant provinces, how to keep many peoples loyal, how to pay for armies, and how to deal with a world that European ships were now linking together. This lesson compares their answers.
Benefits and challenges. The benefits of size were security, trade and revenue. The Mughal state under Akbar collected agricultural taxes that amounted to well over half the output of a peasant cultivator, paid in a well-regulated silver currency, which let peasants and artisans enter larger markets. The Ottoman Empire, under Suleiman the Magnificent (1520-1566), captured Belgrade in 1521 and, after the Battle of Mohács in 1526, took the southern and central parts of Hungary. The challenges were distance and diversity. The Ottoman Empire ruled diverse peoples and granted varying levels of autonomy to its many confessional communities, called millets, to manage their own affairs. Large empires also faced fights over who would succeed the ruler and who would pay for the armies.
How governments changed. Machiavelli, writing in 1513, noticed a difference in kinds of rule: the Turk is “governed by one lord, the others are his servants” who are sent to different districts “and shifts and changes them as he chooses,” while the King of France sits among “an ancient body of lords” with “their own prerogatives.” In other words the sultan’s power came from appointment and the French king’s from a partnership. He concludes that the Turk’s state would be hard to seize but easy to hold. Russia changed on purpose. Peter the Great created a Governing Senate in 1711, the Collegia in 1717 and the Table of Ranks in 1722, founded Saint Petersburg on 29 June 1703, and was proclaimed Emperor of All Russia on 2 November 1721. He ordered courtiers to wear European clothing and cut off their beards, taxing those who refused. China took a different path. The Qing emperor, in 1793, answers Britain’s request for an ambassador: “Swaying the wide world, I have but one aim in view… strange and costly objects do not interest me.” He explains that all European trade had been carried on “at Canton” for many years. Where Peter reorganized to learn from Europe, the Qing court limited contact to one port.
Class, religion, age and gender. Empires fixed roles by status. Busbecq, a Habsburg ambassador, met wagon-loads of boys and girls bound for sale at Constantinople and wrote that there “was no distinction of Age; Old and Young were driven in Herds.” The Ottoman devshirme was the practice of forcibly recruiting boys from Balkan Christian families to be raised as Muslims and trained as soldiers or palace officials; it began probably before 1438, and it was resented. The millet system, on the other hand, gave Jewish and Christian communities their own courts. In Mughal India, Akbar allowed freedom of religion at his court, while Aurangzeb reinstated the jizya on non-Muslims. In Qing China, the Eight Banners, founded by Nurhaci, organized the Manchu conquerors with Han and Mongol elements. Peter the Great’s Table of Ranks tied status to service in 14 classes of military, civil and court posts. In each empire, group, age, sex and religion decided what a person could be.
Judging the evidence. No source in this lesson is neutral. Machiavelli analyzes power for a prince, Busbecq represents a rival empire, and Qianlong speaks for a court that believed it needed nothing. Large empires lasted for centuries, and they were often brilliant, but the people whose roles were fixed by birth or faith saw them differently from the rulers.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Missouri standard: 9-12.WH.3.GS.A
In Machiavelli’s comparison, how is the Ottoman ruler’s power different from the King of France’s?
Missouri standard: 9-12.WH.3.CC.C
Qianlong’s 1793 letter says China needed British manufactures.
Missouri standard: 9-12.WH.3.GS.A
Peter the Great founded Saint Petersburg in the year and issued the Table of Ranks in .
Missouri standard: 9-12.WH.3.PC.C
Which group was subject to the Ottoman devshirme?
Missouri standard: 9-12.WH.3.CC.C
Which was a benefit of the Mughal tax system under Akbar?
Missouri standard: 9-12.WH.3.CC.C, 9-12.WH.3.GS.A, 9-12.WH.3.PC.C
Fill in the empire table for the Ottoman, Mughal, Qing and Russian empires: one benefit, one challenge, one government change, and one social group whose role was fixed by status, religion, age or sex. Quote one phrase from Machiavelli, Busbecq or Qianlong. Then write two sentences on how class, religion, age or gender fixed a person’s role in one empire.
How confident are you that you can explain the benefits and challenges of large land empires, how their governments changed, and how status fixed people’s roles?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Suleiman the Magnificent reigned 1520 to 1566. For how many years?
Check your answer
Answer: 1566 – 1520 = 46 years.Subtract. - Peter the Great founded Saint Petersburg in 1703 and was proclaimed Emperor in 1721. How many years between the two events?
Check your answer
Answer: 1721 – 1703 = 18 years.Subtract.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- Quote the phrase in which Machiavelli says how the Turk’s servants are treated, and say what it implies about their loyalty to the people.
Check your answer
Answer: He says the sultan shifts and changes his administrators “as he chooses,” so they depend on him and not on local ties; their loyalty runs to the sultan rather than to the people.Quote, then infer. - Qianlong tells George III that European trade has long been at Canton. What does this show about how the Qing government dealt with an interconnected world?
Check your answer
Answer: It confined foreign trade to one port, so the court limited its contact with Europeans instead of reorganizing the state to learn from them, as Peter had in Russia.Compare Qing and Russian responses. - Busbecq says there was “no distinction of Age” among the captives he met. What does that detail show about how the slave trade treated age, and why should a historian also ask who Busbecq was?
Check your answer
Answer: Children and adults were traded alike. Busbecq was a Habsburg diplomat hostile to the Ottomans writing for European readers, so his account is evidence of the trade but may exaggerate the empire’s cruelty.Combine content and sourcing.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Review (lesson 5.1): in the Ottoman devshirme, which group did the law single out, and which two features of status from lesson 5.1 does it show?
Check your answer
Answer: Boys of Christian families in the Balkans; it shows rank and status assigned by birth and by religion, as the Manu verses and the estates of France did by birth.Link this lesson to stratification.
Three Views of Empire: The Turk, the Slave Road and the Celestial Empire
Niccolò Machiavelli, The Prince (1513), chapter IV, trans. W. K. Marriott, Project Gutenberg #1232; Ogier Ghislain de Busbecq, Travels into Turkey (London, 1744), Project Gutenberg #65414; Qianlong Emperor, edict to King George III, 1793, trans. E. Backhouse and J. O. P. Bland, Annals and Memoirs of the Court of Peking (Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1914), Fordham Internet Modern Sourcebook · Public domain
Why this reading. Lesson 5.7 asks what large land empires gained and what they struggled with, and how their governments changed. Three observers answer it from three angles: a Florentine analyst of power who compares the Ottoman sultan with the king of France, a Habsburg ambassador who met the empire’s slave road at the gates of its capital, and an emperor of China who answers a British request for a trade embassy. All three are outsiders or rulers speaking for their own interests, so read each for what it shows and for what it leaves out.
A. How to rule: a prince and his servants, or a prince and his barons
Niccolò Machiavelli, The Prince (written 1513), chapter IV, translated by W. K. Marriott. Project Gutenberg #1232. Public domain. Machiavelli never visited the Ottoman Empire; he writes from reports.
“I answer that the principalities of which one has record are found to be governed in two different ways; either by a prince, with a body of servants, who assist him to govern the kingdom as ministers by his favour and permission; or by a prince and barons, who hold that dignity by antiquity of blood and not by the grace of the prince. Such barons have states and their own subjects, who recognize them as lords and hold them in natural affection. Those states that are governed by a prince and his servants hold their prince in more consideration, because in all the country there is no one who is recognized as superior to him, and if they yield obedience to another they do it as to a minister and official, and they do not bear him any particular affection. The examples of these two governments in our time are the Turk and the King of France. The entire monarchy of the Turk is governed by one lord, the others are his servants; and, dividing his kingdom into sanjaks, he sends there different administrators, and shifts and changes them as he chooses. But the King of France is placed in the midst of an ancient body of lords, acknowledged by their own subjects, and beloved by them; they have their own prerogatives, nor can the king take these away except at his peril. Therefore, he who considers both of these states will recognize great difficulties in seizing the state of the Turk, but, once it is conquered, great ease in holding it.”
B. At the gates of Constantinople
Ogier Ghislain de Busbecq, ambassador of the Habsburg court to Suleiman, Travels into Turkey, English translation of 1744. Project Gutenberg #65414. Public domain. Busbecq was a Christian diplomat writing for a European audience and was hostile to the Ottoman system; the 1744 translator adds his own wording. Treat the passage as a witness to the slave trade, not as an even-handed account of the empire.
“just as I was gone out of the Gates of Constantinople, I met whole Waggon-Loads of Boys and Girls, which were brought out of Hungary to Constantinople to be sold; no Merchandize is more frequent amongst them than that. For, as when we leave Antwerp, we meet with all sorts of merchantable Commodities importing into the Town, so here, ever now and then, there passed by us abundance of poor miserable Christian Slaves, which were going to be sold in the Markets to a perpetual Bondage. There was no distinction of Age; Old and Young were driven in Herds, or Companies, or else were tied in a long Chain, as we use to tail Horses when we carry them to Fairs. When I beheld this woful sight, I could not forbear weeping and bemoaning the unhappy State of poor Christendom.”
C. China answers Britain, 1793
The Qianlong Emperor to King George III, 1793, translated by E. Backhouse and J. O. P. Bland, Annals and Memoirs of the Court of Peking (1914), Fordham Internet Modern Sourcebook. Public domain. Words such as “barbarian” and “tribute” are the translators’ renderings of the court’s own terms.
“Swaying the wide world, I have but one aim in view, namely, to maintain a perfect governance and to fulfil the duties of the State: strange and costly objects do not interest me. If I have commanded that the tribute offerings sent by you, O King, are to be accepted, this was solely in consideration for the spirit which prompted you to dispatch them from afar. Our dynasty’s majestic virtue has penetrated unto every country under Heaven, and Kings of all nations have offered their costly tribute by land and sea. As your Ambassador can see for himself, we possess all things.”
“Hitherto, all European nations, including your own country’s barbarian merchants, have carried on their trade with our Celestial Empire at Canton.”
About these excerpts. Every excerpt is word for word from the translation named. Passages not shown are omitted, not changed.
Sources: The Prince, trans. W. K. Marriott (Project Gutenberg #1232) (gutenberg.org); Travels into Turkey, Busbecq, 1744 translation (Project Gutenberg #65414) (gutenberg.org); Qianlong to George III, 1793 (Fordham Internet Modern Sourcebook) (sourcebooks.fordham.edu)