
research a noted artist, analyze the distinctive features of their style, and present a four-step criticism of a representative work.
Instruction
In this lab you select a noted artist, research them, and record a criticism presentation on a work that best represents them, using the art-criticism model as a framework. That research then drives the altered hat or shoe you make in Lesson 4.4. This lab teaches you to identify what makes a style distinctive, so that your altered object is recognizably “in the style of” someone without being a copy.
Choosing an artist. Choose an artist with a distinctive visual language and enough available information. You may choose from any culture and period. Look beyond the most famous names; the course’s museum collections include, for example, the woodblock prints of Hokusai and Hiroshige, the posters of Toulouse-Lautrec, the relief prints of José Guadalupe Posada, the sculpture of Edmonia Lewis, the Rinpa painting of Ogata Kōrin, the collage of Kurt Schwitters and the paintings of Van Gogh, Seurat and Cezanne. Closer to home, the Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art in Kansas City holds George Caleb Bingham’s Canvassing for a Vote (1852), which the museum says is set in his hometown of Arrow Rock, Missouri; Bingham was active in Missouri politics for most of his adult life, and the painting builds a politician and three potential voters into a solid pyramid at its center. You may also choose a living artist, in which case you study their work through the artist’s own website or a museum’s pages and describe it rather than reproduce it.
What is a style? A style is a set of recurring choices that make an artist’s work recognizable. Break it down under five headings. Subject: what they depict or refer to. Formal language: characteristic lines, shapes, colors, patterns, compositions. Materials and technique: what they make things from and how the process shows. Scale and presentation: how big, how displayed. Ideas: what the work is about, and why. A style is not one trick (dots, drips, outlines); it is the combination.
A worked style analysis. José Guadalupe Posada (1852-1913) made thousands of images for cheap printed broadsides in Mexico City, including ¡Terrible y verdadera noticia! (Terrible and Real News!) (1910, Art Institute of Chicago) and The Skeleton of the Buses (c. 1900-10, Cleveland Museum of Art). Subject: news, disasters, crimes, politics and calaveras, skeletons dressed and acting like the living. Formal language: strong black-and-white contrast, lively line, figures in motion, crowded compositions. Materials: relief printing, sometimes photo-relief, combined with text on inexpensive paper. Ideas: popular news and satire for a wide audience; death as a great equalizer. An altered shoe in Posada’s style might be black and white, carved or drawn with lively line, carrying a small satirical scene and a caption. It would not simply paste a copied skeleton onto the shoe.
The presentation. Three minutes: one slide or printed page with the artist’s name, dates and nationality or community, and one representative work; then the four steps (description, analysis, interpretation, judgment) applied to that work; then your five-heading style summary. Cite your sources. Record the presentation as a video or as audio over your slide. Then watch it back the next day with the self-review sheet in the reading, and re-record if one of the four steps is missing. You may show the recording to a family member and ask them one question: what did they learn about the artist?
Judging the artist’s impact. Standard VA:Cn11A.III asks you to assess the impact of an artist on the beliefs, values or behaviors of a society. End your presentation with one claim about your artist’s impact and one piece of evidence for it, such as influence on later artists, a movement they shaped, or how their images circulated.
Style and ethics. Working “in the style of” an artist is a long tradition of learning, but it carries responsibilities: credit the artist clearly, transform rather than copy, and take particular care with the sacred or culturally specific designs of living communities, which are not open for anyone to use.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which description of a style is strongest?
Which practice is most responsible when working in another artist’s style?
State one claim about your artist’s impact on later artists or on society, with one piece of evidence. Then name the criterion you used to judge their representative work.
How confident are you that you can analyze an artist’s style under five headings and present a four-step criticism of a representative work?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- List the five headings the lesson uses to break down a style.
Check your answer
Answer: Subject; formal language; materials and technique; scale and presentation; ideas.A style is the combination, not one trick such as dots, drips or outlines. - Define broadside and calavera.
Check your answer
Answer: Broadside: a single printed sheet sold cheaply, carrying news, songs or images. Calavera: a skeleton or skull figure, often dressed and acting like the living, in Mexican popular art.Both are central to Posada’s style. - What does the three-minute presentation contain, in order?
Check your answer
Answer: One slide or printed page with the artist’s name, dates and nationality or community and one representative work; the four steps (description, analysis, interpretation, judgment) applied to that work; a five-heading style summary; a claim about the artist’s impact with one piece of evidence; and cited sources.Watch it back the next day and re-record if a step is missing.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- Write a five-heading style analysis of Posada using the lesson’s facts.
Check your answer
Answer: Subject: news, disasters, crimes, politics and calaveras. Formal language: strong black-and-white contrast, lively line, figures in motion, crowded compositions. Materials and technique: relief printing (sometimes photo-relief) with text on inexpensive paper. Scale and presentation: single cheap broadsides (the Cleveland sheet is about 39 x 29 cm). Ideas: popular news and satire for a wide audience; death as a great equalizer.All five headings must appear; together they make the style recognizable. - Bingham’s Canvassing for a Vote (1852, Nelson-Atkins) is a candidate for the presentation. Write a description sentence and an analysis sentence for it from the lesson’s facts.
Check your answer
Answer: Description: “A politician talks with three potential voters in Arrow Rock, Missouri, Bingham’s hometown.” Analysis: “Bingham builds the four figures into a solid pyramid at the center, so the eye settles on the conversation.”Description states what is there; analysis explains how the parts are organized. - Write one claim about an artist’s impact and one piece of evidence, as Cn11.HSIII requires. Use Cezanne or Posada.
Check your answer
Answer: Model (Cezanne): “Cezanne changed how later painters built pictures: the Nelson-Atkins label says his planes of color and set-aside perspective were paving the way for Cubism, which Picasso and Braque developed around 1908-1912.”Acceptable evidence types: influence on later artists, a movement shaped, or how the images circulated (Posada’s cheap broadsides reached a wide audience). - A classmate’s plan is to paste a printed copy of a famous Posada skeleton onto a shoe. Using the lesson’s ethics, explain what is wrong and how to fix it.
Check your answer
Answer: It copies rather than transforms. Instead, translate Posada’s choices (black-and-white contrast, lively line, a small satirical scene with a caption) into new imagery drawn or carved on the shoe, and credit Posada clearly.Working in the style of an artist means credit, transformation, and care with sacred or culturally specific designs of living communities.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Review (Lesson 1.3): in your presentation’s judgment step, what must you state, and why does the Unit 1 lab say this is where arguments go wrong?
Check your answer
Answer: You must state the criteria (imitational, formal, expressive or functional) and apply them fairly to the work’s purpose. Arguments go wrong because people judge by criteria they have not named.Standard Re9.HSII also asks whether the criteria others use are relevant.
Researching an Artist’s Style: A Posada Print Described, Worked in Full, a Recorded Presentation Plan and a Menu of Verified Artists
Cleveland Museum of Art Open Access records 2000.97, 1983.10, 1963.1; Art Institute of Chicago records 11052, 24645, 150773, 121377, 253744, 93903 (retrieved 26 September 2026); Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art record 54-9 (George Caleb Bingham, Canvassing for a Vote), retrieved 10 November 2026 · SLS original (worked analysis, criticism model, presentation plan); CC0 (museum data)
Why this reading. The lab asks you to choose an artist, study their style under five headings, record a three-minute criticism of one work, and make a claim about the artist’s impact, and it uses José Guadalupe Posada as its worked example without giving you the print. You need three things: the Posada print described closely enough to check the worked analysis against; a complete four-step criticism of it to model your own; and, if you have no artist in mind, a menu of artists with verified records and one fact for each of the five headings, so you can start from something real. Museum data is CC0 (Cleveland Museum of Art 2000.97; Art Institute of Chicago records; retrieved 26 September 2026). The style sheet, criticism model and presentation plan are SLS original.
The Posada print: records and a description
| Work | Record |
|---|---|
| José Guadalupe Posada (Mexican, 1852-1913), The Skeleton of the Buses (La Calavera de los Camiones) | c. 1900-10, Mexico; relief etching and letterpress; sheet 39.4 x 29.3 cm (15 1/2 x 11 9/16 in.); Cleveland Museum of Art, 2000.97 (CC0) |
| José Guadalupe Posada, ¡Terrible y verdadera noticia! (Terrible and Real News!) | 1910; relief engraving or photo relief etching on tan wove paper; image 24.8 x 16.2 cm (9 3/4 x 6 7/16 in.); Art Institute of Chicago, 1959.526 (public domain; I could not view this image, so the record is all I report) |
The Cleveland sheet, in words. A single sheet printed in black on tan paper, in the format of a broadside (a cheap news sheet). Across the top, the title La Calavera de los Camiones in large decorative capital letters, framed in the top corners by floral ornaments. Below it, an illustration fills about a third of the sheet: at the left a giant skeleton leans forward with one arm stretched toward the right, standing behind a heaped mound of skulls; at the right a streetcar loaded with small passengers moves toward the pile; behind are trees, a wall and a gateway. Under the picture is a two-line caption, and the lower half of the sheet is set in four narrow columns of verse in letterpress. Value: almost pure black on tan, with dense parallel lines for shading and clear white shapes for the skulls. Scale: the skeleton is many times larger than the passengers. The Cleveland Museum’s description: a number of twentieth-century Mexican artists admired Posada for reaching a broad public through striking imagery and inexpensively printed works; he combined image and text about social and political issues so they were accessible to workers, many of whom were illiterate; this print is part of a series in which he used skeletons to comment humorously on current events, such as the danger of electric trams in Mexico City. A streetcar delivers passengers to the figure of Death, who beckons them forward, suggesting that the graveyard where he stands is an inevitable stop on their journey.
The five headings, worked out for Posada (SLS original, checked against the record and the print)
| Heading | Posada |
|---|---|
| Subject | News, disasters, crimes, politics, and calaveras, skeletons dressed and acting like the living; here, a streetcar delivering passengers to Death |
| Formal language | Strong black-and-white contrast; dense parallel-line shading; lively, energetic line; figures in motion; crowded compositions (a heap of skulls); large display lettering and ornamental corners |
| Materials and technique | Relief etching (a design bitten into metal so the raised lines print) and letterpress, on cheap tan paper; both are relief processes, which is why picture and type can share one press |
| Scale and presentation | A sheet of about 39 x 29 cm, sold as a broadside; the image is one third of the page and the text the rest |
| Ideas | Popular news and satire for a wide audience, including readers who could not read (Cleveland); death as the great equalizer |
A complete four-step criticism (SLS original; about 300 words)
Description. A tan broadside, 39.4 x 29.3 cm, printed in black. A large title in decorative capitals crowns the sheet. In the illustration a giant skeleton at left leans forward, one arm stretched toward a streetcar at right that carries small passengers toward a mound of skulls. Beneath are a caption and four columns of verse.
Analysis. The skeleton is the largest and most detailed figure and holds the eye first through scale and through the sharp contrast of white bone against dark ground. Its outstretched arm points along a diagonal to the streetcar, so the eye travels left to right, from Death to the victims. The round skulls in the heap repeat one shape many times, which makes a rhythm and a feeling of crowding. Dense parallel lines give shade, so everything stays in black and white with no gray wash.
Interpretation. The picture jokes about the danger of electric trams by having Death himself run the route: the museum reads the graveyard as an inevitable stop on the passengers’ journey. Evidence: the skeleton beckons, the tram is full, and the pile of skulls suggests earlier passengers. Context: the sheet is cheap, printed with verse, and sold for a wide public; the joke and the warning are meant to be understood by people who read by looking.
Judgment. By functional criteria the print works very well: it combines an unmistakable image with text on an inexpensive sheet, exactly what the museum says reached a broad public. By formal criteria the contrast and diagonal make it clear at a glance. By imitational criteria it is a fantasy, so that standard does not apply. I judge it strong on functional and formal grounds.
Impact claim and evidence (the lesson’s final requirement): Posada shaped how later artists thought about reaching ordinary people. Evidence: Cleveland states that a number of twentieth-century Mexican artists admired him for exactly that.
Recorded presentation plan (3 minutes, about 390 words at a speaking pace)
| Time | What you do |
|---|---|
| 0:00 to 0:20 | Name, dates, place or community; show one representative work on a slide (a link or a public-domain image; describe in-copyright work in words) |
| 0:20 to 1:40 | The four steps applied to that work: describe (20 sec), analyze (25 sec), interpret (20 sec), judge with named criteria (15 sec) |
| 1:40 to 2:30 | Your five-heading style summary: one sentence per heading |
| 2:30 to 3:00 | One claim about the artist’s impact and one piece of evidence; sources named |
If you have no artist yet: a menu with verified records
Each row is an artist whose work is in a museum collection with an online record, with one checked fact per heading. Use these as seeds, then find more on the object page.
| Artist and record | Subject | Formal language | Materials | Scale | Ideas |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Katsushika Hokusai, Under the Wave off Kanagawa, 1830/33 (Art Institute of Chicago, 1925.3245) | Mount Fuji seen near and far in weather and seasons | Crisp outlines, flat blues, big curving diagonals | Color woodblock print, Berlin blue | 25.4 x 37.6 cm | The mountain is the protagonist of each scene (AIC) |
| Ogata Kōrin, Plum Tree, c. 1700 (Cleveland, 1983.10) | A plum tree in blossom | Bold simplified shapes; angular black trunk; unpainted white flowers | Ink on silk; reserve technique | Image 94 x 35.4 cm | Effect made by what is left unpainted (Cleveland) |
| Kurt Schwitters, Little Dance, 1920 (Cleveland, 1963.1) | Scraps of daily life | Overlapping angled scraps; printed letters and numbers as shapes; red accents | Found paper collage | 13.1 x 10.4 cm | Interaction of the materials becomes a dance (Cleveland) |
| Georges Seurat, Seated Woman with a Parasol, 1884/85 (AIC, 1999.7) | Figures at leisure | Silhouettes without outlines; dark against light | Black Conté crayon | 48 x 31.5 cm | A study that fixes a figure’s contour |
| Arthur Wesley Dow, Boats at Rest, c. 1895 (AIC, 1990.394) | Boats on a New England shore | Cropping, high viewpoint, flattened space | Oil on canvas | 66 x 91.4 cm | Japanese-print design applied to a local scene (AIC) |
| Romare Bearden, Gray Interior, 1969 (AIC, 2020.29; in copyright) | Interior scenes; figures | Composed of cut printed papers with graphite and incising | Collage on paperboard laid on wood | 52.5 x 67.9 cm | Reworking of familiar scenes, as in his Return of Odysseus (AIC 1977.127) |
| George Caleb Bingham (American, 1811-1879), Canvassing for a Vote, 1852 (Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art, Kansas City, 54-9) | Missouri political life, set in his hometown of Arrow Rock (Nelson-Atkins) | A politician and three potential voters in a solid pyramid at the center; a low horizon and clouds | Oil on canvas | 64.14 x 77.47 cm | Faith in democracy alongside its shortcomings: a sleeping dog and a man with his back turned may suggest disinterested citizens (Nelson-Atkins) |
To research any other artist, use the open-access collection search of the Art Institute of Chicago, the Cleveland Museum of Art, the Metropolitan Museum of Art or Smithsonian Open Access, or the online collections of Missouri’s Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art and Saint Louis Art Museum (these are tools: they take an artist’s name and show records). Write down the accession number and the rights status of anything you use.
Style and ethics: a working rule
Credit the artist by name on the object. Transform, do not copy. If a design comes from a living community and the museum record or a community source says that it is sacred, ceremonial or owned by a family or clan, do not use it; choose another artist. If you choose a living artist, study their work on their own site or a museum’s page and describe it in words; do not reproduce it.
The self-review sheet
Watch your recording the next day and write: (1) one thing that was clear in the four steps; (2) whether the five-heading summary named a combination and not just one trick; (3) whether the impact claim had evidence; (4) one question a viewer might still have. Two stars and a wish is a good shape: two things that worked, one thing to change. If a step is missing or unclear, re-record that section. Optional: play it for a family member and ask what they learned about the artist; compare their answer with your impact claim.
Sources: Cleveland Museum of Art, The Skeleton of the Buses (Posada), 2000.97 (clevelandart.org); Art Institute of Chicago, Terrible and Real News (Posada), 1959.526 (artic.edu); Art Institute of Chicago, Under the Wave off Kanagawa, 1925.3245 (artic.edu); Cleveland Museum of Art, Plum Tree, 1983.10 (clevelandart.org); Cleveland Museum of Art, Little Dance, 1963.1 (clevelandart.org); Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art, Canvassing for a Vote (George Caleb Bingham), 54-9 (art.nelson-atkins.org)