
apply the four steps of art criticism to an unfamiliar work, and construct and defend a judgment based on criteria I can state.
Instruction
Everyone has opinions about art. Criticism is what turns an opinion into a judgment someone else can test. This course uses a criticism model of description, analysis, interpretation and judgment, and asks you to rank works and defend the ranking. This lab does that with four works from four different traditions, chosen so that you cannot fall back on a single idea of what “good art” looks like.
Step 1: Description. Say what is there, without judging it. Subject, medium, size if given, and the visible facts: colors, shapes, lines, textures. Use the museum’s object page for the medium and date. A good description is one another person could use to find the work in a room of similar works. Resist words like “beautiful” or “messy”; they belong to step 4.
Step 2: Analysis. Explain how the parts are organized. Which elements dominate and which are subordinate? Where does the eye go first, and what leads it there? How are balance, rhythm, emphasis and unity achieved? Analysis answers how the work does what it does.
Step 3: Interpretation. Propose what the work means or expresses, and support the proposal with evidence from steps 1 and 2 and from context. Context includes who made it, for whom, and for what purpose. An interpretation is a claim, so it can be wrong; it must be plausible and supported, not simply felt.
Step 4: Judgment. Decide how successful the work is, and say by which criteria. This is where most arguments about art go wrong, because people judge by criteria they have not named. There are at least four families of criteria. Imitational criteria value accurate representation. Formal criteria value the organization of elements and principles. Expressive criteria value the communication of feeling or idea. Functional criteria value how well the work serves its purpose, including ceremonial, social or practical purposes. A work can score low on one and high on another.
The four works. You will rank these, using the object pages:
- Katsushika Hokusai, Under the Wave off Kanagawa (The Great Wave), color woodblock print, 1830/33 (Art Institute of Chicago).
- A Tlingit weaver, Ceremonial Garment (Naaxein), or Chilkat Blanket, late 1800s, cedar bark and mountain goat hair (Cleveland Museum of Art).
- Luster Wall Tile with a Couple, Kashan, Iran, 1266, fritware with luster-painted design (Cleveland Museum of Art).
- Gustave Caillebotte, Paris Street; Rainy Day, oil on canvas, 1877 (Art Institute of Chicago).
Why the ranking is hard. By imitational criteria the Caillebotte may win. By formal criteria the Chilkat garment, built from a strict system of shapes, has a strong claim. By functional criteria the garment and the tile were made to serve ceremonial and architectural purposes that the painting does not share. The point of the exercise is not to reach the “right” order. It is to discover that your ranking depends on your criteria, to state them, and to see whether they are fair to works made for purposes other than hanging in a gallery.
Changing your mind. A good critic forms a position and then changes or defends it after meeting other arguments. When your ranking is done, read the three counter-rankings in this lesson’s dossier, each built on a different family of criteria. If you can, also ask a family member or other adult to rank the four works and explain one choice. If an argument persuades you, change your ranking and say why. Changing your mind for a reason is a strength in criticism, not a loss.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which sentence belongs to the description step?
A student ranks the Chilkat garment last because it is “not realistic.” What is the best critique of this judgment?
After reading the three counter-rankings (and any ranking a family member gave you), did you change your ranking? Write 4-6 sentences naming the argument that moved you, or the argument you rejected and why.
How confident are you that you can use description, analysis, interpretation and judgment and defend a judgment by naming my criteria?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Name the four steps of art criticism in order and state the question each answers.
Check your answer
Answer: Description (what is there?), analysis (how are the parts organized?), interpretation (what does it mean or express?), judgment (how successful is it, and by which criteria?).Description avoids judging words like “beautiful” or “messy”; those belong to judgment. - Name the four families of criteria and what each values.
Check your answer
Answer: Imitational (accurate representation), formal (organization of elements and principles), expressive (communication of feeling or idea), functional (how well the work serves its purpose, including ceremonial, social or practical purposes).A work can score low on one family and high on another. - Label each sentence as description, analysis, interpretation or judgment: (a) “The tile is an eight-pointed star with a cream glaze.” (b) “The symmetry of the garment draws the eye to the central face.” (c) “The wave stands for the power of nature over people.” (d) “By formal criteria the garment is the strongest of the four.”
Check your answer
Answer: (a) description; (b) analysis; (c) interpretation; (d) judgment.(d) is a well-formed judgment because it names its criteria.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- Use the dossier’s scoring method. Your weights: formal 3, expressive 3, functional 2, imitational 2 (they add to 10). You score the Chilkat garment formal 4, expressive 3, functional 4, imitational 1. What is its total out of 40?
Check your answer
Answer: 31 out of 40.3×4 + 3×3 + 2×4 + 2×1 = 12 + 9 + 8 + 2 = 31. The maximum possible is 4 x (3+3+2+2) = 40. - Critic A weights imitational 4, formal 2, expressive 2, functional 2 and ranks Caillebotte first and the Chilkat garment last. State the strongest objection to this ranking.
Check your answer
Answer: Imitation is not a fair main standard for a garment and a tile that were never meant to imitate; the garment was made to be worn on ceremonial occasions and the tile to be part of a wall, so formal and functional criteria give a fairer account.The objection is not that Caillebotte is weak, but that the criteria do not suit the other works’ purposes. - Write one interpretation sentence about Hokusai’s The Great Wave that is a claim supported by visual evidence, not only a feeling.
Check your answer
Answer: Model: “The print suggests that nature dwarfs human effort, because the huge wave curls over three small boats and even Mount Fuji appears tiny beneath its arch.”A strong interpretation states a claim and points to visible evidence from description and analysis (scale of the wave, the boats, the small Fuji). - Explain why the lesson calls changing your ranking after reading the counter-rankings “a strength in criticism, not a loss.”
Check your answer
Answer: A good critic forms a position and then tests it against other arguments. Changing your mind because an argument persuaded you, and saying why, shows the judgment rests on reasons that can be tested.The goal is not the “right” order but discovering that the ranking depends on stated criteria.
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- Show how a change of weights alone can reverse a ranking. Work X scores imitational 4, formal 2; work Y scores imitational 1, formal 4 (other families equal). Compare totals with weights (imitational 4, formal 1) and then (imitational 1, formal 4), counting only these two families.
Check your answer
Answer: Weights (4, 1): X = 4×4 + 1×2 = 18, Y = 4×1 + 1×4 = 8, so X ranks first. Weights (1, 4): X = 1×4 + 4×2 = 12, Y = 1×1 + 4×4 = 17, so Y ranks first.Same works, same scores, opposite order: the ranking depends on the criteria, which is the finding of the lab.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Review (Lesson 1.2): in an analysis of Paris Street; Rainy Day, which two tools from the value-and-edge lab would you look for to explain where the eye goes first?
Check your answer
Answer: Value contrast (the strongest light-dark difference) and edge (the hardest edges). The eye goes to hard edges and strong contrast first.Analysis asks how the work does what it does; value and edge control are the first tools of dominance.
Four Works to Rank: Records, Descriptions, Purposes and a Criteria Sheet
Art Institute of Chicago object records 24645, 20684 and 27992; Cleveland Museum of Art Open Access records 1981.69 and 1915.524 (retrieved 26 September 2026); Burke Museum, “Unpacking a phrase: The Chilkat blanket” · CC0 (museum data); SLS original (descriptions, criteria sheet, worked criticism)
Why this reading. The lab asks you to rank four works from four traditions and defend the ranking with named criteria. You cannot rank what you cannot see, and no one should rank by a thumbnail. Here are the four object records, a careful description of each in the vocabulary of the lab (composition, value, color, edges, scale), what the museums themselves say each object was for, a criteria sheet, three counter-rankings to test yours against, and one complete worked criticism of a fifth work so you can see all four moves done. Museum data is CC0; descriptions were written by looking at museum-released images; the worked criticism, the ranking sheet and the counter-rankings are SLS original. Records retrieved 26 September 2026.
The four records
| Work | Date and place | Medium and size | Museum and accession |
|---|---|---|---|
| Katsushika Hokusai, Under the Wave off Kanagawa (Kanagawa oki nami ura), also known as The Great Wave, from the series Thirty-Six Views of Mount Fuji. Publisher: Nishimura-ya Yohachi | 1830/33, Japan | Color woodblock print, oban format, 25.4 x 37.6 cm (10 x 14 3/4 in.) | Art Institute of Chicago, 1925.3245 (public domain) |
| Tlingit maker (unnamed), Ceremonial Garment (Naaxein), also called a Chilkat blanket | Late 1800s, Northwest Coast of North America | Weft twining: cedar bark wrapped with mountain goat hair; 137.8 x 175.3 cm (54 1/4 x 69 in.) | Cleveland Museum of Art, 1981.69 (CC0) |
| Luster Wall Tile with a Couple, Kashan, Iran, Ilkhanid period (1256-1353) | 1266 | Fritware with luster-painted design; about 19.5 x 16 cm (7 11/16 x 6 5/16 in.) | Cleveland Museum of Art, 1915.524 (CC0) |
| Gustave Caillebotte, Paris Street; Rainy Day | 1877, France | Oil on canvas, 212.2 x 276.2 cm (83 1/2 x 108 3/4 in.) | Art Institute of Chicago, 1964.336 (public domain) |
The four works, in words
Hokusai, The Great Wave. A landscape-format print a little bigger than a sheet of letter paper (25.4 x 37.6 cm). Composition: a huge wave enters from the left and curls over the center, its crest breaking into claw-like fingers of white foam; below it a deep trough and a second, lower swell sweep toward the right. Under the arch of the wave, at center right, a small snow-capped Mount Fuji sits low on the horizon; measured on a reproduction it is only about one-ninth of the print’s width. Long, narrow boats crowded with rowers, drawn as rows of tiny round heads, ride the swells: one at lower center, one at right, and one half swallowed by the wave at left (the AIC’s alt text counts two ships; count for yourself). Value and color: deep blue and lighter blue against cream-white foam, a small area of yellow on the boat hulls, a pale pink and cream sky in the impression I viewed, and a gray-brown gradient of sky around Fuji. Edges: crisp dark-blue contour lines around the wave and flat fields of color inside them; the spray is a scatter of white dots. A title and signature box sits at the top left. The AIC notes that the series made abundant use of the newly affordable Berlin blue pigment, and that its three impressions of this design are all later than the first state; colors therefore differ from impression to impression.
The Chilkat garment. A five-sided form, wide across the top and tapering to a point at the bottom, with a long natural-colored fringe hanging from the sides and lower edge. The Cleveland Museum’s own description: “A black border frames a yellow field filled with symmetrical designs in black and cream. At the center, a large face is flanked by panels of eyes and geometric forms outlined in bold black.” Composition: strictly symmetrical left to right; the large central face, with a mouth showing a row of teeth, is the focal point, with paired eye shapes above and beside it. Value and color: three colors in the woven field (black, yellow, cream) plus the natural tan of the fringe, each in flat areas with no shading. Edges: hard, continuous, swelling and narrowing black outlines called formlines separate every shape. Scale: about 1.4 by 1.75 meters, larger than a bath towel, and made to be worn over the shoulders.
The Kashan tile. An eight-pointed star, small enough to hold in one hand, with a cream glaze. In the central field two haloed figures sit side by side, a bearded man at left and a smooth-faced figure with long dark hair at right; between them rises a slender turquoise tree, and a small blue bird sits at each side. The Cleveland Museum’s record calls it a couple with a wine beaker surrounded by verses of Iranian love poetry. Value and color: lustrous brown-black lines on cream, with cobalt blue and turquoise as accents; the ground behind the figures is a dense field of small spirals and dots, so the two faces, left plain, are the lightest areas. Edges: thin, even, painted lines; a cobalt rim; a band of script following the outline of the star. The museum says the design shows it was part of wall decoration and would have alternated with cross-shaped tiles.
Caillebotte, Paris Street; Rainy Day. A life-size wet street scene. A green lamppost divides the canvas about in half; just to its right a couple in dark clothing under one umbrella walk toward the viewer, and they are the darkest and sharpest forms. Left of the post a cream apartment block recedes to a distant corner; the cobbled street is small pink and gray marks with reflections. Value: darkest in the lower right (about 11 percent of the canvas is very dark), lightest at upper left. Color: restrained grays with one green and one pink-red accent. Edges: sharp near the couple, soft in the distance.
What the museums say each object was for
| Object | What the museum’s own record says |
|---|---|
| Hokusai print | The AIC describes the series as a tour-de-force that established the popularity of landscape prints. (The lesson notes that a print is a multiple; several impressions exist.) |
| Chilkat garment | The Burke Museum in Seattle writes that these garments were worn by noble women and men, particularly chiefs, on extraordinary ceremonial occasions, and that the fringe swirls as the wearer dances. The Cleveland record gives the materials and technique; it names no individual weaver. |
| Kashan tile | Cleveland: part of a wall decoration that alternated with cross-shaped tiles, so each tile was made to be seen as one piece of a larger surface. |
| Caillebotte painting | The AIC: a large, ambitious picture of modern urban life that the artist showed with the Impressionists, in a more Realist technique; it calls it his largest work. |
The four moves, and a criteria sheet for the fourth
Describe, analyze, interpret, judge. Step 4 is where arguments go wrong, because people judge by criteria they have not named. Write down your criteria as families, then weight them before you look at any ranking.
| Criteria family | Question you ask the work | Evidence you can point to |
|---|---|---|
| Imitational | How faithfully does it record what the eye sees? | Proportion, perspective, light and texture that match observation |
| Formal | How well are the elements and principles organized? | Balance, emphasis, rhythm, unity, contrast of value and edge |
| Expressive | How strongly does it communicate a feeling or idea? | Choices of color, scale, cropping and gesture that carry mood or meaning |
| Functional | How well does it do the job it was made for? | The museum’s statement of purpose: ceremony, wall decoration, mass circulation, exhibition |
Scoring method (SLS original). Give each family a weight from 0 to 4, with the weights adding to 10. Score each work 1 (weak) to 4 (strong) in each family. Multiply, add, and rank by total. The arithmetic is not the argument; it forces you to say which family you are relying on. If your ranking changes when you change a weight, that is the finding of the lab.
Worked example on a fifth work. Weights chosen for the demonstration: formal 4, expressive 3, imitational 1, functional 2. Scores for Seurat’s A Sunday on La Grande Jatte (invented to show the arithmetic): formal 4, expressive 3, imitational 2, functional 2. Total = 4×4 + 3×3 + 1×2 + 2×2 = 16 + 9 + 2 + 4 = 31 out of 40. A critic who weighted imitational 4, formal 1, expressive 3 and functional 2 would score the same work 1×4 + 3×3 + 4×2 + 2×2 = 4 + 9 + 8 + 4 = 25 out of 40. Same picture, same scores, different total. State your weights.
One complete criticism (SLS original; all facts from the AIC record and the image)
Work: Georges Seurat, A Sunday on La Grande Jatte – 1884, 1884-86, border added 1888-89, oil on canvas, 207.5 x 308.1 cm, Art Institute of Chicago, 1926.224.
1. Description. A very wide canvas, nearly 3 by 2 meters. On a riverbank park, a crowd of people of different ages sit, stand and walk on grass, the men in top hats, caps or straw hats and the women in long dresses with bustles. The figures are stiff and mostly in profile or seen from behind. A dark dog sniffs the grass at the center, a small monkey on a leash stands beside the tall woman at right, and sailboats sit on blue water at upper left. The AIC notes that, close up, forms dissolve into dots and dashes of complementary colors placed side by side; a border of dots in red and blue was added in 1888-89.
2. Analysis. Long shadows fall across the lawn in horizontal bands, alternating dark green with sunlit yellow-green, so the eye moves in stripes from front to back. The tallest verticals, the woman and man at right and the tree trunks, are set against these horizontals. The tall pair at right is the largest and darkest group and holds the eye first; the small white-dressed child at the center is the brightest note. Edges are firm and simplified; figures look cut out.
3. Interpretation. The AIC describes the picture as showing people of every age and social class on the banks of the Seine. The stiffness and repetition of the figures make the crowd read less as a gathering than as a pattern, which suggests that the painter is interested in modern leisure as a structure, seen from outside, rather than in any one person’s story. The evidence is the identical profile poses and the way each figure occupies its own island of shade or light.
4. Judgment. By formal criteria the picture is very strong: the dot technique gives the whole surface a shimmering unity and the horizontals and verticals are balanced. By imitational criteria it is uneven, because the figures do not look like people caught in motion. By functional criteria it did what a large exhibition picture must do, which is hold a wall from across a room. I rate it highly on formal and functional grounds, and I say plainly that on imitational grounds another viewer could rate it lower.
Ranking log
Copy this into your notes. Round 1: weights (four numbers adding to 10); the four totals; the order. Round 2, after reading the counter-rankings below (and any ranking a family member gives you): which argument moved you (name the critic and the claim), which you rejected and why, the new order, and the weight you changed, if any.
Three counter-rankings to test yours against (SLS original)
Each critic below is invented to model a position; none is a quotation. Each uses the scoring method above, with weights adding to 10.
Critic A: imitational 4, formal 2, expressive 2, functional 2. Order: Caillebotte, Hokusai, Kashan tile, Chilkat garment. Claim: the street, the wet cobblestones and the walking couple look as they would to someone standing on that corner, and no other work tries as hard to show a moment as it looked. Test it: is imitation a fair standard for a garment and a tile that were never meant to imitate?
Critic B: functional 4, formal 3, expressive 2, imitational 1. Order: Chilkat garment, Kashan tile, Hokusai, Caillebotte. Claim: the garment was made to be worn by noble women and men, particularly chiefs, on extraordinary ceremonial occasions, and its strict system of shapes does that work; the star tile was made to repeat across a wall with cross-shaped tiles and still reward close looking; the painting was made only to hang. Test it: does ranking the painting last ignore what an exhibition picture is for?
Critic C: formal 4, expressive 4, imitational 1, functional 1. Order: Hokusai, Chilkat garment, Caillebotte, Kashan tile. Claim: the claw-like foam and the tiny snowy Fuji under the wave’s arch make the strongest contrast of size in the four works, and the threat of the wave is felt before it is understood. Test it: does a low functional weight undervalue a print made as an affordable multiple?
Sources: Art Institute of Chicago, Under the Wave off Kanagawa, 1925.3245 (artic.edu); Cleveland Museum of Art, Ceremonial Garment (Naaxein), 1981.69 (clevelandart.org); Cleveland Museum of Art, Luster Wall Tile with a Couple, 1915.524 (clevelandart.org); Art Institute of Chicago, Paris Street; Rainy Day, 1964.336 (artic.edu); Art Institute of Chicago, A Sunday on La Grande Jatte, 1926.224 (artic.edu); Burke Museum, Unpacking a phrase: The Chilkat blanket (burkemuseum.org)