
use energy diagrams and the spread of molecular speeds to explain, at the molecular level, why temperature, concentration, surface area and catalysts change reaction rates, and revise our model of the foam and the window bottle.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Draw your first model of the foam and the window bottle from 2.01 again from memory. Circle one part your rate data from 2.03 and 2.04 would make you change.
Warming peroxide from 22 °C to 35 °C raised the rate. Which statement explains it best?
The energy hill. Even a reaction that releases energy must first get over a hill. Breaking the O–O bond in peroxide costs energy before new bonds pay it back. The minimum collision energy needed to start the reaction is the activation energy, Ea. An energy diagram plots energy against reaction progress: reactants on the left, a peak, products on the right, lower than the reactants by 196 kJ for 2H2O2 → 2H2O + O2. The peak height above the reactants is Ea.
Not every molecule moves at the same speed. At any temperature, molecules have a spread of kinetic energies: many near the average, a few very slow and a few very fast. Only the fast tail of that spread has enough energy, at a collision, to get over the hill. Raise the temperature and the whole spread shifts toward higher energy and flattens, so the share of molecules in the tail beyond Ea grows a lot. Many reactions near room temperature roughly double in rate for every 10 °C rise, a rule of thumb, not a law.
Orientation. Energy is not quite enough. The molecules must also meet in a suitable orientation, the right atoms facing each other. That is one reason enzymes are so effective: catalase holds a peroxide molecule in just the position that lets its O–O bond break easily.
Four levers, one model. Concentration: more molecules per mL means more collisions per second; the share that succeed stays the same. Surface area: more exposed solid means more places where collisions with the surface can happen. Temperature: more collisions per second and, much more important, a larger share above Ea. Catalyst: an alternative pathway with a lower hill, so a larger share of ordinary collisions succeed at the same temperature. A catalyst does not change the energy of the reactants or products, so ΔH stays −196 kJ. Light is a fifth lever for peroxide: an ultraviolet photon can deliver enough energy to break an O–O bond without any collision.
Worked example 1: the shelf data, explained. Rafael compared the co-op’s sample shelf data: the 20 °C closet lost 4% in 6 months, the 35 °C cabinet 16%. That is 16 ÷ 4 = 4 times the loss for a 15 °C rise. The rule of thumb predicts about 21.5 ≈ 2.8 times, so the cabinet lost a little more than the rule suggests, which is reasonable for a rough rule. His explanation: at 35 °C a larger share of peroxide molecules collide with enough energy to break the O–O bond, so more decompose each day.
Worked example 2: reading an energy diagram. Hana drew two paths on one diagram, using illustrative values for the model (not measurements): the uncatalyzed path with a tall hill, and the catalase path with a much lower hill. Both start at the same reactant level and end at the same product level. She labeled Ea for each and ΔH once, and wrote: “Same start, same finish, lower hill: more molecules make it over each second.”
Why the yeast reaction is less temperature-sensitive. In 2.03 the yeast reaction sped up about 1.8 times for 13 °C, less than the rule suggests. With catalase the hill is already low, so most collisions with the enzyme already succeed; warming adds less. Uncatalyzed decomposition on the shelf, with its higher hill, is the one most sensitive to a warm garage.
Reading. OpenStax Chemistry 2e, chapters 12.5 (collision theory) and 12.7 (catalysis), CC BY 4.0.
Use the sim, or the paper histogram, then the model questions.
In your Rate Notebook.
Draw one energy diagram with an uncatalyzed path and a catalyzed path for peroxide decomposition. Label Ea for each, ΔH, reactants and products.
Write the co-op's first draft of storage advice: three rules, each with a one-sentence molecular reason (collisions, energy or photons).
One model now explains every lever. Next class we meet a new idea the indicator needs: reactions that run both ways.
Exit ticket: return to the Wonder Board. Pick one question we can now answer and answer it in two sentences.
Materials: devices for the PhET Gas Properties sim or printed 300 K / 400 K speed histograms with a threshold line, energy-diagram templates, the 2.03 and 2.04 data tables, the Wonder Board.
Note: the sim shows gas particles, not peroxide in solution; use it only for the shape of the speed spread. Avoid quoting textbook activation energies as facts unless you cite them; the diagram values here are illustrative.
Listen for: “the catalyst gives molecules more energy”; “heat makes molecules bigger”; concentration said to change collision energy.
Support / stretch: give a lever table (lever, more collisions?, more energetic collisions?, lower hill?). Stretch: use the rule of thumb to estimate how much faster the shelf reaction runs at 40 °C than at 5 °C (about 23.5 ≈ 11 times).