
develop a precise claim about the relationship between two addresses and a counterclaim with its own evidence, pointing out the strengths and limitations of both.
Instruction
Your essay will argue about how two or more addresses define liberty and its obligations. The hardest part is making a claim about the relationship between texts rather than summarizing each one.
Content comparison (weak). Lincoln and Kennedy both talk about liberty and duty. True of almost any two speeches; it cannot organize an essay.
Relationship claim (strong). Kennedy inherits Lincoln’s idea that liberty carries obligation, but reverses its direction: Lincoln asks the nation to heal those it has harmed, while Kennedy asks citizens to serve a nation facing an enemy — a shift from reconciliation to mobilization that reflects the Cold War. This claim names what is shared, what changes and why.
Build the counterclaim at full strength (9-10.W.2.A). Develop claims and counterclaims fairly, supplying evidence for each and pointing out strengths and limitations. For the claim above, a strong counterclaim is that Kennedy’s speech also contains reconciliation — “Let us never negotiate out of fear. But let us never fear to negotiate” — so the contrast with Lincoln is overstated. Quote it; take it seriously.
Answering. Refute (show the evidence is weaker than it looks), concede and outweigh, or concede and qualify. Qualifying often makes the best essays: Kennedy’s speech does make room for negotiation, but negotiation with an enemy is not the same as Lincoln’s charity toward a defeated fellow-citizen.
Drawing evidence from informational texts (9-10.RI.1.A). Choose short, exact quotations; analyze each; and delineate at least one address’s argument (Lesson 3.3) as part of your evidence. Quote from the official texts — the National Archives, the Library of Congress or presidential libraries — and cite them.
Introduce a precise claim (9-10.W.2.A). Your introduction should establish why the relationship matters, state the claim, and distinguish it from a simpler reading.
The organizer (9-10.W.3.A). Draft your claim; three reasons with a quotation for each; the counterclaim with its own quotation; your answer; one strength and one limitation of your own claim. Plan where you will analyze a sentence’s structure (Lesson 3.2) as evidence.
Reading: Claims and counterclaims across documents: a mentor paragraph, a model organizer and a revision
George Washington, Farewell Address (1796), Avalon Project, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/washing.asp; Abraham Lincoln, Second Inaugural Address (1865), Avalon Project, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/19th_century/lincoln2.asp; John F. Kennedy, Inaugural Address (1961), Avalon Project, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/kennedy.asp. All retrieved 2026-09-26. · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (U.S. government works and George Washington, 1796)
The mentor paragraph is quoted whole from Washington. The organizer, revisions and criteria are SLS original; the quotations inside the organizer are exact.
This workshop gives you a mentor paragraph from a public-domain text, a model Stage 1 organizer, a before-and-after revision, and the criteria your organizer will be scored against. The quotations in the model come from the four addresses in Lesson 3.1 and are checked against the official texts. Everything labeled SLS original is written for this course.
1. A mentor paragraph: claim, concession and qualification (George Washington, Farewell Address, 1796)
Washington makes a claim, grants what an objector would say, and then narrows the claim so it cannot be dismissed. Read it for the moves, not the topic.
It is our true policy to steer clear of permanent alliances with any portion of the foreign world; so far, I mean, as we are now at liberty to do it; for let me not be understood as capable of patronizing infidelity to existing engagements. I hold the maxim no less applicable to public than to private affairs, that honesty is always the best policy. I repeat it, therefore, let those engagements be observed in their genuine sense. But, in my opinion, it is unnecessary and would be unwise to extend them. Taking care always to keep ourselves by suitable establishments on a respectable defensive posture, we may safely trust to temporary alliances for extraordinary emergencies.
The moves (SLS original).
- Claim: it is the true policy to avoid permanent alliances.
- Concession: “for let me not be understood as capable of patronizing infidelity to existing engagements.” Washington grants the objection that promises must be kept.
- Qualification: the claim covers only new commitments (“unnecessary and would be unwise to extend them”).
- Limit that stops the reader from over-reading: temporary alliances for extraordinary emergencies remain possible.
Notice that the paragraph is stronger because it does not overclaim.
2. Before and after: the claim (SLS original)
| Draft | Problem | Revision |
|---|---|---|
| Lincoln and Kennedy both talk about liberty and duty. | A content comparison. True of almost any two speeches; it cannot organize an essay. | Kennedy inherits Lincoln’s idea that liberty carries obligation but redirects it: Lincoln asks the nation to heal those it has harmed, and Kennedy asks citizens to defend a nation facing an enemy. The shift is from reconciliation to mobilization. |
| Kennedy is a more aggressive speaker than Lincoln. | A judgment of personality, not of the texts. | Kennedy defines the obligation of liberty as a pledge made to the world (“pay any price”); Lincoln defines it as care for the wounded (“bind up the nation’s wounds”). |
3. A model Stage 1 organizer (SLS original)
Relationship claim. Kennedy inherits Lincoln’s idea that liberty carries obligation but redirects it, from reconciliation with a defeated fellow citizen to mobilization against a foreign rival.
Why it matters (for the introduction). Each speech looks like the same promise, but the obligation in each points a different way. The difference shows how a nation’s idea of liberty changes with its danger.
Reason 1 (Lincoln’s obligation). Lincoln asks for charity and care: “With malice toward none, with charity for all” The purpose that follows is “to bind up the nation’s wounds”
Reason 2 (Kennedy’s obligation). Kennedy asks for a pledge against an enemy: “we shall pay any price, bear any burden, meet any hardship, support any friend, oppose any foe” The audience is the world, not the nation.
Reason 3 (what changed). The danger changed. Lincoln’s is a war that is nearly over and whose cause is a wrong the nation must answer for. Kennedy’s is a rivalry with no end in sight (his phrase later in the speech is “a long twilight struggle,” which you may quote from the text in Lesson 3.1 or from the official text).
Counterclaim (at full strength). Kennedy’s speech also contains reconciliation. He asks both sides to “begin anew” and says “Let us never negotiate out of fear. But let us never fear to negotiate.” So the contrast with Lincoln is overstated.
Answer (concede and qualify). Kennedy does make room for negotiation, and the passage above is the evidence. But his sentence asks an enemy power to negotiate about arms and inspection, while Lincoln asks for charity toward those who have just been defeated and who are fellow citizens. The two passages share the phrase “let us” and a wish for peace; they do not share the party asked to change.
Strength and limitation of my own claim. Strength: it accounts for both speeches and for the counterclaim. Limitation: it compares the promises only. It does not show what either president did afterward.
Sentence whose structure I will analyze (Lesson 3.2). “Let us never negotiate out of fear. But let us never fear to negotiate.” The two short sentences share almost every word; only the object of “fear” changes.
4. Criteria for Stage 1 (SLS original)
| Criterion | Strong | Developing |
|---|---|---|
| Claim | Names what is shared, what changes and why. | Says both texts are about the same topic. |
| Reasons | Three reasons, each with a short quotation from the official text and an analysis sentence. | Reasons without quotations, or quotations without analysis. |
| Counterclaim | Stated fairly, with its own quotation, and answered by refuting, conceding and outweighing, or conceding and qualifying. | Missing, or stated so weakly that no one would hold it. |
| Limitation | Names where your own claim is weaker. | Claims no limitation. |
| Language as evidence | Names one sentence and what its structure does. | Names a sentence without saying how its structure works. |
5. Your turn
Choose two of the four addresses. Write a claim about how they relate that a reader could argue with. Then write the counterclaim you would most dislike having to answer.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which is a relationship claim rather than a content comparison?
Naming a limitation of your own claim weakens your essay.
Submit Stage 1: your relationship claim; three reasons each with a quotation; a counterclaim with its own quotation; your answer; one strength and one limitation of your claim; and the sentence whose structure you will analyze.
How confident are you that you can make a claim about how two documents relate, and develop a counterclaim with its own evidence?