
write equilibrium constant expressions and use K and Q to predict shifts, then set prioritized criteria and constraints and evaluate design options for the co-op’s packaging and indicator.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. List every lever you now know for slowing peroxide decomposition in a bottle. Star the two you think the co-op can actually control.
For Fe3+ + SCN− ⇌ FeSCN2+, which is the equilibrium constant expression?
Putting a number on equilibrium. For a reaction aA + bB ⇌ cC + dD, the equilibrium constant is K = [C]c[D]d ÷ ([A]a[B]b), using molar concentrations at equilibrium. Water that is the solvent, and pure solids, are left out. A large K (much more than 1) means products dominate at equilibrium; a small K means reactants do. At a fixed temperature K is constant: add or remove a substance and the mixture shifts until the ratio returns to K. Changing the temperature changes K itself.
Worked example 1: finding K. Priya mixed solutions so that [Fe3+] started at 0.0050 M and [SCN−] at 0.0010 M. A colorimeter gave [FeSCN2+] = 0.00040 M at equilibrium (sample data). Each FeSCN2+ uses one of each ion, so [Fe3+] = 0.0050 − 0.00040 = 0.0046 M and [SCN−] = 0.0010 − 0.00040 = 0.00060 M. K = 0.00040 ÷ (0.0046 × 0.00060) = 0.00040 ÷ (2.76 × 10−6) ≈ 1.4 × 102.
Worked example 2: Q tells you which way. The reaction quotient Q uses the same expression with the concentrations right now. Priya then doubled [Fe3+] to 0.0092 M in an instant. Q = 0.00040 ÷ (0.0092 × 0.00060) ≈ 72. Q < K, so there is too little product for equilibrium: the forward reaction outpaces the reverse until Q rises back to K. That is Le Chatelier’s principle in numbers. (Q > K would mean a shift left.)
The indicator’s equilibrium. For [Co(H2O)6]2+ + 4Cl− ⇌ [CoCl4]2− + 6H2O in water, K = [CoCl42−] ÷ ([Co(H2O)62+][Cl−]4). Because the forward reaction is endothermic, K grows as temperature rises, so warming makes the mixture bluer. That is what lets a sealed vial work as a storage-check warning. Chloride appears to the fourth power, so a modest change in chloride has a big effect on Q.
Class criteria and constraints (sample values set by the class with the co-op). Cleaner: (1) after the class 7-day hot-box test (a lamp-lit box at 35 °C, a stand-in for months of poor storage), a 5.0 mL sample must still release at least 48 mL of oxygen with excess yeast, which is 90% of the 53 mL a fresh sample releases at 22 °C; (2) it must still act fast on a surface: initial rate at least 0.60 mL/s with 2.0 mL of yeast suspension; (3) cost at most 10 sample budget points per bottle; (4) nothing added that is unsafe on food-contact surfaces; (5) recyclable packaging. Storage-check indicator: (6) clearly pink at 25 °C or below and clearly blue at 30 °C or above; (7) reverses at least 10 times; (8) cobalt fully sealed with no way for a user to touch it; (9) cost at most 3 points.
Generating options. Cleaner: (A) brown, light-blocking recyclable plastic bottle; (B) clear bottle with storage advice on the label; (C) a small amount of a stabilizer that binds stray metal ions (stops them catalyzing decomposition); (D) smaller bottles used up sooner; (E) a vented cap so built-up oxygen cannot strain the bottle. Indicator: (1) a sealed cobalt chloride vial in a plastic blister on a shelf card; (2) a cobalt chloride paper humidity card; (3) a printed liquid-crystal temperature strip; (4) a cobalt-free dye card.
Worked example 3: a weighted decision matrix. Ji-woo’s team weighted criteria safety ×3, hot-box strength ×3, surface speed ×2, cost ×1, recyclability ×1, and scored options 1–3 (sample scores). Brown bottle (A): 3, 2, 3, 2, 3 → 9 + 6 + 6 + 2 + 3 = 26. Stabilizer (C): 2, 3, 2, 3, 3 → 6 + 9 + 4 + 3 + 3 = 25. Clear bottle with advice (B): 3, 1, 3, 3, 3 → 9 + 3 + 6 + 3 + 3 = 24. The scores are close, which told the team that combining A with some of C might beat either alone. For the indicator they ruled out option 2: it responds to humidity, not temperature, so it fails criterion 6.
Work as a team; each member answers in their own notebook.
Build version 1 of both designs.
Complete your team's decision matrix for at least three cleaner options and three indicator options. Choose version 1 of each and explain the choice in a paragraph that names one trade-off.
Write the K expression for the cobalt system and explain, using Q, why adding chloride makes the vial turn blue at a lower temperature.
Version 1 is chosen. Next class we test it against every criterion and refine it.
Exit ticket: which criterion is your version 1 most likely to fail, and what evidence would tell you?
Materials: decision-matrix templates, the criteria card, sample bottles (brown, white, clear), a sealed cobalt vial in a blister for display only, calculators.
Setup: start the 7-day hot-box test today with each team’s version 1 bottle (a cardboard box with a desk lamp and thermometer held near 35 °C); the readings are used in 2.08. If time is short, use the sample results in 2.08.
Listen for: “K changes when you add more”; Q and K reversed; criteria scored without reasons.
Support / stretch: a K-expression frame (products on top, exponents = coefficients, leave out solvent water). Stretch: show that halving [Cl−] in the cobalt system multiplies Q by 16, and say which way the color moves.