
delineate and evaluate the argument and specific claims in an address, assessing whether the reasoning is valid and the evidence relevant and sufficient, and identify false statements or fallacious reasoning.
Instruction
Admiring a speech is easy; evaluating it is the skill. 9-10.RI.2.D asks you to delineate an argument — lay out its parts — and evaluate it: is the reasoning valid, and is the evidence relevant and sufficient?
Four parts to delineate. The claim — what the speaker wants the audience to accept. The reasons — why. The evidence — facts, examples, authority or experience offered in support. The assumptions — what must also be true for the reasons to support the claim, often unstated.
Worked example: Roosevelt, 1941. Claim: the United States should give full material support to nations fighting aggression, even at the risk of war. Reasons: American security depends on the survival of democracies abroad; appeasement will not stop aggressors; the freedoms Americans value must be secured worldwide. Evidence: the fall of democracies in Europe, the aggressors’ record, historical analogies. Assumption: that the fate of democracies abroad directly determines American security — which isolationists of the time disputed. Delineating the assumption shows exactly where the debate lay.
Evaluate reasoning apart from your agreement. A speech can reach a conclusion you accept through reasoning that is weak, or reach one you reject through reasoning that is strong. Evaluation asks: does the conclusion follow? Is the evidence enough? Is anything false or exaggerated?
Fallacies to watch for. False dilemma — presenting two options as the only ones. Hasty generalization — a broad claim from thin evidence. Slippery slope — assuming one step must lead to a chain of disasters. Appeal to fear used in place of evidence. Great speeches are not immune; Kennedy’s pledge to “pay any price” invites the question whether any price is truly acceptable — a question the Vietnam War would soon pose.
Evaluating a speaker (9-10.SL.1.B). For spoken texts, add the speaker’s point of view and use of rhetoric: how emphasis, tone and word choice shape the argument’s force. Eisenhower’s authority as a former general gives his warning weight that the same words from a critic of the military would lack — an appeal to ethos you can evaluate.
The seminar (9-10.SL.1.B). Each student delineates one address in full. In discussion, propel the conversation with questions that probe reasoning — “What would have to be true for that reason to support the claim?” — and connect it to broader themes, such as whether liberty requires sacrifice, or whether leaders should ever ask citizens to accept risk for others’ freedom. Bring in a classmate who has not yet spoken.
Across documents (9-10.RI.3.B / 9-10.RI.3.C). After delineating, compare assumptions across two addresses. Lincoln assumes the nation can be reconciled; Eisenhower assumes a free people can restrain its own power. Assumptions are where documents most deeply agree or disagree.
Reading: Delineating an argument: Roosevelt worked, Washington compared, and a seminar protocol
Franklin D. Roosevelt, Annual Message to Congress (1941), U.S. National Archives, https://www.archives.gov/milestone-documents/president-franklin-roosevelts-annual-message-to-congress; George Washington, Farewell Address (1796), Avalon Project, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/washing.asp; John F. Kennedy, Inaugural Address (1961), Avalon Project, https://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/kennedy.asp; Dwight D. Eisenhower, Farewell Address (1961), U.S. National Archives, https://www.archives.gov/milestone-documents/president-dwight-d-eisenhowers-farewell-address. All retrieved 2026-09-26. · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (U.S. government works and George Washington, 1796)
Passages are quoted whole from the sources named. The charts, protocol and model contribution are SLS original.
Your delineation needs the passage in front of you. This reading supplies the passages, one fully worked chart (Roosevelt), an earlier position for comparison (Washington), a protocol and question stems for the seminar, and a model contribution. The delineation, the notes and the model are SLS original.
1. Roosevelt, Annual Message to Congress (January 6, 1941): the passages to delineate
Read all four passages, then read the worked chart below.
R1. The danger.
Armed defense of democratic existence is now being gallantly waged in four continents. If that defense fails, all the population and all the resources of Europe, Asia, Africa and Australasia will be dominated by the conquerors. Let us remember that the total of those populations and their resources in those four continents greatly exceeds the sum total of the population and the resources of the whole of the Western Hemisphere-many times over.
R2. The rejection of a bargain peace.
No realistic American can expect from a dictator’s peace international generosity, or return of true independence, or world disarmament, or freedom of expression, or freedom of religion -or even good business. Such a peace would bring no security for us or for our neighbors. “Those, who would give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety.”
R3. The policy.
Second, by an impressive expression of the public will and without regard to partisanship, we are committed to full support of all those resolute peoples, everywhere, who are resisting aggression and are thereby keeping war away from our Hemisphere. By this support, we express our determination that the democratic cause shall prevail; and we strengthen the defense and the security of our own nation. Third, by an impressive expression of the public will and without regard to partisanship, we are committed to the proposition that principles of morality and considerations for our own security will never permit us to acquiesce in a peace dictated by aggressors and sponsored by appeasers. We know that enduring peace cannot be bought at the cost of other people’s freedom.
R4. The proposal.
Our most useful and immediate role is to act as an arsenal for them as well as for ourselves. They do not need man power, but they do need billions of dollars worth of the weapons of defense.
R5. The reply to an objection.
In fulfillment of this purpose we will not be intimidated by the threats of dictators that they will regard as a breach of international law or as an act of war our aid to the democracies which dare to resist their aggression. Such aid is not an act of war, even if a dictator should unilaterally proclaim it so to be.
2. A worked delineation chart: Roosevelt (SLS original)
| Part | Roosevelt, 1941 |
|---|---|
| Claim | The United States should give full support to nations resisting aggression, even though that support may be called an act of war (R3, R4, R5). |
| Reason 1 | The security of the United States is tied to the fate of democracies abroad (R1). |
| Evidence for reason 1 | If the defense fails, the population and resources of four continents “will be dominated by the conquerors,” and they greatly exceed those of the Western Hemisphere (R1). |
| Reason 2 | A peace made with dictators would give no security (R2). |
| Evidence for reason 2 | The speech claims that no realistic American can expect “freedom of expression, or freedom of religion” from a dictator’s peace (R2). This is asserted, not shown in these lines; the speech elsewhere points to the invaded nations. |
| Reason 3 | Aid is a cheaper and safer way to defend the country than fighting later (R4; the speech says the democracies “do not need man power”). |
| Unstated assumption | That the fate of democracies overseas directly determines American security. This is the point on which the debate turned. |
| Evaluation | The reasoning is valid if the assumption is granted: the conclusion follows from the reasons. The evidence for the assumption is a projection (what four continents would mean if conquered), which is relevant but not proof. R5 is a claim about international law, offered without support in those lines. The speech also attacks opponents (see section 4), which does not answer their argument. |
3. An earlier position to compare: Washington, Farewell Address (1796)
Roosevelt speaks 145 years after Washington, and he argues against a position of this kind, which he calls “enforced isolation.” Washington states his own position in his own terms. Read it as an argument, not as a slogan: the claim, the reasons and the assumption are all there.
W1.
The great rule of conduct for us in regard to foreign nations is in extending our commercial relations, to have with them as little political connection as possible.
W2.
Europe has a set of primary interests which to us have none; or a very remote relation. Hence she must be engaged in frequent controversies, the causes of which are essentially foreign to our concerns. Hence, therefore, it must be unwise in us to implicate ourselves by artificial ties in the ordinary vicissitudes of her politics, or the ordinary combinations and collisions of her friendships or enmities. Our detached and distant situation invites and enables us to pursue a different course. If we remain one people under an efficient government. the period is not far off when we may defy material injury from external annoyance; when we may take such an attitude as will cause the neutrality we may at any time resolve upon to be scrupulously respected; when belligerent nations, under the impossibility of making acquisitions upon us, will not lightly hazard the giving us provocation; when we may choose peace or war, as our interest, guided by justice, shall counsel. Why forego the advantages of so peculiar a situation? Why quit our own to stand upon foreign ground?
W3.
It is our true policy to steer clear of permanent alliances with any portion of the foreign world; so far, I mean, as we are now at liberty to do it; for let me not be understood as capable of patronizing infidelity to existing engagements. I hold the maxim no less applicable to public than to private affairs, that honesty is always the best policy. I repeat it, therefore, let those engagements be observed in their genuine sense. But, in my opinion, it is unnecessary and would be unwise to extend them.
A delineation of Washington (SLS original): the claim is that the country should keep political connections with foreign nations to a minimum. The reasons are that Europe has interests unlike ours and is often in controversy, and that alliances would entangle American peace in causes foreign to American concerns. The evidence is the “detached and distant situation” of the nation. The assumption is that distance and strength can protect the country from outside events. Compare it with Roosevelt’s assumption in the chart above: the two speakers disagree about whether that assumption is still true.
4. Passages for evaluation: is the reasoning valid?
E1. Roosevelt on opponents.
We must especially beware of that small group of selfish men who would clip the wings of the American eagle in order to feather their own nests.
Ask: does this passage answer an argument, or describe the people who make it? What would a fair statement of the opposing view look like?
E2. Kennedy on arms.
We dare not tempt them with weakness. For only when our arms are sufficient beyond doubt can we be certain beyond doubt that they will never be employed.
Ask: is the reasoning valid? What must be true about the other side for this argument to hold? Is there a second reading in which the same premise leads to a different conclusion?
E3. Kennedy on the pledge.
Let every nation know, whether it wishes us well or ill, that we shall pay any price, bear any burden, meet any hardship, support any friend, oppose any foe, in order to assure the survival and the success of liberty.
Ask: “any price” is a very broad claim. What evidence does the speech give that no price is too high? What would a limit look like?
E4. Eisenhower on authority.
A vital element in keeping the peace is our military establishment. Our arms must be mighty, ready for instant action, so that no potential aggressor may be tempted to risk his own destruction. . . . American makers of plowshares could, with time and as required, make swords as well. But now we can no longer risk emergency improvisation of national defense; we have been compelled to create a permanent armaments industry of vast proportions. . . . This conjunction of an immense military establishment and a large arms industry is new in the American experience. . . .Yet we must not fail to comprehend its grave implications. . . . In the councils of government, we must guard against the acquisition of unwarranted influence, whether sought or unsought, by the military-industrial complex. The potential for the disastrous rise of misplaced power exists and will persist. The end of Eisenhower’s term as President not only marked the end of the 1950s, but also the end of an era in government. A new, younger generation was rising to national power that would set a more youthful, vigorous course. His farewell address was a warning to his successors of one of the many things they would have to be wary of in the coming years. Teach with this document. This document is available on DocsTeach, the online tool for teaching with documents from the National Archives. Find teaching activities that incorporate this document, or create your own online activity. Previous DocumentNext Document Transcript My fellow Americans: Three days from now, after half a century in the service of our country, I shall lay down the responsibilities of office as, in traditional and solemn ceremony, the authority of the Presidency is vested in my successor. This evening I come to you with a message of leave-taking and farewell, and to share a few final thoughts with you, my countrymen. Like every other citizen, I wish the new President, and all who will labor with him, Godspeed. I pray that the coming years will be blessed with peace and prosperity for all. Our people expect their President and the Congress to find essential agreement on issues of great moment, the wise resolution of which will better shape the future of the Nation. My own relations with the Congress, which began on a remote and tenuous basis when, long ago, a member of the Senate appointed me to West Point, have since ranged to the intimate during the war and immediate post-war period, and, finally, to the mutually interdependent during these past eight years. In this final relationship, the Congress and the Administration have, on most vital issues, cooperated well, to serve the national good rather than mere partisanship, and so have assured that the business of the Nation should go forward. So, my official relationship with the Congress ends in a feeling, on my part, of gratitude that we have been able to do so much together. ****** We now stand ten years past the midpoint of a century that has witnessed four major wars among great nations. Three of these involved our own country. Despite these holocausts America is today the strongest, the most influential and most productive nation in the world. Understandably proud of this pre-eminence, we yet realize that America’s leadership and prestige depend, not merely upon our unmatched material progress, riches and military strength, but on how we use our power in the interests of world peace and human betterment. ****** Throughout America’s adventure in free government, our basic purposes have been to keep the peace; to foster progress in human achievement, and to enhance liberty, dignity and integrity among people and among nations. To strive for less would be unworthy of a free and religious people. Any failure traceable to arrogance, or our lack of comprehension or readiness to sacrifice would inflict upon us grievous hurt both at home and abroad. Progress toward these noble goals is persistently threatened by the conflict now engulfing the world. It commands our whole attention, absorbs our very beings. We face a hostile ideology-global in scope, atheistic in character, ruthless in purpose, and insidious in method. Unhappily the danger it poses promises to be of indefinite duration. To meet it successfully, there is called for, not so much the emotional and transitory sacrifices of crisis, but rather those which enable us to carry forward steadily, surely, and without complaint the burdens of a prolonged and complex struggle-with liberty at stake. Only thus shall we remain, despite every provocation, on our charted course toward permanent peace and human betterment. Crises there will continue to be. In meeting them, whether foreign or domestic, great or small, there is a recurring temptation to feel that some spectacular and costly action could become the miraculous solution to all current difficulties. A huge increase in newer elements of our defense; development of unrealistic programs to cure every ill in agriculture; a dramatic expansion in basic and applied research-these and many other possibilities, each possibly promising in itself, may be suggested as the only way to the road we wish to travel. But each proposal must be weighed in the light of a broader consideration: the need to maintain balance in and among national programs-balance between the private and the public economy, balance between cost and hoped for advantage-balance between the clearly necessary and the comfortably desirable; balance between our essential requirements as a nation and the duties imposed by the nation upon the individual; balance between action of the moment and the national welfare of the future. Good judgment seeks balance and progress; lack of it eventually finds imbalance and frustration. The record of many decades stands as proof that our people and their government have, in the main, understood these truths and have responded to them well, in the face of stress and threat. But threats, new in kind or degree, constantly arise. I mention two only. ****** A vital element in keeping the peace is our military establishment. Our arms must be mighty, ready for instant action, so that no potential aggressor may be tempted to risk his own destruction. Our military organization today bears little relation to that known by any of my predecessors in peace time, or indeed by the fighting men of World War II or Korea. Until the latest of our world conflicts, the United States had no armaments industry. American makers of plowshares could, with time and as required, make swords as well. But now we can no longer risk emergency improvisation of national defense; we have been compelled to create a permanent armaments industry of vast proportions. Added to this, three and a half million men and women are directly engaged in the defense establishment. We annually spend on military security more than the net income of all United State corporations. This conjunction of an immense military establishment and a large arms industry is new in the American experience. The total influence-economic, political, even spiritual-is felt in every city, every state house, every office of the Federal government. We recognize the imperative need for this development. Yet we must not fail to comprehend its grave implications. Our toil, resources and livelihood are all involved; so is the very structure of our society.
Ask: the speaker is a former general. How does that ethos give weight to the warning? Would the same words from a critic of the military carry the same weight? Does the argument stand without his authority?
5. The seminar protocol (SLS original)
- Two minutes of silent reading and marking of your passage.
- Each speaker states the claim of the address he or she delineated, in one sentence, before anything else.
- Speakers who have not yet spoken go before speakers who have.
- Every contribution refers to a line in the passage. “The passage says …” comes before “I think …”.
- Before answering, restate the previous point in your own words.
- The last five minutes: each person names one assumption from another address that he or she could not have found alone.
Question stems.
- What would have to be true for that reason to support the claim?
- Is this evidence relevant, and is it enough?
- What does the speaker assume that the audience already believes?
- Which of these assumptions do our four addresses share, and which do they dispute?
- Is this a reason, or is it an appeal to fear, authority or pride?
- What is the strongest version of the other side, and does the speaker meet it?
- Does liberty require sacrifice? Whose, and who decides?
Model contribution (SLS original). “Roosevelt’s reasons hold together only if the assumption in the chart is true. The passage on the four continents shows how he uses it: he compares populations and resources, but he offers no evidence that conquest overseas would come to our shores. Washington in 1796 makes the opposite assumption, that distance protects us. So the two speeches do not disagree about liberty. They disagree about whether the ocean still counts. To whoever delineated Eisenhower: Does his warning rest on the same kind of assumption?” (The final question brings a classmate who has not yet spoken into the conversation.)
6. A blank chart for your own address (SLS original)
| Part | Your address |
|---|---|
| Claim | |
| Reason 1, evidence | |
| Reason 2, evidence | |
| Reason 3, evidence | |
| Unstated assumption | |
| Is the reasoning valid? Is the evidence sufficient? Any fallacy? | |
| Question for the seminar |
For Lincoln, use the complete Second Inaugural Address in Lesson 3.1; for Eisenhower and Kennedy, the passages there and in section 4 above.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
In the Four Freedoms speech, what is the key assumption isolationists disputed?
If you agree with a speech’s conclusion, its reasoning must be valid.
Delineate one address: claim, three reasons, evidence for each, and one unstated assumption. Evaluate whether the reasoning is valid and the evidence sufficient, naming any fallacy. Then write the question you will use to probe reasoning in the seminar.
How confident are you that you can delineate an argument and evaluate its reasoning separately from whether I agree?